Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(04-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My issue with Bruce is I've simply seen nothing from him to suggest it'll improve in any way if he stays.
Last night's team selection can only be described as either lazy or moronic.
This is my biggest worry with him too.
I had hoped for some level of hope to be resurrected with his arrival, instead it's made a dismal season into a dire one. I'd given up on the Play offs back in December, but the levels of disunity across the board from fans to players are at levels I haven't seen before. Even back in the darkest days the fans were united, now there's in fighting and all sorts.
I really hoped that Bruce was this season's Moore, and if he had then I'd have taken that and moved into next season with some level of hope / belief. As it stands, I have no hopes for next year, and my expectations are that we'll be at Swansea like levels for a while... possibly lurching up or down depending on what the clowns in charge do.
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(04-19-2022, 10:58 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (04-19-2022, 09:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I do wonder though considering we almost all agree that the owners of the club have mishandled it appallingly since they bought it from Peace that there's an element of screaming fans who somehow expect Bruce to be a miracle worker, considering he's had no new players.
Both Gourlay and Bruce made it very clear that the expectation was promotion. You're seeking to defend someone who had made a club that was on a bad run worse, which was completely the opposite of what his remit is.
Unless they're lucky enough to be appointed just before a transfer window, new managers have to have the ability to make a difference with the players who are already at the club, rather than attempt to tread water until the next window arrives. With more than 1000 games under his belt, Bruce really ought to be able to make a difference to an existing squad.
That he hasn't made any difference at all results-wise and has made us worse in other respects has led me to believe that he shouldn't be entrusted with the summer transfer window or for us to have to put up with his bewildering team selections and lack of tactical nous in the early stages of next season. We need someone at the helm who's younger and has some oomph, charisma and guile if next season isn't to be a repeat of this one.
Very good post.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-19-2022, 10:45 AM)Peachy Wrote: (04-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My issue with Bruce is I've simply seen nothing from him to suggest it'll improve in any way if he stays.
Last night's team selection can only be described as either lazy or moronic.
Thats my issue Birdy.
The stories about his training methods, demotivated players and picking favourites that came out of his time at Newcastle were worrying and you have to say have been born out with us so far.
I understand he hasn't had a window and I was encouraged when he came out and said we need an overhaul but then to follow that up with bringing back the same players he'd just dropped and the resulting performance, it smacks of a man who doesn't really have a clue.
I've been advocating Bruce to stay simply because a new guy will need time to work out what he's got but I'm starting yo think it might be the better idea. Especially if Dyche is a live contender.
To be honest Peachy, I'd hang fire on that mindset as there's always a number of demotivated players not happy with the manager. Also Newcastle have delusions on another scale, which sadly will not become real as they've got their blood money.
I do think Dyche coming into the picture changes things considerably, as he seems a proper fit for the club.
In an ideal world I'd like it if Bruce has said he doesn't fancy it and Dyche has already been told it is his.
However, that might not be the case and I just believe we have to back Bruce's judgement, which is probably far better than anonymous folks on social media will say.
It's just uncertain times at Albion and time for a reset.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
04-19-2022, 11:14 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-19-2022, 11:24 AM by fuzzbox.)
It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.
It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!
(It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!)
This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.
People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time.
I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"
So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas. Too late, he's realised this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.
Except this is a highly paid professional.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-19-2022, 11:14 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.
It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!
It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!
This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.
People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time.
I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"
So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas now he realises this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.
A really well-formed post. You may be right. I hope you're not though.
If it is as you say, my guess is he will walk as he hasn't the hunger for it.
Posts: 13,258
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Everything he's said so far suggests that he really wants to stay
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(04-19-2022, 11:14 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.
It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!
(It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!)
This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.
People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time.
I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"
So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas. Too late, he's realised this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.
Except this is a highly paid professional.
Absolutely spot on.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(04-19-2022, 11:14 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.
It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!
(It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!)
This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.
People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time.
I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"
So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas. Too late, he's realised this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.
Except this is a highly paid professional.
Good post. Smacks of laziness in both the appointment and in Bruce himself.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(04-19-2022, 11:14 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.
It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!
(It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!)
This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.
People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time.
I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"
So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas. Too late, he's realised this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.
Except this is a highly paid professional.
You would think Mozza would be the first person Bruce would speak to, to get at least an overview and gist of what the position was at the club and in the dressing room. Maybe it was.
Posts: 945
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
Except that other than for the opening sentence this is all conjecture, not fact. I fully agree though that what we’ve seen makes it plausible, but that’s still not proof that proper due diligence wasn’t followed. You could just as easily argue that despite Bruce conducting some form of analysis beforehand the squad itself is so corrupt that it is past salvaging.
|