“The Squad isn’t good enough”
#1
Seen this repeated a few times on here to the point where it becomes accepted truth, but is that true?

A quick look through our current squad throws up:

12 Players with experience of promotion from the Championship
9 Full internationals 
3 Players with major international tournament experience
3 Players who have previously made Championship team of the year
2 who have scored 19+ Championship goals in one season.
4 Players who have moved clubs for eight figure fees

Looking at those numbers do people really believe that mid-table in the Championship is the ceiling of this squad’s abilities? Saying they aren’t good enough is disingenuous and makes excuses for the real issues. These players have demonstrated, both individually and collectively, that they should be better than they currently are, the failing isn’t in their feet (or hands) but in their heads and hearts. There is no character in this squad, no pride, no sense of responsibility for themselves or for those who turn up to watch them. This is an issue that has been ingrained in the squad since the last days of Pulis, it now runs through the club like a cancer, infecting almost every player who joins us now.

They can be better. They should be better. They just don’t give a fuck.
Reply
#2
Unfortunately all of that only counts on paper.

Said a while back, the problem with this squad is there's very little motivation to achieve anything. As your post rightly points out, most of these players have already played at the highest level they will play at, and there's very little motivation to press on. Most of them are on the biggest contract they've ever been on, and ever will be on and frankly comfort has set in.

The only players from this group who seem motivated to improve are Dike who we're yet to really see, Mowatt, who has been ostracised allegedly by most of the dressing room, and O'Shea, but with his contract running out next season, he can afford to play a waiting game.

There is simply no hunger or appetite in this side and it shows.
Reply
#3
It's no good looking at them as individuals. Football is a team sport and our team is unbalanced. No creativity in midfield and very weak upfront for most of the season. If you struggle to score goals, you will struggle full stop.
Reply
#4
(04-11-2022, 01:46 PM)Squid Wrote: It's no good looking at them as individuals. Football is a team sport and our team is unbalanced. No creativity in midfield and very weak upfront for most of the season. If you struggle to score goals, you will struggle full stop.
This has been the major issue all season. Highlighted, yet again on Saturday, simply by moving TGH, which, immediately shutdown our midfield and turned it into a pointless melee of backwards passing and chasing shadows, churning up the same 20 yard area of pitch over and over again.

Every fibre of our scouting department should be working around the clock to address this for next season.
Reply
#5
(04-11-2022, 12:59 PM)Duffers Wrote: Seen this repeated a few times on here to the point where it becomes accepted truth, but is that true?

A quick look through our current squad throws up:

12 Players with experience of promotion from the Championship
9 Full internationals 
3 Players with major international tournament experience
3 Players who have previously made Championship team of the year
2 who have scored 19+ Championship goals in one season.
4 Players who have moved clubs for eight figure fees

Looking at those numbers do people really believe that mid-table in the Championship is the ceiling of this squad’s abilities? Saying they aren’t good enough is disingenuous and makes excuses for the real issues. These players have demonstrated, both individually and collectively, that they should be better than they currently are, the failing isn’t in their feet (or hands) but in their heads and hearts. There is no character in this squad, no pride, no sense of responsibility for themselves or for those who turn up to watch them. This is an issue that has been ingrained in the squad since the last days of Pulis, it now runs through the club like a cancer, infecting almost every player who joins us now.

They can be better. They should be better. They just don’t give a fuck.

I still believe that this squad should be doing far better than we've shown this season. It's difficult to pinpoint precisely what the issues are - every player would rather win and be successful than not (surely?).   

I find it difficult not to believe however in the mantra that 'management are responsible for 99% of the problems'.  Seemingly, the previous 2 Managers (Lardarse/Ismael) allegedly caused a lot of damage to players confidence and there have been allegations that Bilic allowed fitness/standards to slip.  

Couple of things from the weekend.   TGH said that contrary to the criticism of the players, every player at the club is absolutely giving their all. 

The other thing which I haven't heard personally is someone said Bruce was asked (WM interview?)  what he said to the players after the game and he said he didn't have to say anything as one of the players said to the others 'you lot don't care'.  Not seen it myself. Anyone hear this as I can't find it?  

Bruce mentioned 3 games in 6 days as maybe a factor but said we have to be able to deal with it physically.  Stoke played Sat/Tues so had an extra 24 hrs.  We did look leggy but he could have freshened it up from the start.
Reply
#6
TGH is hardly going to say “None of us give a fuck. While you’re booing we are all rolling around on a massive pile of your money pissing ourselves!” is he?
Reply
#7
There is a starting 11 good enough to get top 6, Val proved that. However in a 46 game league you need a strong squad, it’s no good having a capable first 11 and nothing beyond that.

For the vast majority of this season we’ve had:

1 right back option
1 available centre forward
0 attacking midfielders so we’ve put TGH there. Luckily he’s done a decent job
No reasonable alternatives to Livermore and Mowatt
Two players in TGH and Reach that are expected to cover about 4 different positions.

Unbalanced is an understatement. I could hypothetically put together a squad of 20 players that got promoted multiple times. It doesn’t necessarily mean it’d be a good squad.
Reply
#8
For me, a player's psyche is a factor on judging whether they are good enough, not just their physical attributes. It's part of the overall bundle.
Reply
#9
The squad is good enough the attitude isn’t. There is no way that most bar Fulham and perhaps Bournemouth have better players what they have is a better attitude and in some cases more confidence.

The squad is unbalanced in central midfield but that is down to the previous managers tactics and wishes. It doesn’t excuse where we are in the league however. We are like the lazy, clever kid in class who is far more intelligent than many but wastes that talent doing just enough.
Reply
#10
(04-11-2022, 01:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 12:59 PM)Duffers Wrote: Seen this repeated a few times on here to the point where it becomes accepted truth, but is that true?

A quick look through our current squad throws up:

12 Players with experience of promotion from the Championship
9 Full internationals 
3 Players with major international tournament experience
3 Players who have previously made Championship team of the year
2 who have scored 19+ Championship goals in one season.
4 Players who have moved clubs for eight figure fees

Looking at those numbers do people really believe that mid-table in the Championship is the ceiling of this squad’s abilities? Saying they aren’t good enough is disingenuous and makes excuses for the real issues. These players have demonstrated, both individually and collectively, that they should be better than they currently are, the failing isn’t in their feet (or hands) but in their heads and hearts. There is no character in this squad, no pride, no sense of responsibility for themselves or for those who turn up to watch them. This is an issue that has been ingrained in the squad since the last days of Pulis, it now runs through the club like a cancer, infecting almost every player who joins us now.

They can be better. They should be better. They just don’t give a fuck.

I still believe that this squad should be doing far better than we've shown this season. It's difficult to pinpoint precisely what the issues are - every player would rather win and be successful than not (surely?).   

I find it difficult not to believe however in the mantra that 'management are responsible for 99% of the problems'.  Seemingly, the previous 2 Managers (Lardarse/Ismael) allegedly caused a lot of damage to players confidence and there have been allegations that Bilic allowed fitness/standards to slip.  

Couple of things from the weekend.   TGH said that contrary to the criticism of the players, every player at the club is absolutely giving their all. 

The other thing which I haven't heard personally is someone said Bruce was asked (WM interview?)  what he said to the players after the game and he said he didn't have to say anything as one of the players said to the others 'you lot don't care'.  Not seen it myself. Anyone hear this as I can't find it?  

Bruce mentioned 3 games in 6 days as maybe a factor but said we have to be able to deal with it physically.  Stoke played Sat/Tues so had an extra 24 hrs.  We did look leggy but he could have freshened it up from the start.

That was from a blistering interview with the Walsall manager. Not Bruce.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)