Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-12-2022, 11:40 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-12-2022, 10:48 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (04-12-2022, 09:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 06:34 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I'm struggling to see what Bruce has done to deserve to remain as Manager next season. I consider myself to usually be patient when it comes to Managers, but I just don't think he's the right man for the job at this stage of his career. I understand why he was appointed for the remainder of this season, but I'd be parting company given how things have gone.
I appreciate where you're coming from though Spandau, and perhaps if he is allowed to move 6 or 7 players on and replace them, that's the point at which we should judge him. One things clear, if the majority of the squad remain, along with Bruce, it's going to be a struggle next season.
Let's hope you're right and I'm wrong when it comes to Bruce, because after next season, promotion back to the Premiership will become more and more difficult.
There's a very simple answer to that. He's signed an 18 month contract. There needs to be an extraordinarily good reason to get rid of him. You might point out that Val was binned barely six months into a 4 year contract - the difference there was that he had two transfer windows and a full pre-season to get himself sorted. Bruce has had none of that.
I didn't like Ismael's approach to the game, if everyone played like that it would be a nightmare. But I also deplore the fact that player power and fan power got him out - there were many things he could have done differently, but the final straw was the reaction of fans and the absolute rebellion by the players. That's not acceptable. The proper thing to do with Steve Bruce is give him the summer and see how next season starts. Can't pretend I'm optimistic, he seems far too cosy with the senior players and is even talking about bringing Sawyers back, but we can't just keep firing managers.
According to the media, there was a end of season break clause, so there is in theory a cheap way out.
Regardless of my preference, I'd be surprised if Bruce didn't start next season with us. The only hope for a promotion push is that he's backed in the summer, and manages to off-load some of the under performing current squad.
Here's hoping... Whilst the ideal would be to offload a massive chunk of this lot, it's not really a necessity, we just need to do enough so that they are not first 11.
We should be ok for CH's
We desperately need:
LWB
RWB
Creative MF
Mobile DM
Wide forward
CF
Ok that's 6, which is a lot, but not impossible.
I think we could shift at least some of:
Phillips
Townsend
Ajayi
Robinson
Mowatt
Furlong
Provided the incomings are an upgrade on this shower, then we will be a completely different animal.
Agree with all of them but you can add Mowatt and Bartley to that list as I think they will have sutures I also think 1 of Robinson or Diangana will leave probably on loan.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(04-12-2022, 10:47 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-12-2022, 10:08 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (04-12-2022, 09:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Bruce is a "proper" manager, who will reset the club. He did the same at Villa. He may not be the best 1st team manager these days, but this club needs a complete shakedown, with only one eye on the 1st team results. Bruce can deliver that.
How do you equate this view with his almost total failure to give first team game time to young players since his arrival here?
It's also curious that you use his time at Villa to support your point, given that he failed to get them promoted and was sacked in Oct 2018 after a run of only 1 win in 9 games, despite having had 4 transfer windows since arriving to change things around. He was replaced by Dean Smith when they were 14th and Smith went on to win promotion in the play-off final, of course, mainly as a result of a run of 10 consecutive wins in Spring 2019.
In fairness to Bruce, he left them in a better state then when he arrived. Table position doesn't tell the whole story. Exactly this.
People I know who are ITK at Villa tell me he stabilised the ship, and built the platform for Smith.
I agree first team results are key, but I think we need to look deeper than this.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
04-12-2022, 01:26 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-12-2022, 01:26 PM by Remi_Moses.)
(04-12-2022, 12:11 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-12-2022, 11:40 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-12-2022, 10:48 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (04-12-2022, 09:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 06:34 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I'm struggling to see what Bruce has done to deserve to remain as Manager next season. I consider myself to usually be patient when it comes to Managers, but I just don't think he's the right man for the job at this stage of his career. I understand why he was appointed for the remainder of this season, but I'd be parting company given how things have gone.
I appreciate where you're coming from though Spandau, and perhaps if he is allowed to move 6 or 7 players on and replace them, that's the point at which we should judge him. One things clear, if the majority of the squad remain, along with Bruce, it's going to be a struggle next season.
Let's hope you're right and I'm wrong when it comes to Bruce, because after next season, promotion back to the Premiership will become more and more difficult.
There's a very simple answer to that. He's signed an 18 month contract. There needs to be an extraordinarily good reason to get rid of him. You might point out that Val was binned barely six months into a 4 year contract - the difference there was that he had two transfer windows and a full pre-season to get himself sorted. Bruce has had none of that.
