Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
Madeley posted this after the Bournemouth game.
"West Brom job for next season is now Bruce's to lose."
3 DAYS AGO | By Steve Madeley | The Athletic
With 12 minutes remaining of a night that was uplifting and infuriating in equal measure, the Smethwick End at The Hawthorns broke into song. A chorus of "Brucey, Brucey give us a wave" was followed by a spirited rendition of "Steve Bruce's Barmy Army." It was not a definitive vote of confidence in the West Bromwich Albion manager, but it was telling nonetheless.
3 days is a fucking long time in football.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(04-10-2022, 09:51 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Derek Hardballs Wrote:Pragmatist Wrote:Huggybear Wrote:Pragmatist Wrote:We cannot keep changing managers every 6 months. That’s the route to constant failure. Steve Bruce is a very experienced and successful manager at this level. He knows exactly what he needs to rebuild this squad, and he knows who he needs to offload. Any new manager would have to go through that player assessment process. A pointless exercise.
We have nearly £40m coming as the final installment of our parachute payments. Steve Bruce and RG know that some of that money will have to be used to pay off some of these players. That leaves less to spend on transfer fees. But it still leaves plenty to sign Bosmans and loan players, plus very good young players from the Championship and below. That’s what needs to be done and one hopes that we are ready to pounce - which yet another new manager would not be.
Steve Bruce has to be given the chance to discard, replace and rebuild. He has to be give the next two transfer windows and next season to rebuild. His playing style is not “extreme” so if it doesn’t work out then he won’t have built a squad unable to adapt to the next manager.
Over the past 3 months he’s had to deal with and shuffle the badly unbalanced pack that he was dealt. There are times when we haven’t agreed with his selections, there have been some good performances and some poor performances, but this is not HIS squad.
Every time we drive a manager out and restart the clock we set the whole process back, making it even harder to move forward. We need to back a decent experienced manager, one who knows what it takes, to carry out the rebuild and give him as many of the resources needed as possible.
Let’s get behind him. I think by the end of this summer’s transfer window this squad will look materially different. I agree we can’t keep changing manager every six months but give Bruce the start of next season and I don’t think he will last three months,that’s why we need a reset at the end of the season.I have no doubt that Bruce could sign and rejig the squad but he can’t coach which is really important.The coaching and organisation is of no surprise to me and shouldn’t be to anyone,take yesterday’s match,it was the slowest sidewards backwards passing I’ve ever seen and then the last 25 minutes turned into what I can only describe as industrial football.There was no game plan at all and walking out the ground I had fans saying to me that if Bruce is here next season then they won’t and you could see the genuine hurt and anger on there faces.
Do we blame Bruce and his coaching for our defence switching off twice at free kicks and then being left to chase the game?
To say he “can’t coach” is ridiculous. How many teams has he got promoted from this division? Does that happen by accident? This is not his squad. He deserves a chance to restructure it.
You can guarantee that if he goes now, a new manager will come in and want to take a look at what he’s got. Another season (and parachute funding) wasted. We don’t have time for that.
Come on now Prag you know this places rules…
Managers who play easy on the eye football… free pass for two or three year projects
Managers who are between 40-55 are young and hungry and are again given two or three year projects
Managers like Bruce who are fashionable and don’t fit into the Guardian / Telegraph football supplements whose hot and not section are given a few months, no transfer window and no excuses. Wrong DH, all managers at the Albion are only given a few months. If we could have shown intent we would have Allardyce (who despite people's ideas on here, actually knows a thing or two), or thrown some weight behind the last manager when his players down tooled. This short termism is doing the club no favours. Remember Johnny Giles remarking how patient Albion fans were when he struggled for 2 months to find his first win? Now we have the same levels of entitlement that we have always scoffed at our neighbours for. For me, the jury is still out on Bruce, understandably as we are so inconsistent. It's a simple solution though, if there is someone better, that's where we go, if not, we back him to clear out the losing mentality. Whatever, the club MUST back the manager.
Allardyce is a good manager and Bruce isn’t ,it really is that simple.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-10-2022, 10:11 AM)Huggybear Wrote: (04-10-2022, 09:51 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Derek Hardballs Wrote:Pragmatist Wrote:Huggybear Wrote:I agree we can’t keep changing manager every six months but give Bruce the start of next season and I don’t think he will last three months,that’s why we need a reset at the end of the season.I have no doubt that Bruce could sign and rejig the squad but he can’t coach which is really important.The coaching and organisation is of no surprise to me and shouldn’t be to anyone,take yesterday’s match,it was the slowest sidewards backwards passing I’ve ever seen and then the last 25 minutes turned into what I can only describe as industrial football.There was no game plan at all and walking out the ground I had fans saying to me that if Bruce is here next season then they won’t and you could see the genuine hurt and anger on there faces.
