Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
04-11-2022, 08:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2022, 08:46 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(04-11-2022, 08:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Granted he's not been able to bring in any of his own players but the fact he's arrived and ruined the only element of our team that did work, whilst not improving any of the other parts is enough to suggest he shouldn't be given the gig long term.
The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Granted he's not been able to bring in any of his own players but the fact he's arrived and ruined the only element of our team that did work, whilst not improving any of the other parts is enough to suggest he shouldn't be given the gig long term.
The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
We sacked our last manager just over halfway through the season though, so the same applies. Fair play he needs to try things out, but breaking the only part of our team that worked is inexcusable for me.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
04-11-2022, 09:05 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2022, 09:13 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(04-11-2022, 08:51 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Granted he's not been able to bring in any of his own players but the fact he's arrived and ruined the only element of our team that did work, whilst not improving any of the other parts is enough to suggest he shouldn't be given the gig long term.
The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
We sacked our last manager just over halfway through the season though, so the same applies. Fair play he needs to try things out, but breaking the only part of our team that worked is inexcusable for me.
Having no patience is inexcusable to me. It's endemic in a have it all now society.
Weirdly I was chatting to a mate on Saturday who was discussing this same topic. He's a Leeds fan and he said the shocking lack of patience and level of expectation crippled them for years, and also how people in their 30s generally seem to borrow much more than people a decade or two older as they want/expect now.
My view is simply managers used to be afforded more time. If we could turn the clock back to the mid 70s with that mindset of now Johnny Giles would have been bombed out by fans long before he turned things around. Sometimes things get worse before they get better.
Bruce is extremely well-connected and he's just recently spent a couple of years in one of the most high-pressurised clubs in the country. He deserves more respect and patience than he's getting by some.
There will be a line in the sand where we have to decide to take stock, but that has to be after a pre-season and about 15 games of a new season in the mind of any cool and calm decision maker rather than an emotional fan who instantly expects 2 years of rot to be turned around in a few weeks without even a transfer window.
Sorry, but it's completely irrational and ridiculous to want him out now.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
04-11-2022, 09:16 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2022, 09:28 AM by Ted Maul.)
(04-11-2022, 09:05 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Having no patience is inexcusable to me. It's endemic in a have it all now society.
Weirdly I was chatting to a mate on Saturday who was discussing this same topic. He's a Leeds fan and he said the shocking lack of patience and level of expectation crippled them for years, and also how people in their 30s seem to borrow much more than people a decade or two older.
My view is simply managers used to be afforded more time. If we could turn the clock back to the mid 70s with that mindset of now Johnny Giles would have been bombed out by fans long before he turned things around. Sometimes things get worse before they get better.
Bruce is extremely well-connected and he's just recently spent a couple of years in one of the most high-pressurised clubs in the country. He deserves more respect and patience than he's getting by some.
There will be a line in the sand where we have to decide to take stock, but that has to be after a pre-season and about 15 games of a new season in the mind of any cool and calm decision maker rather than an emotional fan who instantly expects 2 years of rot to be tuned around in a few weeks without even a transfer window.
Sorry, but it's completely irrational and ridiculous to want him out now.
We sacked our last manager after less than 30 games, so much for giving time. Corberan at Huddersfield has benefitted massively from a season to get his feet under the table, likewise Martin at Swansea is finishing the season strongly and will improve next season. Neither of those would have lasted the season with us. So shouting for Bruce to be given time all of a sudden is plain weird.
As far as I was aware, Bruce wasn't brought in to rebuild, he was given the job with the remit of halting the slide and ensuring we get in the POs. He broke the best defence in the league for no reason and hasn't been able to inject any impetus going forwards either. I've nothing against Bruce, but he's certainly not filled me with confidence thus far.
If we're looking for a rebuild there are better candidates out there who would be worth a long-term deal. Critchley at Blackpool and Manning from MK Dons would be top of my list and to be given at least a season.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
04-11-2022, 09:33 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2022, 09:38 AM by WorcsWBA.)
