Defensive stats
#1
Outraged as I am to see Bartley getting the blame (again) for Ajayi's poor marking, I've done some statting. This is based on starting line-up only, and includes players only when picked for central defence. I realise that detracts from the accuracy of the figures, but it was an interesting hour or so:

  • Bruce is conceding 1.33 goals per game, Ismael conceded 0.83 goals per game.
  • The most commonly used combo this season (12 games) has been Ajayi/Bartley/Clarke. Also the worst, conceding 1.25 goals per game for both managers.
  • Kipre/Bartley/Clarke (9 games) has conceded 0.67 goals per game, while Ajayi/Bartley/Townsend (5 games) an impressive 0.6 goals per game. No other combo has played more than 3 games.
  • Ajayi has the worst individual record, conceding 1.09 goals per game. Bartley and O'Shea on 1.00, Clarke on 0.97, Townsend on 0.88 and Kipre on 0.86. Also worth noting that O'Shea has an 80% win record and no defeats in his five starts in centre back positions (in three different combos).
  • Bruce has only used Ajayi, Clarke and Bartley - all three of these have seen a catastrophic collapse in their individual goals conceded records since the change of manager, as you'd expect.
  • Apart from Bartley, only Clarke has started in the central position (3 times W1 D1 L1), although we have finished games with Ajayi or Clarke there, maybe also O'Shea?
  • Four games started with a central defensive pair, yielding 1 point and 6 goals conceded.

What can we conclude? Ajayi's figures don't surprise me, he lacks concentration and we defend less well when he's on the pitch. Why is Bartley undroppable? Is it his height? It surely isn't his pace or inspired leadership. And finally, with comedy defending happening on a regular basis and two proven alternatives in Kipre and O'Shea sitting on the bench, how bad does it have to get before Bruce makes a change?

It can't be denied that Bruce has messed up the defence. Ismael was forced into several makeshift line-ups, but he also made changes (in particular dropping Ajayi after the 3-0 defeat at Fulham) to keep things tight. By contrast, Bruce has settled on the combination of three wily old pros who performed worst for Ismael, failed to get them sorted as a proper pair the way he wanted to play and now persistently ignores others who might improve things for him. He should start the "major overhaul" now, but almost certainly won't. It doesn't fill me with confidence for the summer window and next season.
Reply
#2
Those stats are all well and good but I hope you're prepared to be firmly put in your place by those on here who know better by "WATCHING THE GAME"

Great post, btw. I've said enough that Bruce's biggest failing is ruining the only part of the team that worked when there was absolutely no need to.
Reply
#3
Ajayi was worse last game. Bartleys been worse overall.

Don’t be outraged, neither should start the next game
Reply
#4
Fascinating post Cheshire, thank you for doing the research. As a central defender of some repute himself, you'd expect Bruce to be more capable of identifying the best defensive partnership than anything else. However, as your stats clearly illustrate he's made the defence worse, with there being no tangible improvements as a consequence either.

I'd be happy for Kipre to play in the centre with O'Shea and Clarke either side of him. It's an absolute must that a different combination is tried in the back 3.
Reply
#5
Like a few on here - trying Clarke/O'Shea/Kipre is a no-brainer for me.
Reply
#6
Is Bruce not keen on playing O'Shea at centre back because he doesn't think he's tall enough? 

I agree that Clarke Kipre and O'Shea is worth trying
Reply
#7
(04-11-2022, 05:49 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Is Bruce not keen on playing O'Shea at centre back because he doesn't think he's tall enough? 

I agree that Clarke Kipre and O'Shea is worth trying

Bruce has been told not to play him so he gets pissed off and wants to leave. We sell him and give SB a war chest of 1.5 m for next season’s promotion campaign. Probably
Reply
#8
Bruce has a very good track record -  if not incomparable - of getting teams promoted to the Prem.  

It could be argued that he's inherited a mess and so should be given the opportunity to do a rebuild for next season.  

But look at the facts.  If ever a Manager should have got an easy bounce it should have been Bruce, shouldn't it?  