Do we blame Bruce and his coaching for our defence switching off twice at free kicks and then being left to chase the game?
To say he “can’t coach” is ridiculous. How many teams has he got promoted from this division? Does that happen by accident? This is not his squad. He deserves a chance to restructure it.
You can guarantee that if he goes now, a new manager will come in and want to take a look at what he’s got. Another season (and parachute funding) wasted. We don’t have time for that.
Come on now Prag you know this places rules…
Managers who play easy on the eye football… free pass for two or three year projects
Managers who are between 40-55 are young and hungry and are again given two or three year projects
Managers like Bruce who are fashionable and don’t fit into the Guardian / Telegraph football supplements whose hot and not section are given a few months, no transfer window and no excuses. Wrong DH, all managers at the Albion are only given a few months. If we could have shown intent we would have Allardyce (who despite people's ideas on here, actually knows a thing or two), or thrown some weight behind the last manager when his players down tooled. This short termism is doing the club no favours. Remember Johnny Giles remarking how patient Albion fans were when he struggled for 2 months to find his first win? Now we have the same levels of entitlement that we have always scoffed at our neighbours for. For me, the jury is still out on Bruce, understandably as we are so inconsistent. It's a simple solution though, if there is someone better, that's where we go, if not, we back him to clear out the losing mentality. Whatever, the club MUST back the manager.
Allardyce is a good manager and Bruce isn’t ,it really is that simple.
Allardyce left and Bruce’s CV is worse than which alternatives?
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(04-10-2022, 08:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:28 AM)Cuzer Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:11 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We cannot keep changing managers every 6 months. That’s the route to constant failure. Steve Bruce is a very experienced and successful manager at this level. He knows exactly what he needs to rebuild this squad, and he knows who he needs to offload. Any new manager would have to go through that player assessment process. A pointless exercise.
We have nearly £40m coming as the final installment of our parachute payments. Steve Bruce and RG know that some of that money will have to be used to pay off some of these players. That leaves less to spend on transfer fees. But it still leaves plenty to sign Bosmans and loan players, plus very good young players from the Championship and below. That’s what needs to be done and one hopes that we are ready to pounce - which yet another new manager would not be.
Steve Bruce has to be given the chance to discard, replace and rebuild. He has to be give the next two transfer windows and next season to rebuild. His playing style is not “extreme” so if it doesn’t work out then he won’t have built a squad unable to adapt to the next manager.
Over the past 3 months he’s had to deal with and shuffle the badly unbalanced pack that he was dealt. There are times when we haven’t agreed with his selections, there have been some good performances and some poor performances, but this is not HIS squad.
Every time we drive a manager out and restart the clock we set the whole process back, making it even harder to move forward. We need to back a decent experienced manager, one who knows what it takes, to carry out the rebuild and give him as many of the resources needed as possible.
Let’s get behind him. I think by the end of this summer’s transfer window this squad will look materially different.
You make a lot of sense but Bruce for me has shown nothing to say he’s the man to rebuild us, he’s a dated manager with a dated successful record
He’s made us worse, much worse than where we were previously when no patience was shown, why is this bloke the answer?
You know if we’re 10th after 8 games next season he will be gone and then we are rebuilding during a season again , should be brave and make the call this summer
Cuzer
I think you are completely under-estimating the scale of the task of rebuilding the confidence of the squad demoralised by Val-ball, coupled with too many of the squad needing spinal implants and new testicles.
In hindsight, an expectation of a “new manager bounce” was unrealistic.
Dear me, really?
The players downed tools for the previous manager because he demanded expectations of them, what a poor bunch of souls they are
Parasites the majority of them, to think SJ had a hissy fit which in large led to that PNE performance, then the poor show at Milwall before Val got the heave ho, all the while knowing he had no passion for the club and every desire to leave on a free whilst stringing us along doesn't sit well with me one iota!
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(04-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Cuzer Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:28 AM)Cuzer Wrote: (04-10-2022, 08:11 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We cannot keep changing managers every 6 months. That’s the route to constant failure. Steve Bruce is a very experienced and successful manager at this level. He knows exactly what he needs to rebuild this squad, and he knows who he needs to offload. Any new manager would have to go through that player assessment process. A pointless exercise.
We have nearly £40m coming as the final installment of our parachute payments. Steve Bruce and RG know that some of that money will have to be used to pay off some of these players. That leaves less to spend on transfer fees. But it still leaves plenty to sign Bosmans and loan players, plus very good young players from the Championship and below. That’s what needs to be done and one hopes that we are ready to pounce - which yet another new manager would not be.
