Bruce set for a squad overhaul
(04-14-2022, 10:04 AM)Squid Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 09:04 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Dike likes Bruce reading the interview on the Athletic.

Been very supportive, kept his motivation up. What you want from your manager.

He's not going to say otherwise though, is he? I do not doubt that Bruce is a lovely bloke but I'm still not convinced he's the best person to manage us next season. Our three previous managers are widely reputed to be very nice people too, it still didn't quite work out for us.

Well it's better than falling out with half the squad like a certain previous manager...
Reply
Having watched Bruce's career with interest over the years,  I am yet to see a "system" that lasts any longer than the first goal conceded.  I sincerely hope he proves me wrong. 

I lifted this from the Heroes and Villains thread when he was sacked by Villa

The Bruce problem was not a complex one.  He was a dullard who surrounded himself with dullards, his colleagues and his media connections.  By doing that his limitations were never properly exposed.  His appetite for spending his clubs' money to bring in random influxes of incorrectly evaluated players was enough to bump and grind teams to be, in his own words, there or thereabouts.  Eventually through laziness and over confidence in his own ability he even lost the ability to use his owners' money to buy performances that would deliver there or thereabouts.  That is the legacy of Steve Bruce.

Two years of profligate spending, players randomly bought, rented or disposed of, players binned off to Australia to achieve a pinnacle of fourth in the Championship and a play off of three games, two against Middlesborough and one against Fulham in which we never looked for one minute that we were going to achieve promotion.

His tenure as Aston Villa manager has been an object lesson in bungling, short sighted stupidity.  The only notable element of which was the number of people he convinced that it was ever acceptable.
Reply
(04-14-2022, 10:57 AM)Offside Wrote: Having watched Bruce's career with interest over the years,  I am yet to see a "system" that lasts any longer than the first goal conceded.  I sincerely hope he proves me wrong. 

I lifted this from the Heroes and Villains thread when he was sacked by Villa

The Bruce problem was not a complex one.  He was a dullard who surrounded himself with dullards, his colleagues and his media connections.  By doing that his limitations were never properly exposed.  His appetite for spending his clubs' money to bring in random influxes of incorrectly evaluated players was enough to bump and grind teams to be, in his own words, there or thereabouts.  Eventually through laziness and over confidence in his own ability he even lost the ability to use his owners' money to buy performances that would deliver there or thereabouts.  That is the legacy of Steve Bruce.

Two years of profligate spending, players randomly bought, rented or disposed of, players binned off to Australia to achieve a pinnacle of fourth in the Championship and a play off of three games, two against Middlesborough and one against Fulham in which we never looked for one minute that we were going to achieve promotion.

His tenure as Aston Villa manager has been an object lesson in bungling, short sighted stupidity.  The only notable element of which was the number of people he convinced that it was ever acceptable.

It looks like he is well matched to our owners ambitions, then.
Reply
It’s good to see Bruce putting his foot down. 8 or 9players have been told that they must move closer to the Hawthorns if they want to remain. Button has been told no new contract unless he moves from Brighton. He also says they earn enough so if they have to get an apartment so be it.
Reply
(04-14-2022, 11:24 AM)wba13 Wrote: It’s good to see Bruce putting his foot down. 8 or 9players have been told that they must move closer to the Hawthorns if they want to remain. Button has been told no new contract unless he moves from Brighton. He also says they earn enough so if they have to get an apartment so be it.

This is the point I've been trying to make.

Are there better coaches out there? Probably. Will he sort out all the shite behind the scenes? - I would like to think so.
Reply
(04-14-2022, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 10:30 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 07:44 AM)Huggybear Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 03:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:17 PM)Squid Wrote: In fairness, he did the job he was employed to do and any club with functioning management would have said goodbye at the end of the 2016–17 season and had a plan in place for his replacement. Even Pulis wanted out. But no, we gave him a contract extension. The decision that lead to all our recent problems.
Bang on.