I didn't like Ismael's approach to the game, if everyone played like that it would be a nightmare. But I also deplore the fact that player power and fan power got him out - there were many things he could have done differently, but the final straw was the reaction of fans and the absolute rebellion by the players. That's not acceptable. The proper thing to do with Steve Bruce is give him the summer and see how next season starts. Can't pretend I'm optimistic, he seems far too cosy with the senior players and is even talking about bringing Sawyers back, but we can't just keep firing managers.
According to the media, there was a end of season break clause, so there is in theory a cheap way out.
Regardless of my preference, I'd be surprised if Bruce didn't start next season with us. The only hope for a promotion push is that he's backed in the summer, and manages to off-load some of the under performing current squad.
Here's hoping... Whilst the ideal would be to offload a massive chunk of this lot, it's not really a necessity, we just need to do enough so that they are not first 11.
We should be ok for CH's
We desperately need:
LWB
RWB
Creative MF
Mobile DM
Wide forward
CF
Ok that's 6, which is a lot, but not impossible.
I think we could shift at least some of:
Phillips
Townsend
Ajayi
Robinson
Mowatt
Furlong
Provided the incomings are an upgrade on this shower, then we will be a completely different animal.
Agree with all of them but you can add Mowatt and Bartley to that list as I think they will have sutures I also think 1 of Robinson or Diangana will leave probably on loan.
Our business is always shrouded in secrecy.
But I would like to see who/if Bruce puts on the transfer list.
He has the last 5 games to try our youngsters and get Palmer in the sticks. If he sticks with the same wasters my confidence in him will be going south.
I wouldn't care if we lost as long as we are working towards a positive change in the future.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
2 Months is a long time in football:
8 weeks ago: "I can't change the squad, but I've looked at it and lets be honest on paper this squad is as good as anything in the Championship. If I didn't think the squad wasn't good enough, I wouldn't be sitting here."
1 week ago: "I'll have a look and see how we improve it, and what we do. I’m still assessing it. I haven’t seen three of our players who have been injured, two of them are maybe among our better players in (Matt) Phillips and (Daryl) Dike"
Now: “We’re verging on a major overhaul. That’s required because the club is never going to accept being halfway in the Championship and rightly so."
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-12-2022, 01:34 PM)Sliced Wrote: 2 Months is a long time in football:
8 weeks ago: "I can't change the squad, but I've looked at it and lets be honest on paper this squad is as good as anything in the Championship. If I didn't think the squad wasn't good enough, I wouldn't be sitting here."
1 week ago: "I'll have a look and see how we improve it, and what we do. I’m still assessing it. I haven’t seen three of our players who have been injured, two of them are maybe among our better players in (Matt) Phillips and (Daryl) Dike"
Now: “We’re verging on a major overhaul. That’s required because the club is never going to accept being halfway in the Championship and rightly so."
A couple years time, we may have to!
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(04-12-2022, 01:34 PM)Sliced Wrote: 2 Months is a long time in football:
8 weeks ago: "I can't change the squad, but I've looked at it and lets be honest on paper this squad is as good as anything in the Championship. If I didn't think the squad wasn't good enough, I wouldn't be sitting here."
1 week ago: "I'll have a look and see how we improve it, and what we do. I’m still assessing it. I haven’t seen three of our players who have been injured, two of them are maybe among our better players in (Matt) Phillips and (Daryl) Dike"
Now: “We’re verging on a major overhaul. That’s required because the club is never going to accept being halfway in the Championship and rightly so."
Finger on the pulse stuff from someone so experienced!!
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
04-12-2022, 03:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-12-2022, 03:24 PM by Big Daddy Cool.)
He was hardly going to say "This squad is shit, we need new players" when he was first appointed.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
04-12-2022, 03:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-12-2022, 03:38 PM by Psalm23.)
I've no doubt that on paper, this squad is as good as anything in the Championship, unfortunately as soon as they have to play on grass, most of em seem to turn to shit.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Bob Fossil Wrote:Whilst the ideal would be to offload a massive chunk of this lot, it's not really a necessity, we just need to do enough so that they are not first 11.
We should be ok for CH's
We desperately need:
LWB
RWB
Creative MF
Mobile DM
Wide forward
CF
Ok that's 6, which is a lot, but not impossible.