Steve Bruce has to be given the chance to discard, replace and rebuild. He has to be give the next two transfer windows and next season to rebuild. His playing style is not “extreme” so if it doesn’t work out then he won’t have built a squad unable to adapt to the next manager.
Over the past 3 months he’s had to deal with and shuffle the badly unbalanced pack that he was dealt. There are times when we haven’t agreed with his selections, there have been some good performances and some poor performances, but this is not HIS squad.
Every time we drive a manager out and restart the clock we set the whole process back, making it even harder to move forward. We need to back a decent experienced manager, one who knows what it takes, to carry out the rebuild and give him as many of the resources needed as possible.
Let’s get behind him. I think by the end of this summer’s transfer window this squad will look materially different.
You make a lot of sense but Bruce for me has shown nothing to say he’s the man to rebuild us, he’s a dated manager with a dated successful record
He’s made us worse, much worse than where we were previously when no patience was shown, why is this bloke the answer?
You know if we’re 10th after 8 games next season he will be gone and then we are rebuilding during a season again , should be brave and make the call this summer
Cuzer
I think you are completely under-estimating the scale of the task of rebuilding the confidence of the squad demoralised by Val-ball, coupled with too many of the squad needing spinal implants and new testicles.
In hindsight, an expectation of a “new manager bounce” was unrealistic.
Dear me, really?
The players downed tools for the previous manager because he demanded expectations of them, what a poor bunch of souls they are
Parasites the majority of them, to think SJ had a hissy fit which in large led to that PNE performance, then the poor show at Milwall before Val got the heave ho, all the while knowing he had no passion for the club and every desire to leave on a free whilst stringing us along doesn't sit well with me one iota!
Cuzer
The situation with SJ has, I feel, been awful. The hissy fit, for me, should have meant he never played for us again. Since the play offs became unlikely, why keep picking a bloke who we know won`t be here next season ? Will Button, a capable deputy, want to extend his contract, I would imagine so, as, if he leaves us no one else will want to pay what he is on here. I would drop SJ and give Button / Palmer the last few games.
Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
04-10-2022, 10:41 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2022, 10:52 AM by EastMidsBaggie.)
Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:Cuzer Wrote:Pragmatist Wrote:Cuzer Wrote:Pragmatist Wrote:We cannot keep changing managers every 6 months. That’s the route to constant failure. Steve Bruce is a very experienced and successful manager at this level. He knows exactly what he needs to rebuild this squad, and he knows who he needs to offload. Any new manager would have to go through that player assessment process. A pointless exercise.
We have nearly £40m coming as the final installment of our parachute payments. Steve Bruce and RG know that some of that money will have to be used to pay off some of these players. That leaves less to spend on transfer fees. But it still leaves plenty to sign Bosmans and loan players, plus very good young players from the Championship and below. That’s what needs to be done and one hopes that we are ready to pounce - which yet another new manager would not be.
Steve Bruce has to be given the chance to discard, replace and rebuild. He has to be give the next two transfer windows and next season to rebuild. His playing style is not “extreme” so if it doesn’t work out then he won’t have built a squad unable to adapt to the next manager.
Over the past 3 months he’s had to deal with and shuffle the badly unbalanced pack that he was dealt. There are times when we haven’t agreed with his selections, there have been some good performances and some poor performances, but this is not HIS squad.
Every time we drive a manager out and restart the clock we set the whole process back, making it even harder to move forward. We need to back a decent experienced manager, one who knows what it takes, to carry out the rebuild and give him as many of the resources needed as possible.
Let’s get behind him. I think by the end of this summer’s transfer window this squad will look materially different.
You make a lot of sense but Bruce for me has shown nothing to say he’s the man to rebuild us, he’s a dated manager with a dated successful record
He’s made us worse, much worse than where we were previously when no patience was shown, why is this bloke the answer?
You know if we’re 10th after 8 games next season he will be gone and then we are rebuilding during a season again , should be brave and make the call this summer
Cuzer
I think you are completely under-estimating the scale of the task of rebuilding the confidence of the squad demoralised by Val-ball, coupled with too many of the squad needing spinal implants and new testicles.
In hindsight, an expectation of a “new manager bounce” was unrealistic.
Dear me, really?
The players downed tools for the previous manager because he demanded expectations of them, what a poor bunch of souls they are
Parasites the majority of them, to think SJ had a hissy fit which in large led to that PNE performance, then the poor show at Milwall before Val got the heave ho, all the while knowing he had no passion for the club and every desire to leave on a free whilst stringing us along doesn't sit well with me one iota!