Val - 45 pts from 29  -  GD  +10   -  5th when he was sacked -   8 pts from 2nd

SB  -12 pts from 12   -  GD  + 5   -  12th now -                     - 16 pts from 2nd     

He's talking about an overhaul but how is he going to achieve this, until we have money we're not aware of?  

We will probably give Carroll another yr on better money which is fair.   Johnstone and hopefully Sawyers will go so that's gives us a little room to manoevre but not much. 

Personally, I think Bruce is over the hill, an overweight dinosaur who spouts cliches and does nothing more than state the bleeding obvious.  He doesn't appear to have any particular style of play/formation or tactics that will consistently overcome the opposition.   He is now the main reason we have not made the play-offs, not the players.  Any Manager worth his salt would have done so.    

If we have a break-clause, get rid!
Reply
#9
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:Outraged as I am to see Bartley getting the blame (again) for Ajayi's poor marking, I've done some statting. This is based on starting line-up only, and includes players only when picked for central defence. I realise that detracts from the accuracy of the figures, but it was an interesting hour or so:


[ul]
[li]Bruce is conceding 1.33 goals per game, Ismael conceded 0.83 goals per game.[/li]
[li]The most commonly used combo this season (12 games) has been Ajayi/Bartley/Clarke. Also the worst, conceding 1.25 goals per game for both managers.[/li]
[li]Kipre/Bartley/Clarke (9 games) has conceded 0.67 goals per game, while Ajayi/Bartley/Townsend (5 games) an impressive 0.6 goals per game. No other combo has played more than 3 games.[/li]
[li]Ajayi has the worst individual record, conceding 1.09 goals per game. Bartley and O'Shea on 1.00, Clarke on 0.97, Townsend on 0.88 and Kipre on 0.86. Also worth noting that O'Shea has an 80% win record and no defeats in his five starts in centre back positions (in three different combos).[/li]
[li]Bruce has only used Ajayi, Clarke and Bartley - all three of these have seen a catastrophic collapse in their individual goals conceded records since the change of manager, as you'd expect.[/li]
[li]Apart from Bartley, only Clarke has started in the central position (3 times W1 D1 L1), although we have finished games with Ajayi or Clarke there, maybe also O'Shea?[/li]
[li]Four games started with a central defensive pair, yielding 1 point and 6 goals conceded.[/li]
[/ul]

What can we conclude? Ajayi's figures don't surprise me, he lacks concentration and we defend less well when he's on the pitch. Why is Bartley undroppable? Is it his height? It surely isn't his pace or inspired leadership. And finally, with comedy defending happening on a regular basis and two proven alternatives in Kipre and O'Shea sitting on the bench, how bad does it have to get before Bruce makes a change?

It can't be denied that Bruce has messed up the defence. Ismael was forced into several makeshift line-ups, but he also made changes (in particular dropping Ajayi after the 3-0 defeat at Fulham) to keep things tight. By contrast, Bruce has settled on the combination of three wily old pros who performed worst for Ismael, failed to get them sorted as a proper pair the way he wanted to play and now persistently ignores others who might improve things for him. He should start the "major overhaul" now, but almost certainly won't. It doesn't fill me with confidence for the summer window and next season.
That is great statting and it confirms my opinion of what I have watched myself. Ajayi flatters to deceive, Bartley is simply poor. Kipre did no wrong, he was improving every game and O'Shea, well a game at right back isn't going to tell Bruce much. Bruce's loyalty to these 3 may be his undoing.  Another vote for a back 3 of O'Shea, Kipre, Clarke from me. I wouldn't mind seeing Ajayi at right wing back, it could go horribly wrong as he can't pass water, but he is certainly fast enough to be given Furlongs shirt for a try.
Reply
#10
I guess that Bruce thinks that Ajayi and Bartley are better players than O'Shea and Kipre. I guess Bruce is also not a stats-driven manager  Big Grin  

Some nice statting there though, and Ajayi and Bartley are two of the players I would put in the "not good enough overall" bracket.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)