Bruce set for a squad overhaul
#21
(04-11-2022, 09:35 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 09:05 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 08:51 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.

Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived. 

Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.

In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.

We sacked our last manager just over halfway through the season though, so the same applies. Fair play he needs to try things out, but breaking the only part of our team that worked is inexcusable for me.

Having no patience is inexcusable to me. It's endemic in a have it all now society. 

Weirdly I was chatting to a mate on Saturday who was discussing this same topic. He's a Leeds fan and he said the shocking lack of patience and level of expectation crippled them for years, and also how people in their 30s seem to borrow much more than people a decade or two older. 

My view is simply managers used to be afforded more time. If we could turn the clock back to the mid 70s with that mindset of now Johnny Giles would have been bombed out by fans long before he turned things around. Sometimes things get worse before they get better.

Bruce is extremely well-connected and he's just recently spent a couple of years in one of the most high-pressurised clubs in the country. He deserves more respect and patience than he's getting by some.

There will be a line in the sand where we have to decide to take stock, but that has to be after a pre-season and about 15 games of a new season in the mind of any cool and calm decision maker rather than an emotional fan who instantly expects 2 years of rot to be tuned around in a few weeks without even a transfer window.

Sorry, but it's completely irrational and ridiculous to want him out now.

We sacked our last manager after less than 30 games, so much for giving time. Corberan at Huddersfield has benefitted massively from a season to get his feet under the table, likewise Martin at Swansea is finishing the season strongly and will improve next season. Neither of those would have lasted the season with us. So shouting for Bruce to be given time all of a sudden is plain weird.

As far as I was aware, Bruce wasn't brought in to rebuild, he was given the job with the remit of halting the slide and ensuring we get in the POs. He broke the best defence in the league for no reason and hasn't been able to inject any impetus going forwards either. I've nothing against Bruce, but he's certainly not filled me with confidence thus far.

If we're looking for a rebuild there are better candidates out there who would be worth a long-term deal. Critchley at Blackpool and Manning from MK Dons would be top of my list and to be given at least a season.

You clearly have something against him or are just an incredibly impatient character as you've given him no reasonable time or half a chance. Our last manager had 29 games, as you point out. Bruce has had 12! Our previous manager had a transfer window. Bruce hasn't.  It's hardly like for like is it? If you read my post I said he needs a pre-season and 15 games. He'd then have about 30 matches and that's a decent spell to take stock.

Val had 30 odd games but it was obvious it was getting worse and worse.

Bruce might have been given a remit of getting us in the play-offs, but who honestly thought he would do it? I certainly thought it was unlikely. The club is in a malaise and it needs more time.

As for the defence being broke, that means it's beyond repair. It's not. We actually are scoring goals and are more of an attacking threat of late I'd argue.

However, I'll shelve all of this micro-analysis of now for the chance for Bruce to use his standing in the game to entice players to us and see what his players do.

If you recall when Megson turned us around 20 odd years ago he had the chance to get players in straight away. Bruce has the equivalent of that 2000 bunch of wasters under Little now, but no chance to refresh them with his own men. 

I think the fans need a reset. I hope this basket case of a season will mean we have a little more patience next year and some fans may be a little more benevolent than you about what we are faced with.

Sorry Spandau, you're belief in Bruce is admirable  but we look worse now than when Val was sacked. 
We in no way look better going forward, I'd argue we've actually regressed up top with the only reason why we may sometimes look like scoring being down to the addition of Carroll to wallop it at from goalkicks.

Bruce was brought in to give the place a lift and get the promotion push back on track, and he failed. He grossly misjudged the size of the task and failed to adjust quickly when it was clear a quick arm round the shoulder wouldn't fix anything.

His persistence with Reach as an AMC, the selection of Bartley ahead of O'Shea, picking Johnstone and Townsend despite having replacements available and their form being poor, the strange decision to move TGH into RWB despite him being crucial in the middle... it paints the picture of a manager reliant on giving the lads a lift and not having the coaching and tactical ability to influence the modern game.

For many it seems the fact Bruce is not Val is enough for him to deserve patience and time. For me, Bruce is bloody lucky we still have some elements of the fitness and defensive structure structure Val coached into this team as all I've seen so far from Bruce is a team becoming  steadily more disorganised and going from having a clear Plan A but no Plan B to a side without a clear Plan A.

I appreciate Bruce has a decent track record in this division but that was generally with sides with good players and big budgets, I'm not sure he's ever had to oversee a squad rebuild and reset, and comparatively nezt season will be the lowest budget he's had to work with.
Reply
#22
(04-11-2022, 09:35 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: You clearly have something against him or are just an incredibly impatient character as you've given him no reasonable time or half a chance. Our last manager had 29 games, as you point out. Bruce has had 12! Our previous manager had a transfer window. Bruce hasn't.  It's hardly like for like is it? If you read my post I said he needs a pre-season and 15 games. He'd then have about 30 matches and that's a decent spell to take stock.