It seemed Peace just wanted to keep him there to protect his asset, without thinking further ahead.

Peace's exit and the cluelessness of the Chinese regime has got us here.

We've been short-sighted throughout the past few years with the first team squad that hold the rest of the club in place, such as reserves, youth etc.

That's why I find the condemnation of Bruce not turning around a club in crisis in 12 games so bonkers.

Our budget is very competitive in the championship. Lest we forget we got Prem parachutes whilst many in the Championship really struggled during covid.

Allowing an experienced manager a proper pre-season and chance to re-arrange the squad best he can, bearing in mind some of the stupid contracts handed out, is the least we can do now.

If Bruce fails to make us a better side come November or so then maybe there may be something better as a plan, but for now we've got to let him use his knowledge of 20 years of being at many clubs like us and hopefully start the rebuild.
Pulis for all his faults was a far better coach and organiser than Bruce will ever be.Pulis did have a time limit and the more talented players he bought in actually became one of his downfalls.What I don’t understand is that you keep saying you would give Bruce until November,that really is suicidal.We have swapped managers something like four times in six half way through a season and that’s one of the reasons of the huge problems we have.By the way we were not a club in crisis,we were a club in the top six and many a manager would of been beating down the door to get a job like that.
I'm so fed up of the weak argument that we were not a club in crisis and using the top 6 argument Huggy old chap.

Simply he was sacked because we'd gone from looking nailed on promotion certs after 10 games to a team sliding into the middle of the pack in 3 months. Bottom 6 form for the latter two-thirds of Val's regime got him the sack. The dismissal was no surprise to virtually anyone, with the fans turning nasty too.

All the momentum was downwards. That is why he was given the boot. I always stick with managers and wish them well and did him, but the Preston game made us realise he'd lost the players and someone else had to try.

Pulis came here when we were in a position of relative strength and a good squad. Bruce has inherited 3-4 years of a mess.

Writing him off now and starting again seems to me to be utterly short-sighted. He needs a window to bin the rotten core and then try to add new life to the squad. Sacking him now would make us look like basket cases.

+1

Who are the rotten core in your opinion KKC? 

Let's not re-write history, Bruce was brought in to get us promoted - realistically, via the play-offs - which is what the hierarchy and Bruce himself stated .  And Bruce was waxing lyrical about the squad the day he was appointed. 

Gourlay - "His excellent man-management skills, tactical nous, (LOL) and ability to hit the ground running were among the many reasons we decided he was the man to take us forward," said Gourlay, who was only appointed chief executive on Wednesday.

"Promotion remains our objective for this season, and we are confident that with Steve leading the club we have given ourselves every chance of achieving that goal."

So at that point the Club and Bruce must have believed our demise was solely down to Val and it was going to be a foregone conclusion that we would improve and that Bruce would achieve his 5th promotion.   However he has failed miserably with absolutely no bounce whatsoever.  Took him to half-way through his brief tenure to find a formation that appears to suit us.  Surely a manager with his experience should have put this in place immediately.  3-5-2 is probably the safest system you can play especially with 5 defenders.  

There is - according to the Athletic -  a mutually agreed break-clause after 6 months,  so if we exercise this it's not effectively a sacking, it's a mutually agreed goodbye - either way.
Reply
(04-14-2022, 11:28 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 10:30 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 07:44 AM)Huggybear Wrote:
(04-14-2022, 03:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Bang on.

It seemed Peace just wanted to keep him there to protect his asset, without thinking further ahead.

Peace's exit and the cluelessness of the Chinese regime has got us here.

We've been short-sighted throughout the past few years with the first team squad that hold the rest of the club in place, such as reserves, youth etc.

That's why I find the condemnation of Bruce not turning around a club in crisis in 12 games so bonkers.

Our budget is very competitive in the championship. Lest we forget we got Prem parachutes whilst many in the Championship really struggled during covid.