Cuzer
The situation with SJ has, I feel, been awful. The hissy fit, for me, should have meant he never played for us again. Since the play offs became unlikely, why keep picking a bloke who we know won`t be here next season ? Will Button, a capable deputy, want to extend his contract, I would imagine so, as, if he leaves us no one else will want to pay what he is on here. I would drop SJ and give Button / Palmer the last few games.
Agreed, don't want to see him play for us again. He's not been very good overall anyway this season bar a few stellar games.
WorcsWBA Wrote:EastMidsBaggie Wrote:SO Brucie's reign so far:
PLAYED 12
WON 3
DREW 3
LOST 6
Points 12 out of 36 ! (45 points when he took over , now on 57)
GOALS: FOR 11 , AGNST 16
League position: 9th to 11th
Unfortunately, no new manager bounce and the facts make depressing reading...
We were actually 5th when he took over. It's worth reminding ourselves what Gourlay said at the time Bruce was appointed: "His excellent man-management skills, tactical nous, and ability to hit the ground running were among the many reasons we decided he was the man to take us forward. Promotion remains our objective for this season, and we are confident that with Steve leading the club we have given ourselves every chance of achieving that goal."
As for Bruce, he said: "I am coming in with one aim and that is to get Albion to the Premier League....to the supporters, I hope I can give them the results and find the style of play that they can associate with, and I’m sure that like most supporters even more so here, they want to see their team play with a bit of heart, a bit of passion, and a bit of spirit".
12 games in and absolutely none of the above have happened, quite the opposite in fact.
Correct, we were fifth directly after the Millwall game.
We dropped to 9th after the fist Bruce game at Sheff Utd.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I don’t know how Bruce does change our performances - to wha? We have nothing, nothing in midfield to play through. He’s tried 1,2 and 3 up front and different combinations. We chuck in a good performance and think “ah, he’s found it” and then the next game is back to shite.
We were only 5the due to games in hand for other clubs, we’d fallen well off the pace months before.
Bruce’s record at Newcastle in the 2 seasons were identical to the much lauded Benitez’s, he just didn’t make snidely digs at Ashley to make the fans love him.
I don’t see why he’s outdated at 61. He has, so I’m led to believe, good contacts at many clubs and one of the few people at the club who have footballing knowledge.
I’ve yet to be given a name we should try and get in the summer that makes me feel any more confident that Bruce. The good thing we have now is that he’s seen the players, saying the right things and appears aware of the problems. Many of the problems cannot be fixed from within the current squad so I’m not sure what people expect.
I don’t want a new manager taking the first 10 games to recognise that Mowatt hides, that Ajayi has brain farts, Bartley doesn’t lead and boss the defence, that Robinson has the heart of a pea and all his flicks and fancy-dan stuff works once every 8 games, that Livermore simply doesn’t have the legs to do anything other than shield a back 3,that the midfield cannot function without 3 in there and that Grant offers nothing apart from a penalty taker and a cut-in and shot from the left. I believe Bruce knows most of this and, yes, he could have done a bit better, but I’ve no idea how I would ask this lot to play, formations are one thing but we’re unable to press and unable to keep possession. The squad is too imbalanced.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 830
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
04-10-2022, 11:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2022, 11:21 AM by Artist.)
Heckingbottom, Cooper and Wilder have all turned around teams that were in deep decline this season alone, don't get this impossible job idea.
Bruce has had borderline relegation form, he has been a disaster. Everything we feared could go wrong with his appointment has happened, that he is negative, out of ideas, clueless with tactics etc. If his reign was an audition he would have failed miserably, yet some people want to keep him on. Continuity alone is nowhere near enough of a reason to override awful performance.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(04-10-2022, 11:20 AM)Artist Wrote: Heckingbottom, Cooper and Wilder have all turned around teams that were in deep decline this season alone, don't get this impossible job idea.
Bruce has had borderline relegation form, he has been a disaster. Everything we feared could go wrong with his appointment has happened, that he is negative, out of ideas, clueless with tactics etc. If his reign was an audition he would have failed miserably, yet some people want to keep him on. Continuity alone is nowhere near enough of a reason to override awful performance.
I look at our squad and I don't see how anyone gets anything from it, that's why I don't really blame Bruce or Val.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
04-10-2022, 11:28 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2022, 11:29 AM by Big Daddy Cool.)
Bruce, Val, Allardyce and Bilic post lockdown couldn't get anything out of these players. Are we to believe that we'll get a better manager than those four names, three of those who have had success at Premier League level?
|