Val had 30 odd games but it was obvious it was getting worse and worse.

Bruce might have been given a remit of getting us in the play-offs, but who honestly thought he would do it? I certainly thought it was unlikely. The club is in a malaise and it needs more time.

As for the defence being broke, that means it's beyond repair. It's not. We actually are scoring goals and are more of an attacking threat of late I'd argue.

However, I'll shelve all of this micro-analysis of now for the chance for Bruce to use his standing in the game to entice players to us and see what his players do.

If you recall when Megson turned us around 20 odd years ago he had the chance to get players in straight away. Bruce has the equivalent of that 2000 bunch of wasters under Little now, but no chance to refresh them with his own men. 

I think the fans need a reset. I hope this basket case of a season will mean we have a little more patience next year and some fans may be a little more benevolent than you about what we are faced with.

Our squad has needed resetting since 2018, the closest we got was the summer under Bilic. All of what you say there can be applied to the previous manager, who I don't believe was given enough time. The two examples I've pointed out show why if we're going down the long-term, rebuild then they need to be given at least a season. For some reason those rules apply to Bruce and no one else.

The fact is we aren't any more creative (the numbers prove this, despite what you think you know) and we're conceding far more chances and goals. If this has been Bruce's audition to be given the chance of shaping a team for the next 18 months, it's not been great has it.

Ultimately the ownership is a sham and can't see beyond the end of their noses/don't care enough to try. Until we invest in a proper scouting network and a young manager committed to developing players working their way up the leagues we're going to be stuck in this cycle of a manager every 12 months. There are plenty of teams in this league showing that parachute money isn't the be all and end all. I honestly think our fans would be far more patient and accepting of our current position if say, I'll use the Swansea example again, we appoint a young manager, trying to play football a certain way and develop what he has. We complain about the club giving contract extensions to has beens like Phillips, Livermore and Bartley whilst we've got the managerial equivalent in the dugout.

Middlesbrough, Swansea, Huddersfield, fucking LUTON! and Blackpool are blowing us out of the water in terms of the model to build your club around. We did it so well for years and now we're totally clueless.
Reply
#23
"We complain about the club giving contract extensions to has beens like Phillips, Livermore and Bartley whilst we've got the managerial equivalent in the dugout."

You articulate what is wrong with the club in that excellent sentence
Reply
#24
(04-11-2022, 09:55 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 09:35 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: You clearly have something against him or are just an incredibly impatient character as you've given him no reasonable time or half a chance. Our last manager had 29 games, as you point out. Bruce has had 12! Our previous manager had a transfer window. Bruce hasn't.  It's hardly like for like is it? If you read my post I said he needs a pre-season and 15 games. He'd then have about 30 matches and that's a decent spell to take stock.

Val had 30 odd games but it was obvious it was getting worse and worse.

Bruce might have been given a remit of getting us in the play-offs, but who honestly thought he would do it? I certainly thought it was unlikely. The club is in a malaise and it needs more time.

As for the defence being broke, that means it's beyond repair. It's not. We actually are scoring goals and are more of an attacking threat of late I'd argue.

However, I'll shelve all of this micro-analysis of now for the chance for Bruce to use his standing in the game to entice players to us and see what his players do.

If you recall when Megson turned us around 20 odd years ago he had the chance to get players in straight away. Bruce has the equivalent of that 2000 bunch of wasters under Little now, but no chance to refresh them with his own men. 

I think the fans need a reset. I hope this basket case of a season will mean we have a little more patience next year and some fans may be a little more benevolent than you about what we are faced with.

Our squad has needed resetting since 2018, the closest we got was the summer under Bilic. All of what you say there can be applied to the previous manager, who I don't believe was given enough time. The two examples I've pointed out show why if we're going down the long-term, rebuild then they need to be given at least a season. For some reason those rules apply to Bruce and no one else.

The fact is we aren't any more creative (the numbers prove this, despite what you think you know) and we're conceding far more chances and goals. If this has been Bruce's audition to be given the chance of shaping a team for the next 18 months, it's not been great has it.

Ultimately the ownership is a sham and can't see beyond the end of their noses/don't care enough to try. Until we invest in a proper scouting network and a young manager committed to developing players working their way up the leagues we're going to be stuck in this cycle of a manager every 12 months. There are plenty of teams in this league showing that parachute money isn't the be all and end all. I honestly think our fans would be far more patient and accepting of our current position if say, I'll use the Swansea example again, we appoint a young manager, trying to play football a certain way and develop what he has. We complain about the club giving contract extensions to has beens like Phillips, Livermore and Bartley whilst we've got the managerial equivalent in the dugout.