Allowing an experienced manager a proper pre-season and chance to re-arrange the squad best he can, bearing in mind some of the stupid contracts handed out, is the least we can do now.

If Bruce fails to make us a better side come November or so then maybe there may be something better as a plan, but for now we've got to let him use his knowledge of 20 years of being at many clubs like us and hopefully start the rebuild.
Pulis for all his faults was a far better coach and organiser than Bruce will ever be.Pulis did have a time limit and the more talented players he bought in actually became one of his downfalls.What I don’t understand is that you keep saying you would give Bruce until November,that really is suicidal.We have swapped managers something like four times in six half way through a season and that’s one of the reasons of the huge problems we have.By the way we were not a club in crisis,we were a club in the top six and many a manager would of been beating down the door to get a job like that.
I'm so fed up of the weak argument that we were not a club in crisis and using the top 6 argument Huggy old chap.

Simply he was sacked because we'd gone from looking nailed on promotion certs after 10 games to a team sliding into the middle of the pack in 3 months. Bottom 6 form for the latter two-thirds of Val's regime got him the sack. The dismissal was no surprise to virtually anyone, with the fans turning nasty too.

All the momentum was downwards. That is why he was given the boot. I always stick with managers and wish them well and did him, but the Preston game made us realise he'd lost the players and someone else had to try.

Pulis came here when we were in a position of relative strength and a good squad. Bruce has inherited 3-4 years of a mess.

Writing him off now and starting again seems to me to be utterly short-sighted. He needs a window to bin the rotten core and then try to add new life to the squad. Sacking him now would make us look like basket cases.

+1

Who are the rotten core in your opinion KKC? 

Let's not re-write history, Bruce was brought in to get us promoted - realistically, via the play-offs - which is what the hierarchy and Bruce himself stated .  And Bruce was waxing lyrical about the squad the day he was appointed. 

Gourlay - "His excellent man-management skills, tactical nous, (LOL) and ability to hit the ground running were among the many reasons we decided he was the man to take us forward," said Gourlay, who was only appointed chief executive on Wednesday.

"Promotion remains our objective for this season, and we are confident that with Steve leading the club we have given ourselves every chance of achieving that goal."

So at that point the Club and Bruce must have believed our demise was solely down to Val and it was going to be a foregone conclusion that we would improve and that Bruce would achieve his 5th promotion.   However he has failed miserably with absolutely no bounce whatsoever.  Took him to half-way through his brief tenure to find a formation that appears to suit us.  Surely a manager with his experience should have put this in place immediately.  3-5-2 is probably the safest system you can play especially with 5 defenders.  

There is - according to the Athletic -  a mutually agreed break-clause after 6 months,  so if we exercise this it's not effectively a sacking, it's a mutually agreed goodbye - either way.

Rotten to the core? Names don't matter. The wage bill of that squad should mean they were in the mix, and they aren't.

As I've said in previous posts, the club needs a reset, and that starts behind the scenes. Some of the stuff coming out of the presser today is heart-warming. 

There may be better coaches out there, but we have to get the basics right first. This isn't a quick-fix project. I back Bruce to do just that. Gammon wouldn't have got The Seals promoted, unless he had Bruce's Building Blocks to improve upon.
Reply
There isn't a huge Bruce fan club at villa, not among the ST holders that I know. Jury still very much out for me.
Reply
(04-14-2022, 11:24 AM)wba13 Wrote: It’s good to see Bruce putting his foot down. 8 or 9players have been told that they must move closer to the Hawthorns if they want to remain. Button has been told no new contract unless he moves from Brighton. He also says they earn enough so if they have to get an apartment so be it.

Then promptly picks the bloke who lives the furthest away over those who live closer

That'll teach em
Reply
(04-14-2022, 12:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: There isn't a huge Bruce fan club at villa, not among the ST holders that I know. Jury still very much out for me.

The backroom staff speak very highly of him. I'm a little bit ITK on that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)