I think we could shift at least some of:
Phillips
Townsend
Ajayi
Robinson
Mowatt
Furlong
Provided the incomings are an upgrade on this shower, then we will be a completely different animal.
Not sure it is that drastic TBH. Agree we shift where possible ( no one is crucial and I'd like to bomb a few out), but I think Phillips, Townsend, Ajayi and Mowatt could do a job as squad members. Assuming we are seriously trying to land Carroll then we are sorted up front. Clarke would be good at the right price. Reach should have the LWB for now. Jake either as one of the back 3 or just in front of it should sort the defence. As long as we get a new RB and at least one, preferably two better midfielders we will be competitive.
Palmer
O'Shea Kipre Clarke
Livermore
New RWB TGH New MF Reach
Dike Grant
Also; Can do a job when required,
Phillips
Grady
Mowatt
Townsend
Taylor
Ajayi
We also need to see who we have in the academy that will either do a job or need to go out on loan. Ingram, Ashworth, Tulloch, Richards.
Posts: 1,149
Threads: 75
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
4
Over the years I've seen many incidences of 11 competent, but not spectacularly talented players, each of whom knew their job precisely, organised into a method of playing to the manager's plan.
And as a result, this gives them an better than evens chance of winning games.
Brian Clough was a master at this in his early career. Alf Ramsey did the same with Ipswich and England, as did Bobby Robson. And for those of you old enough to remember, Vic Buckingham did it with us in the 1950s, and that became the blue-print for the Netherland's "Total Football" philosophy which revolutionised football tactics.
I've been a keen student of Steve Bruce since he shat on Huddersfield when he was a manager there. I always wondered what it was that convinced various boards of directors that this decent but very intellectually limited man, was the person to take their club forward. He certainly has mastered his interview technique. Perhaps he should take interview coaching up as a profession?
I don't dislike him. But he is without a jot of inspiration in his footballing philosophy, because he doesn't have one. He appears to make no attempt to assess a player, work out what his strengths are, work out if he can improve him in order to slot him into his strategic plan for the the team, because he doesn't have one. Hence he puts players into roles that they don't know, or understand or have never practised on the training ground. Hence they don't know what they should be doing, and neither do the players around them.
He fails to motivate players because there is no vision of what the team should play like, where they are going as a team, and importantly, no apparent desire from any individuals to buy into the team ethos. Gary Megson had a bang-average bunch of players who would kill for each other because he created a collective cult who wanted to achieve more than they ever believed they could achieve individually. As Derek McInnes said " there's something special happening here".
Bruces' teams rarely show any evidence of a plan other than to hoof it in the general direction of the opponent's goal. He can't organise a defence because the players in mid-field, who are the first line of defence, are usually ageing ( but "good pros") lacking in pace. And in the unlikely event that they win the ball back, the shock of doing so is so overwhelming, they pass it back to the opposition.
Meanwhile the four behind them are clueless as to where they should be, where the ball is likely to go, and where the final delivery will be delivered to, and who is likely to make the runs. These things should be dealt with in the classroom, or on the training pitch, and based on a thorough analysis of how the opposition play leading up to the game. Because if the opposition are any good, unlike us, they will have a plan.
His teams lack creativity. The options from midfield are limited due to the lack of well-rehearsed movement from the front two. They are usually a target man, who when the ball arrives at neck height, at 50 mph, has no chance of controlling it, and no colleague to lay it off to, because he hasn't a clue where he should be. So we lose possession again.
Have a look at how easily Harry Kane skimmed the ball off his head to Son vs the Villa on Sunday. That's how easy it is if you know where your mate is and where he is going to be. That has to be the simplest goal ever. Total route one football, brilliantly executed and obviously rehearsed ad infinitum on the training pitch. The player who launched the ball knew where Kane was, Kane took a look at where Son was, Son knew where he was going and where Kane would put the ball for him to run on to. A superb piece of football at its simplest.
Bruce can't change a game in the second half with plan B, because there is no plan A. And the players know it. So they don't care, other than Andy Carroll and TGH.
Bruce is a relic worthy of role in the next Mike Bassett film. I wouldn't be surprised in the next film, to find his character out in the town centre in the early hours, throwing white plastic bar chairs at the opposition fans, which is about the nearest he will ever come to organising an attack.
The cabbage that landed on the pitch in his final days at Villa Park was cruel but well-deserved. I think there's an Asian convenience store on Brasshouse Lane that stocks them.
Drink has been taken.
|