(04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
What is barmy and bewilderingly unreasonable is booing during the 7th game of the season when we were top of the league, but that's what happened. Contrast that to "Steve Bruce's barmy army" being sung on Saturday when we were pathetically losing to Stoke.
For someone who regularly criticises others' stats, you chuck out stuff like I've highlighted above - just to point out to you that we lost just 1 game in 8 from Nov 3rd to Dec 17th (Ismael was sacked after the Millwall game on Jan 29th) and had the best defensive record in the league almost up until when Ismael was sacked. Our problem was simply not scoring enough goals, plus a total lack of patience from many fans.
Someone with over 1000 games of managerial experience should be able to come in and improve results at a club quickly and certainly not make them worse. If Bruce had done that, I'd be happy for him to stay, but W3 D3 L6 (12 points out of 36) is relegation form and it's just not good enough, particularly when you consider the remit he had when he was appointed and his willingness to accept that remit. Combine that with what happened at Newcastle earlier in the season and there has to be concern that he's become a busted flush.
If he can't improve on results before the end of the season then my view is that he won't have done enough to deserve to stay.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-11-2022, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-11-2022, 09:05 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:51 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Granted he's not been able to bring in any of his own players but the fact he's arrived and ruined the only element of our team that did work, whilst not improving any of the other parts is enough to suggest he shouldn't be given the gig long term.
The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
We sacked our last manager just over halfway through the season though, so the same applies. Fair play he needs to try things out, but breaking the only part of our team that worked is inexcusable for me.
Having no patience is inexcusable to me. It's endemic in a have it all now society.
Weirdly I was chatting to a mate on Saturday who was discussing this same topic. He's a Leeds fan and he said the shocking lack of patience and level of expectation crippled them for years, and also how people in their 30s seem to borrow much more than people a decade or two older.
My view is simply managers used to be afforded more time. If we could turn the clock back to the mid 70s with that mindset of now Johnny Giles would have been bombed out by fans long before he turned things around. Sometimes things get worse before they get better.
Bruce is extremely well-connected and he's just recently spent a couple of years in one of the most high-pressurised clubs in the country. He deserves more respect and patience than he's getting by some.
There will be a line in the sand where we have to decide to take stock, but that has to be after a pre-season and about 15 games of a new season in the mind of any cool and calm decision maker rather than an emotional fan who instantly expects 2 years of rot to be tuned around in a few weeks without even a transfer window.
Sorry, but it's completely irrational and ridiculous to want him out now.
We sacked our last manager after less than 30 games, so much for giving time. Corberan at Huddersfield has benefitted massively from a season to get his feet under the table, likewise Martin at Swansea is finishing the season strongly and will improve next season. Neither of those would have lasted the season with us. So shouting for Bruce to be given time all of a sudden is plain weird.
As far as I was aware, Bruce wasn't brought in to rebuild, he was given the job with the remit of halting the slide and ensuring we get in the POs. He broke the best defence in the league for no reason and hasn't been able to inject any impetus going forwards either. I've nothing against Bruce, but he's certainly not filled me with confidence thus far.
If we're looking for a rebuild there are better candidates out there who would be worth a long-term deal. Critchley at Blackpool and Manning from MK Dons would be top of my list and to be given at least a season.
You clearly have something against him or are just an incredibly impatient character as you've given him no reasonable time or half a chance. Our last manager had 29 games, as you point out. Bruce has had 12! Our previous manager had a transfer window. Bruce hasn't. It's hardly like for like is it? If you read my post I said he needs a pre-season and 15 games. He'd then have about 30 matches and that's a decent spell to take stock.
Val had 30 odd games but it was obvious it was getting worse and worse.
Bruce might have been given a remit of getting us in the play-offs, but who honestly thought he would do it? I certainly thought it was unlikely. The club is in a malaise and it needs more time.
As for the defence being broke, that means it's beyond repair. It's not. We actually are scoring goals and are more of an attacking threat of late I'd argue.
However, I'll shelve all of this micro-analysis of now for the chance for Bruce to use his standing in the game to entice players to us and see what his players do.
If you recall when Megson turned us around 20 odd years ago he had the chance to get players in straight away. Bruce has the equivalent of that 2000 bunch of wasters under Little now, but no chance to refresh them with his own men.
I think the fans need a reset. I hope this basket case of a season will mean we have a little more patience next year and some fans may be a little more benevolent than you about what we are faced with.
Posts: 932
Threads: 58
Joined: Mar 2020
Reputation:
9
IIRC Megson’s early games weren’t great and he needed to sign 6 players in order to bomb a few out and limp us over the line to safety.
He then strengthened again to get us into the play offs and finally got us up after signing an entire new spine (Hoult, Bali’s, Moore, Gilchrist, McInnes plus Roberts & Dichio).
The smell of decline weighs heavy on a club that’s become shrouded in negativity. The bounce back won’t happen overnight and certainly won’t be easy. The rot was set long before Bruce got here, even Ismael’s signing have proven to be pretty woeful.
This summer is absolutely huge and will determine if we are here to stay for many years or turn it around. We’re pretty wealthy by championship standards, so it’s down to foresight and good recruitment in critical areas.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-11-2022, 09:33 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
What is barmy and bewilderingly unreasonable is booing during the 7th game of the season when we were top of the league, but that's what happened.
For someone who criticises others' stats, you chuck out stuff like I've highlighted above - just to point out to you that we lost just 1 game in 8 from Nov 3rd to Dec 17th (Ismael was sacked after the Millwall game on Jan 29th) and had the best defensive record in the league almost up until when Ismael was sacked. Our problem was simply not scoring enough goals, plus a total lack of patience from many fans.
Someone with over 1000 games of managerial experience should be able to come in and improve results at a club quickly and certainly not make them worse. If Bruce had done that, I'd be happy for him to stay, but W3 D3 L6 (12 points out of 36) is relegation form and it's just not good enough, particularly when you consider the remit he had when he was appointed and his willingness to accept that remit. Combine that with what happened at Newcastle earlier in the season and there has to be concern that he's become a busted flush.
If he can't improve on results before the end of the season then my view is that he doesn't deserve to stay. There will always be extremes of fans like spanners who boo when we are still doing well. Don't take them as the majority. Most are patient.
You can draw little demarcation lines all over the place Worcs, as you do for your somehow strange obsession with Val's tenure. Simply he was sacked after 19 games of a massive downturn in form, after a great start. It didn't surprise barely any fans as the wheels had clearly come off.
Also, most fans wanted him to succeed. It was obvious though after the fall outs with players and abysmal performance v Preston he was finished. He still then got the Millwall game and we know what happened there and there was fan disruption too. It had become a very poor situation.
Bruce might be a busted flush as you say, but I'm willing to give him at least the same time to see if he is as the club did for Val.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-11-2022, 08:51 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-11-2022, 08:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Granted he's not been able to bring in any of his own players but the fact he's arrived and ruined the only element of our team that did work, whilst not improving any of the other parts is enough to suggest he shouldn't be given the gig long term.
The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
We sacked our last manager just over halfway through the season though, so the same applies. Fair play he needs to try things out, but breaking the only part of our team that worked is inexcusable for me.
We couldn’t score goals and no amount of nonsense stats changed the fact we created relatively poor opportunities. To try and change this, Bruce has tried different ways to make us more attacking but inevitably that has meant the defence not being as solid as it was. We had one way to play under Val underlined by the lack of different and creative options in midfield. Sadly this has hampered us all season. Our only options to change things on Sat was to go from two up front to three and lose a runaround a lot player in midfield. That’s the choices left open to Bruce.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Sorry Ted can’t agree, any new manager coming in at the end of season would have to look at the players already here to give him an idea who to keep and who to let go, so that is a lot of pre season wasted particularly as the pre season is short this year. Then you have to see what players are available to you who others haven’t snapped up while the new manager is sussing out the squad. Non of this now applies to Bruce as the work is already done or being done. He and the CEO will now have a list of players they want and they certainly know which wasters they want out the door. So for me as long as he doesn’t have a terrible end to season { who knows with this bunch of wasters } the job is his until at least xmas. As good a manager as all of Critchley, Manning and Robins are and I like those 3 they will not have the pulling power of Bruce.
|