Middlesbrough, Swansea, Huddersfield, fucking LUTON! and Blackpool are blowing us out of the water in terms of the model to build your club around. We did it so well for years and now we're totally clueless.
Think this is where we are finding common ground Ted.

Predominantly the issue is the short-termist board who have not looked at the whole scouting infrastructure. The next big issue has been the players who you mention on these contracts. Mental. 

The appointment of Gourlay shows some attempt to redress this.However, he has question marks too.

However, I think condemning Bruce after 12 games without any chance to refresh the squad is utterly bonkers when Val, with his pull as a manager, bought in substandard players like the captain of Barnsley and a young kid loaned out from Brighton to the championship. 

My defence of Bruce isn't due to anything other than being measured about the big picture of where we are as a club. I hoped for something more inspiring when Val went, but he needs a Pres-season and 15 games and despite the amazing impatience shown by some he'll get it unless something dramatic happens in a few weeks and he just doesn't want it.

The Hawthorns isn't a happy place- the club has been a shambles since Peace left. It's a real state of flux. Some cool heads and medium/long-term perspective is needed. Time will tell if it happens.
Reply
#25
Pull as manager means little in the modern game.

Only thing Bruce has is his contacts, since our scouting system seems so poor, remember when we had one of the best....
Reply
#26
(04-11-2022, 10:01 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: "We complain about the club giving contract extensions to has beens like Phillips, Livermore and Bartley whilst we've got the managerial equivalent in the dugout."

You articulate what is wrong with the club in that excellent sentence

It seems ageist to me. 

Maybe Val was the equivalent to the kids stuffed 6-0 by Arsenal!
Reply
#27
It worries me that those wanting Bruce to stay can only point to things he's done in the past as opposed to anything visible he's achieved with us.

I see also that we moved on from blaming Ismael for denting the confidence of the players and now he's blamed for bringing the captain of his play-off achieving side (a transfer nobody criticised at the time) and a young midfielder as a squad player (ditto).

If we keep Bruce, he will end up getting sacked halfway through next season and we'll be in the same situation again.

He was brought in to achieve playoffs. If he fails, he needs to go. As do many members of the team.
Reply
#28
(04-11-2022, 10:19 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Think this is where we are finding common ground Ted.

Predominantly the issue is the short-termist board who have not looked at the whole scouting infrastructure. The next big issue has been the players who you mention on these contracts. Mental. 

The appointment of Gourlay shows some attempt to redress this.However, he has question marks too.

However, I think condemning Bruce after 12 games without any chance to refresh the squad is utterly bonkers when Val, with his pull as a manager, bought in substandard players like the captain of Barnsley and a young kid loaned out from Brighton to the championship. 

My defence of Bruce isn't due to anything other than being measured about the big picture of where we are as a club. I hoped for something more inspiring when Val went, but he needs a Pres-season and 15 games and despite the amazing impatience shown by some he'll get it unless something dramatic happens in a few weeks and he just doesn't want it.

The Hawthorns isn't a happy place- the club has been a shambles since Peace left. It's a real state of flux. Some cool heads and medium/long-term perspective is needed. Time will tell if it happens.

Absolutely. We can kiss goodbye to any forward planning whilst the club is being ran the way it is, the rot started when they failed to seize the chance to replace Pulis (see Palace with Hodgson and Viera) with someone more dynamic when we were a top half PL side and we've been paying the price ever since.

The decisions we've made in the short-term interests of our owners back pocket has led us to this house of cards scenario, we're just about at the point where it completely collapses I fear. Until the ownership changes, I'd be inclined to agree with you that Bruce is probably the best we're going to get.

It does beg the question, why when all they were concerned was an immediate return to the PL so they could sell up, did they appoint a bloke who was probably going to need 12 months to get us playing 'his way'? Tells you all you need to know about the people making footballing decisions at the club.
Reply
#29
Bruce has the last few games to convince us he's going to change things. Starting by dropping the wasters. If he doesn't grasp the golden opportunity now, then I don't see why he needs to stay. If he can't change now he never will.
Reply
#30
(04-11-2022, 11:21 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Bruce has the last few games to convince us he's going to change things. Starting by dropping the wasters. If he doesn't grasp the golden opportunity now, then I don't see why he needs to stay. If he can't change now he never will.

Drop them for who? The kids! 

I don’t think we have Man U 1995 coming through and most youngsters loaned out go to League 1 or 2. That tells you of their development. 

Let’s just not over analyse the next few games and see what next season brings. 

The chances are extremely high Bruce will be here whether some like it or not.

I’m still in the give him a chance camp for the reasons I’ve stated.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)