Fuck Bruce off now
His success in this league was many years ago. His last spell of any length had him taking Villa into the bottom half of the table despite spending a lot of money. The much derided Smith took that same team to promotion.
His current form is exactly that - current. We have shown no improvement under Bruce in fact in terms of shots on goal, chances created and goals conceded we have got considerably worse and have no discernible pattern of play. He refuses to play O’Shea, picks players out of position (TGH, Diangana) and discards the younger players after giving them 10 minutes (Tulloch, Castro, Fellows) but continues to select the same old failures. We need a complete reset in terms of players ( difficult given their contracts) and playing style. I don’t expect us to go up next year whoever is manager but I do expect us to develop some form of playing identity. I don’t think Bruce is the man to do this.
Reply
(04-10-2022, 03:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 03:10 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two or was it three seasons ago Appleton was the young hungry manager we needed and now? Nothing, yesterdays young hungry manager, discarded like an old sock. We really aren’t financially in a position to take gambles on managers until we have nothing to lose.

Incidentally the mighty Imps are 18th league one!

Appleton has been receiving treatment for testicular cancer this season.

I did not know that apologies for my ignorance. I hope he makes a speedy and full recovery. 

I used Appleton as an example of younger managers that gets a lot of support due to one decent season and then fall away in popularity if the next one or two aren’t as good. We don’t have the luxury to take the risk and as we have seen with Val it’s not necessarily a good move for the manager either.

Not advocating Appleton btw, but to be fair it is more than one decent season.
Reply
I’m being serious here but have you watched Steve Bruce teams play over the last few years?It really is sit back football and the type of football that won’t get you anywhere now.The teams at the top are front foot attacking possession based teams and he isn’t capable of this.Every manager is a gamble but for gods sake let’s stick with a policy of what the top teams in the Division are doing and can I say Swansea have decided that they are going down this route and although they won’t go up this season they look as if they have a plan to go forward and they should stick to this.
Reply
(04-10-2022, 04:10 PM)Sliced Wrote: There seems to be a select few that can't stand Val so much that they take every comment against Bruce as a comment that's pro-Val. I was absolutely 100% of the opinion that Bruce should stay beyond the summer prior to his appointment. However, he's been fundamentally much worse than I expected. If we had cracked on after the Fulham game then I'd been absolutely behind him.

However, when I weight up why Bruce should stay, absolutely everything in the positive column is based upon historical performance:
He knows the league, he's done well in it before, he has contacts which will help us immensely in the loan market.

Every single negative is around his current performance; a reluctance to change things when they are stale, poor performances in almost every game, seemingly not having any idea of our best way to play.

So I'm torn.

You are Natalia Imbruglia and i claim my five pounds!

Hopefully we've got Farke lined up, Bruce has done worse than i thought he would...
Reply
(04-10-2022, 06:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 04:10 PM)Sliced Wrote: There seems to be a select few that can't stand Val so much that they take every comment against Bruce as a comment that's pro-Val. I was absolutely 100% of the opinion that Bruce should stay beyond the summer prior to his appointment. However, he's been fundamentally much worse than I expected. If we had cracked on after the Fulham game then I'd been absolutely behind him.

However, when I weight up why Bruce should stay, absolutely everything in the positive column is based upon historical performance:
He knows the league, he's done well in it before, he has contacts which will help us immensely in the loan market.

Every single negative is around his current performance; a reluctance to change things when they are stale, poor performances in almost every game, seemingly not having any idea of our best way to play.

So I'm torn.

You are Natalia Imbruglia and i claim my five pounds!

Hopefully we've got Farke lined up, Bruce has done worse than i thought he would...

I think we would all like to see Slice lying naked on the floor.
Reply
(04-10-2022, 06:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 06:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 04:10 PM)Sliced Wrote: There seems to be a select few that can't stand Val so much that they take every comment against Bruce as a comment that's pro-Val. I was absolutely 100% of the opinion that Bruce should stay beyond the summer prior to his appointment. However, he's been fundamentally much worse than I expected. If we had cracked on after the Fulham game then I'd been absolutely behind him.

However, when I weight up why Bruce should stay, absolutely everything in the positive column is based upon historical performance:
He knows the league, he's done well in it before, he has contacts which will help us immensely in the loan market.

Every single negative is around his current performance; a reluctance to change things when they are stale, poor performances in almost every game, seemingly not having any idea of our best way to play.

So I'm torn.

You are Natalia Imbruglia and i claim my five pounds!

Hopefully we've got Farke lined up, Bruce has done worse than i thought he would...

I think we would all like to see Slice lying naked on the floor.

I have no idea how to react to that Big Grin
Reply
Simply Bruce has said he wants new players. Allie him this and let’s see what happens in the first 15 games of the season.

Not allowing that small measure of patience shows ridiculous impatience.
Reply
(04-10-2022, 01:48 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 12:51 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I had the misfortune of sitting with Stoke fans in corporate yesterday and he couldn’t believe how placid we were and why we would stand off a Stoke side who were out of form and below us in the league

Alas a combination of Bruce tactics and hopeless footballer tells you everything as I said one thing we did do under Val was play high and press, we’ve just lost everything currently

Cuzer

What press under Val? I’m sorry but from Peterborough(a) game onwards, the press had disappeared. It went the same way as the results. Right call to chop Val but worryingly we’ve seen no improvement from his successor and the football looks exactly the same to me. Lacking energy, pace and creativity.
You can't polish a turd.
Reply
(04-10-2022, 06:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(04-10-2022, 04:10 PM)Sliced Wrote: There seems to be a select few that can't stand Val so much that they take every comment against Bruce as a comment that's pro-Val. I was absolutely 100% of the opinion that Bruce should stay beyond the summer prior to his appointment. However, he's been fundamentally much worse than I expected. If we had cracked on after the Fulham game then I'd been absolutely behind him.

However, when I weight up why Bruce should stay, absolutely everything in the positive column is based upon historical performance:
He knows the league, he's done well in it before, he has contacts which will help us immensely in the loan market.

Every single negative is around his current performance; a reluctance to change things when they are stale, poor performances in almost every game, seemingly not having any idea of our best way to play.

So I'm torn.

You are Natalia Imbruglia and i claim my five pounds!

Hopefully we've got Farke lined up, Bruce has done worse than i thought he would...

Think we are too much of a state for Farke, and there’s no way this group would tolerate all that pesky running he’s expect. He was also heavily reliant on Webber for recruitment, our next manager needs a decent little black book.

I’m not off the idea of Appleton still… he’d take no prisoners with this lot, and he’ll have amassed a decent knowledge of lower league players and is highly regarded when it comes to attracting youth players, he’s had some very good loans at the Imps. 

Easy to say “oh they’re 18th” but for a club of their size, and I imagine budget, that’s not a bad place to be… they’ve also had a lot of injuries and his own personal circumstances to deal with.
Reply
A gentle bump

Nothing since the original post has changed my opinion

I feel sorry for Bruce, he clearly cares, is trying and is being let down by the gutless players, so many want out, so many need to go

Team tonight, moving Reach back into midfield, he openly came out and said he tried him there and it hadn’t worked, well why try it again?
Mowatt back in? Again looks dead on his feet after 20 minutes

Mistake after mistake after mistake

Gourlay is/was desperate for Bruce to do well and get next season, he’s a big call to make now IMO as attendances will drop without a summer window to be excited about and if we have a poor start Bruce is toast and we’re even deeper in the shit

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: