Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-10-2022, 02:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2022, 02:54 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
Two or was it three seasons ago Appleton was the young hungry manager we needed and now? Nothing, yesterdays young hungry manager, discarded like an old sock. We really aren’t financially in a position to take gambles on managers until we have nothing to lose.
Incidentally the mighty Imps are 18th league one!
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(04-10-2022, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two or was it three seasons ago Appleton was the young hungry manager we needed and now? Nothing, yesterdays young hungry manager, discarded like an old sock. We really aren’t financially in a position to take gambles on managers until we have nothing to lose.
Incidentally the mighty Imps are 18th league one!
Appleton has been receiving treatment for testicular cancer this season.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-10-2022, 10:02 AM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:11 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We cannot keep changing managers every 6 months. That’s the route to constant failure. Steve Bruce is a very experienced and successful manager at this level. He knows exactly what he needs to rebuild this squad, and he knows who he needs to offload. Any new manager would have to go through that player assessment process. A pointless exercise.
We have nearly £40m coming as the final installment of our parachute payments. Steve Bruce and RG know that some of that money will have to be used to pay off some of these players. That leaves less to spend on transfer fees. But it still leaves plenty to sign Bosmans and loan players, plus very good young players from the Championship and below. That’s what needs to be done and one hopes that we are ready to pounce - which yet another new manager would not be.
Steve Bruce has to be given the chance to discard, replace and rebuild. He has to be give the next two transfer windows and next season to rebuild. His playing style is not “extreme” so if it doesn’t work out then he won’t have built a squad unable to adapt to the next manager.
Over the past 3 months he’s had to deal with and shuffle the badly unbalanced pack that he was dealt. There are times when we haven’t agreed with his selections, there have been some good performances and some poor performances, but this is not HIS squad.
Every time we drive a manager out and restart the clock we set the whole process back, making it even harder to move forward. We need to back a decent experienced manager, one who knows what it takes, to carry out the rebuild and give him as many of the resources needed as possible.
Let’s get behind him. I think by the end of this summer’s transfer window this squad will look materially different.
This the most sensible post I’ve seen for a while, agree with all Prag has said we cannot keep going down the sack line.
It's what all sensible fans think.
It's hard trying to converse with those wanting Bruce out- it's like they're covid deniers.
Bruce has had 12 games with a squad he hasn't had a chance to refresh, that has been going backwards for 2 years. However, despite the clear problem with the squad so many whine sack him.
They'll be lots of players out of contract this season and we are still a big draw in this division at the minute.Allow us to get in 5 or 6 then let's see what happens.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(04-10-2022, 03:13 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-10-2022, 10:02 AM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:11 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We cannot keep changing managers every 6 months. That’s the route to constant failure. Steve Bruce is a very experienced and successful manager at this level. He knows exactly what he needs to rebuild this squad, and he knows who he needs to offload. Any new manager would have to go through that player assessment process. A pointless exercise.
We have nearly £40m coming as the final installment of our parachute payments. Steve Bruce and RG know that some of that money will have to be used to pay off some of these players. That leaves less to spend on transfer fees. But it still leaves plenty to sign Bosmans and loan players, plus very good young players from the Championship and below. That’s what needs to be done and one hopes that we are ready to pounce - which yet another new manager would not be.
Steve Bruce has to be given the chance to discard, replace and rebuild. He has to be give the next two transfer windows and next season to rebuild. His playing style is not “extreme” so if it doesn’t work out then he won’t have built a squad unable to adapt to the next manager.
Over the past 3 months he’s had to deal with and shuffle the badly unbalanced pack that he was dealt. There are times when we haven’t agreed with his selections, there have been some good performances and some poor performances, but this is not HIS squad.
Every time we drive a manager out and restart the clock we set the whole process back, making it even harder to move forward. We need to back a decent experienced manager, one who knows what it takes, to carry out the rebuild and give him as many of the resources needed as possible.
Let’s get behind him. I think by the end of this summer’s transfer window this squad will look materially different.
This the most sensible post I’ve seen for a while, agree with all Prag has said we cannot keep going down the sack line.
It's what all sensible fans think.
It's hard trying to converse with those wanting Bruce out- it's like they're covid deniers.
Bruce has had 12 games with a squad he hasn't had a chance to refresh, that has been going backwards for 2 years. However, despite the clear problem with the squad so many whine sack him.
They'll be lots of players out of contract this season and we are still a big draw in this division at the minute.Allow us to get in 5 or 6 then let's see what happens.
There is no way we are getting five or six players in without a similar number going out of the door first and most of the team have got at least a year on their contract.
Nobody is playing better under Bruce and the the team don't look any better organised or set up. We were completely overrun in midfield first half and he did nothing to change it until nearly sixty minutes had passed.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(04-10-2022, 03:13 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It's hard trying to converse with those wanting Bruce out- it's like they're covid deniers.
I think some of us would have liked a manager who was brought in with the specific remit to improve our promotion bid this season not to have lost twice as many games as he's won, whilst showing no vision or willingness to deal with very obvious problems.
Perhaps we're old-fashioned....
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-10-2022, 03:10 PM)Squid Wrote: (04-10-2022, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two or was it three seasons ago Appleton was the young hungry manager we needed and now? Nothing, yesterdays young hungry manager, discarded like an old sock. We really aren’t financially in a position to take gambles on managers until we have nothing to lose.
Incidentally the mighty Imps are 18th league one!
Appleton has been receiving treatment for testicular cancer this season.
I did not know that apologies for my ignorance. I hope he makes a speedy and full recovery.
I used Appleton as an example of younger managers that gets a lot of support due to one decent season and then fall away in popularity if the next one or two aren’t as good. We don’t have the luxury to take the risk and as we have seen with Val it’s not necessarily a good move for the manager either.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Derek Hardballs Wrote:Squid Wrote:Derek Hardballs Wrote:Two or was it three seasons ago Appleton was the young hungry manager we needed and now? Nothing, yesterdays young hungry manager, discarded like an old sock. We really aren’t financially in a position to take gambles on managers until we have nothing to lose.
Incidentally the mighty Imps are 18th league one!
Appleton has been receiving treatment for testicular cancer this season.
I did not know that apologies for my ignorance. I hope he makes a speedy and full recovery.
I used Appleton as an example of younger managers that gets a lot of support due to one decent season and then fall away in popularity if the next one or two aren’t as good. We don’t have the luxury to take the risk and as we have seen with Val it’s not necessarily a good move for the manager either.
We don't have the luxury of a spare horse to change to midstream, either. After an appointment, we need to back the manager. Allardyce was too experienced and asked exactly where he stood re backing. Val was naïve, (his 3 transfer window thing was clearly about clearing the under-performers, in hindsight), he also thought we would get by ok until Dike arrived. Meanwhile, Bruce thought our players should be better and it was an easy fix. I'm tempted to go over to Warwick Baggies this week to see if Gourlay has any idea how to go forwards.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-10-2022, 03:45 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Derek Hardballs Wrote:Squid Wrote:Derek Hardballs Wrote:Two or was it three seasons ago Appleton was the young hungry manager we needed and now? Nothing, yesterdays young hungry manager, discarded like an old sock. We really aren’t financially in a position to take gambles on managers until we have nothing to lose.
Incidentally the mighty Imps are 18th league one!
Appleton has been receiving treatment for testicular cancer this season.
I did not know that apologies for my ignorance. I hope he makes a speedy and full recovery.
I used Appleton as an example of younger managers that gets a lot of support due to one decent season and then fall away in popularity if the next one or two aren’t as good. We don’t have the luxury to take the risk and as we have seen with Val it’s not necessarily a good move for the manager either.
We don't have the luxury of a spare horse to change to midstream, either. After an appointment, we need to back the manager. Allardyce was too experienced and asked exactly where he stood re backing. Val was naïve, (his 3 transfer window thing was clearly about clearing the under-performers, in hindsight), he also thought we would get by ok until Dike arrived. Meanwhile, Bruce thought our players should be better and it was an easy fix. I'm tempted to go over to Warwick Baggies this week to see if Gourlay has any idea how to go forwards.
My opinion is to keep Bruce.
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
04-10-2022, 03:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2022, 03:54 PM by baggiebuckster.)
The argument I keep on hearing for retaining Bruce is based around the fact that he has now seen the wasters and will know who needs replacing in the summer. If a new manager comes in then there is a danger that everyone will start with a clean slate and by the time the wasters down tools in September it will be too late to change anything.
It is a fair point but is also a thoroughly depressing state of affairs that the argument for keeping a manager is nothing to do with any signs of improvement that he has presided over. By that logic I could be in the running as I have seen these players repeatedly fail to perform for a lot longer than Bruce has.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
There seems to be a select few that can't stand Val so much that they take every comment against Bruce as a comment that's pro-Val. I was absolutely 100% of the opinion that Bruce should stay beyond the summer prior to his appointment. However, he's been fundamentally much worse than I expected. If we had cracked on after the Fulham game then I'd been absolutely behind him.
However, when I weight up why Bruce should stay, absolutely everything in the positive column is based upon historical performance:
He knows the league, he's done well in it before, he has contacts which will help us immensely in the loan market.
Every single negative is around his current performance; a reluctance to change things when they are stale, poor performances in almost every game, seemingly not having any idea of our best way to play.
So I'm torn.
|