Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
04-06-2022, 01:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-06-2022, 01:37 PM by Big Daddy Cool.)
Saying Val had us in the top 6 and we've slipped under Bruce is like if the captain of the titanic was replaced by another captain after hitting the iceberg and while the ship is sinking the passengers saying "Well the old captain didn't sink the ship so he was better".
Posts: 7,870
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(04-06-2022, 01:34 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Saying Val had us in the top 6 and we've slipped under Bruce is like if the captain of the titanic was replaced by another captain after hitting the iceberg and while the ship is sinking the passengers saying "Well the old captain didn't sink the ship so he was better".
Nail. On. Head.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(04-06-2022, 09:10 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-06-2022, 01:01 AM)Cuzer Wrote: He inherited a team 5th and spoke about automatic promotion, we’re likely to finish outside the top 12
I’ve no issue with Bruce and he’s clearly trying but if you deliver such results in any job you are most likely to lose it
Very dangerous game for Gourmet to keep his mate on IMO
Cuzer
This, we were 5th blah, blah, blah narrative by some is really pissing me off as it's in no context whatsoever to what was actually going on. It's spoken like someone who doesn't support the club and heard we'd sacked the manager and said: "Why have they done that?."
We were 5th in a huge slide, having previously been cemented firmly in the top 3 for most of the season. We'd played with the form of a team likely to finish 17-18th for 3 months(19 games), after the 10 game unbeaten start.
There were teams with games in hand too and the bunch to mid table were on our shoulders. So we weren't strolling into the play-offs at least in the cosy fairytale in your Hans Christian Anderson world.
Sorry Cuzer, but your comment is like Gourlay is engaged in some kind of nepotism in a spring factory on Rabone Lane- it's way off and shows you trying to rubbish Gourlay already!
I'm sure Bruce isn't 'his mate'. They may get on professionally, but Bruce is a bloke with a 20 year CV of managing in the top 2 divisions and 4 different clubs promoted.
I'm no fan of Bruce's but the lunacy of trying to blame him for a poor squad and not being able to get us in the play-offs is moronic black and white opinions for the hard of thinking.
He may succeed, he may fail, but he hasn't been given a chance at all at this juncture.
I was underwhelmed by his appointment, but he should see how the season pans out and then take it from there.
The level of instability you are calling for is the stuff which sees team in League 1 and akin to the mad Italian who was running Leeds for a while.
You can’t keep surmising what was going to happen.The fact is we were in 5th place unless you would like to rewrite history,and now we are 12th.Bruce took this job on and Gourlay gave him the job with the expectation to at least be in the Play offs and his utter failure is there for all to see.It wasn’t an impossible job he took on you know,this league isn’t great.Last time we had an old pals act we ended up with Pardew and we all know how that went.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-06-2022, 02:39 PM)Huggybear Wrote: (04-06-2022, 09:10 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-06-2022, 01:01 AM)Cuzer Wrote: He inherited a team 5th and spoke about automatic promotion, we’re likely to finish outside the top 12
I’ve no issue with Bruce and he’s clearly trying but if you deliver such results in any job you are most likely to lose it
Very dangerous game for Gourmet to keep his mate on IMO
Cuzer
This, we were 5th blah, blah, blah narrative by some is really pissing me off as it's in no context whatsoever to what was actually going on. It's spoken like someone who doesn't support the club and heard we'd sacked the manager and said: "Why have they done that?."
We were 5th in a huge slide, having previously been cemented firmly in the top 3 for most of the season. We'd played with the form of a team likely to finish 17-18th for 3 months(19 games), after the 10 game unbeaten start.
There were teams with games in hand too and the bunch to mid table were on our shoulders. So we weren't strolling into the play-offs at least in the cosy fairytale in your Hans Christian Anderson world.
Sorry Cuzer, but your comment is like Gourlay is engaged in some kind of nepotism in a spring factory on Rabone Lane- it's way off and shows you trying to rubbish Gourlay already!
