Ratings...
#1
Rushed back from Gatwick, haven’t slept in 36 hours, I needed that game.

So refreshing to see a manager make proactive changes and change a game before it’s lost. We changed system a couple of times and the players looked to know their jobs and positioning be it 442/4411/433, which is a credit to Shan and co.

But for some awful defending from a set piece and a foul for their second we’d have won that more clearly I feel, despite a slow first half.

Johnstone - 7 - going direct mixes it up and takes a lot of pressure off us. Couple crosses [font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]I felt he should have done better on, but looks more assured [/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Townsend - 5 - Gifted then a few chances early on, and didn’t look comfortable. Improved going forward second half.[/font][/font]
[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Hegazi - 9 - MOTM - Excellent again today - had he been on the pitch their second goal doesn’t go in. [/font][/font]
[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Dawson - 8 - Another solid performance, seems to be relishing being asked to just defend[/font][/font]
[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Holgate - 7 - Looked more composed today, should have buried a free header from a corner.[/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Brunt - 7 - excellent delivery, we really missed him this season, and is proving he’s still a class act. Seemed comfortable in a central midfield 3 and out wide.[/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Livermore - 5 - Brilliant winner, absolutely stunning goal,  but I thought he was our weakest link today. Ponderous, slow, gets turned far too easily, players get a run on him too easily[/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Morrison - 6 - thought our best play came through him first half but he just doesn’t carry the ball with the speed he used to and we don’t have the pace around him. [/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Edwards - 7 - some excellent individual runs, showing composure and intelligence. Everything Leko lacks, and unfortunate to come off but looked shot.[/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Gayle - 7 - lovely header for the goal, good movement, gave their defenders a lot of trouble and earned fouls for the team. [/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Rodriguez - 6.5 - the partnership with Gayle seems to be improving, and his running freed up space for us to play in. Brilliant penalty but needs to learn the goals are the same size from open play as they are for a penalty! [/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]—-[/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]HRK - 7 - changed the game, wins us so much territory further up the field. We miss Barnes ability to carry the ball up the field quickly, and given we struggle to build up play his directness is an outlet that gets us into dangerous positions.[/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Murphy - Not sure he touched the ball? [/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Shan - 9 - excellent changes, growing on me for the role... [/font][/font]

[font=.SF UI Text][font=.SFUIText]Ref - 3 - bloody awful... got so many big and small decisions wrong... [/font][/font]
Reply
#2
Agree by and large but 5 max for Edwards.
Reply
#3
5 harsh for Townsend . id go for a 6, otherwise i agree , good scores!
Reply
#4
I'd cut Dawson's rating to a 7, thought he was very iffy in the first half and was bailed out, not least by Edwards.
Reply
#5
Thought the ref had a good game, got all the major decisions correct as far as I could see.

My player marks

Johnstone 7
Holgate 7
Dawson 7
Hegazi 7
Townsend 6.5

Brunt 7
Livermore 5.5

Morrison 5.5
Edwards 6
Rodriguez 5.5 - takes a good penalty

Gayke 6.5

HRK 7

It wasn't a great performance, but second half picked up. Probably just about shaded it, once we got ahead the result was never in doubt and that maybe the difference, always felt we had a way back in the game even when they were in control and playing well.
Reply
#6
Decent write up sw4 but touch generous with those marks. That tequila will take a few days to wear off
Reply
#7
(03-29-2019, 10:56 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Decent write up sw4 but touch generous with those marks. That tequila will take a few days to wear off

I think after how crap we’ve been at home recently, a win and 3 goals deserves praise!

Not sure it’ll happen any time soon, my blood is 40% proof.
Reply
#8
You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.
Reply
#9
Johnstone 7

Holgate 6.5
Dawson 6.5
Hegazi 7
Townsend 7

Livermore 6.5
Brunt 6.5
Mozza 6 (HRK 7)

Edwards 7 (Murphy 5)
Rodriguez 6.5 (Bartley 6.5)
Gayle 6.5
Reply
#10
Livermore was at least an 8. Far more mobile tonight, very tidy. Kept his head with the shot and chased back all the way numerous times. He was absolutely swamped when he scored, looks like he's a very popular lad.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)