I'm sure Bruce isn't 'his mate'. They may get on professionally, but Bruce is a bloke with a 20 year CV of managing in the top 2 divisions and 4 different clubs promoted.
I'm no fan of Bruce's but the lunacy of trying to blame him for a poor squad and not being able to get us in the play-offs is moronic black and white opinions for the hard of thinking.
He may succeed, he may fail, but he hasn't been given a chance at all at this juncture.
I was underwhelmed by his appointment, but he should see how the season pans out and then take it from there.
The level of instability you are calling for is the stuff which sees team in League 1 and akin to the mad Italian who was running Leeds for a while.
You can’t keep surmising what was going to happen.The fact is we were in 5th place unless you would like to rewrite history,and now we are 12th.Bruce took this job on and Gourlay gave him the job with the expectation to at least be in the Play offs and his utter failure is there for all to see.It wasn’t an impossible job he took on you know,this league isn’t great.Last time we had an old pals act we ended up with Pardew and we all know how that went.
The fact is we were showing the form of a team 18th in the table for 3 months(19 games) unless you would like to rewrite history, and now we are 12th.
It's like you are pinning this 5th in the table thing as a rubber-stamp for what's happened since and the season magically ended with Val keeping us in the play-offs.
It's proper black and white limited thinking.
The board surmised what was going to happen based on the form of October onwards
Can we now move on.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
04-06-2022, 03:29 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-06-2022, 03:59 PM by Sliced.)
We lost Pereira, Gallagher, AMN, Diagne, Yokuslu from the first team in the summer and spunked our budget on Karlan Grant.
The ship was sinking before Val came in. In spite of the board Slav came in and through his own scouting abilities brought some quality into the team at Championship level. Then ruined it with an absolutely horrendous summer window when we got promoted. At that point the ship needed to be steadied, but it wasn't and we went down with a whimper. Then we sold the best player we've had in recent years for pittance and reinvested 0 of that Pereira money back into the team in the summer given the list of high earners we also let go for free (both out of contract and those on loan).
Val managed to give us a bit of hope at the start of the season before the true quality of the players shone through. Then Steve "if I didn't think we couldn't get promoted I wouldn't be here" Bruce came in and accelerated that decline and now we sit 12th in the league.
Still, at least we won the "we beat Fulham 1-0" trophy.
Another thing I genuinely don't get is, particularly from those so obsessed with Val that they take every criticism of of Bruce personally, why are you so focused on the previous manager and not the board? They made the decision to bring him in, they made the decision to sell Pereira and allocate zero funds for transfer fees and they are still here! Even if you buy this bollocks of Val choosing to spend zero money; that must mean they gave him free reign. Val's in Turkey, they are still here.
If Bruce is still around and we somehow improve next season it will be despite those behind the scenes, because you can guarantee he'll get no help whatsoever.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-06-2022, 03:29 PM)Sliced Wrote: We lost Pereira, Gallagher, AMN, Diagne, Yokuslu from the first team in the summer and spunked our budget on Karlan Grant.
The ship was sinking before Val came in. In spite of the board Slav came in and through his own scouting abilities brought some quality into the team at Championship level. Then ruined it with an absolutely horrendous summer window when we got promoted. At that point the ship needed to be steadied, but it wasn't and we went down with a whimper. Then we sold the best player we've had in recent years for pittance and reinvested 0 back into the team in the summer given the list of high earners we also let go for free (both out of contract and those on loan).
Val managed to give us a bit of hope at the start of the season before the true quality of the players shone through. Then Steve "if I didn't think we couldn't get promoted I wouldn't be here" Bruce came in and accelerated that decline and now we sit 12th in the league.
Still, at least we won the "we beat Fulham 1-0" trophy.
Another thing I genuinely don't get is, particularly from those so obsessed with Val that they take every criticism of of Bruce personally, why are you so focused on the previous manager and not the board? They made the decision to bring him in, they made the decision to sell Pereira and allocate zero funds for transfer fees and they are still here! Even if you buy this bollocks of Val choosing to spend zero money; that must mean they gave him free reign. Val's in Turkey, they are still here.
If Bruce is still around and we somehow improve next season it will be despite those behind the scenes, because you can guarantee he'll get no help whatsoever.
Good post- when we were apportioning blame the board nearly got all of it off me- as the purveyors of stupid decisions. As I said before, if Val had even got in a month earlier it might have been different. We'll never know.
The handful of Val deniers now though are getting tiresome. Whatever the reason it didn't work.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
04-06-2022, 04:11 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-06-2022, 04:13 PM by Tom Joad.)
Spandaubaggie Wrote:Sliced Wrote:We lost Pereira, Gallagher, AMN, Diagne, Yokuslu from the first team in the summer and spunked our budget on Karlan Grant.
The ship was sinking before Val came in. In spite of the board Slav came in and through his own scouting abilities brought some quality into the team at Championship level. Then ruined it with an absolutely horrendous summer window when we got promoted. At that point the ship needed to be steadied, but it wasn't and we went down with a whimper. Then we sold the best player we've had in recent years for pittance and reinvested 0 back into the team in the summer given the list of high earners we also let go for free (both out of contract and those on loan).
Val managed to give us a bit of hope at the start of the season before the true quality of the players shone through. Then Steve "if I didn't think we couldn't get promoted I wouldn't be here" Bruce came in and accelerated that decline and now we sit 12th in the league.
Still, at least we won the "we beat Fulham 1-0" trophy.
Another thing I genuinely don't get is, particularly from those so obsessed with Val that they take every criticism of of Bruce personally, why are you so focused on the previous manager and not the board? They made the decision to bring him in, they made the decision to sell Pereira and allocate zero funds for transfer fees and they are still here! Even if you buy this bollocks of Val choosing to spend zero money; that must mean they gave him free reign. Val's in Turkey, they are still here.
If Bruce is still around and we somehow improve next season it will be despite those behind the scenes, because you can guarantee he'll get no help whatsoever.
Good post- when we were apportioning blame the board nearly got all of it off me- as the purveyors of stupid decisions. As I said before, if Val had even got in a month earlier it might have been different. We'll never know.
The handful of Val deniers now though are getting tiresome. Whatever the reason it didn't work.
as are those that blame Ishmael for everything when the club has been a shitshow for some time. Top post, Sliced.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
Click for the latest from Albion Analysis: " this week week we debate whether Steve Bruce should remain Albion manager next season so @AnalyticsWBA c runched the numbers and it’s not good. While the style has remained similar to Ismael’s reign, we now create fewer chances and our xG against has increased."
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
04-06-2022, 04:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-06-2022, 04:36 PM by baggiebuckster.)
I don't know if I want Bruce next season.
A lot of people are putting the failings on Val and they may have a point. But that doesn't alter the fact that Bruce has hardly pulled up any trees. I guess the question as to why depends upon what you believe would have happened had we appointed a different manager instead of Bruce. Would we have been any better? Was anyone doomed to fail with this set of players?
What we don't know is what Bruce is planning to do if he stays or more to the point what he will be able to do in terms of player recruitment. If he can't get a tune out of the current crop then he clearly needs reinforcements. If his hands are tied then it doesn't bode well if he is expected to coach the current group to a level that challenges the top 6 next season.
We are in a very awkward position and if you asked me now then I wouldn't spend too much money predicting next season. We could finish absolutely anywhere.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
04-06-2022, 04:36 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-06-2022, 04:40 PM by Sliced.)
(04-06-2022, 04:26 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Click for the latest from Albion Analysis: "this week week we debate whether Steve Bruce should remain Albion manager next season so @AnalyticsWBA crunched the numbers and it’s not good. While the style has remained similar to Ismael’s reign, we now create fewer chances and our xG against has increased."
Ouch, that's not a good read. Less possession, less forward passes, more backwards passes, less attacks, less threatening attacks, less chances created, more chances conceded.
On the plus side we are currently having more......*searches for something vaguely positive*......sliding tackles.......
|