Fuck Bruce off now
Have to smile at the "Val didn't have long enough/Bruce needs sacking" after 10 games people.

Val was failing, big time, and had to go.

Bruce has failed too, albeit with mitigating circumstances. He's learning on the job, games come quick and fast, Livermore getting sent off at Sheff U, no transfer window and a midfield that does nothing apart from play ValBall, and that had been sussed out. He can't play an attacking midfield in a 3- we don't have one (he also tried with Reach for too long), we can't play a midfield 2 because they're not strong enough. Fuck knows what he's supposed to do with our strikers either. So yes he's failing with a bunch of players who Val squeezed more out of in the early days but was so stubborn and inflexible wouldn't (or couldn't) change it when it was failing.

Accepting the above I think Bruce has enough pedigree with past promotions and has gained enough knowledge of these wasters who "play" for us to have a crack next season.

This group of players have gone through how many managers now? We have to draw a line in the sand and stop keep going off in different managerial directions otherwise we'll never get a balanced squad.

Mowbray is nostalgia - Never go back they say. He has 1 promotion and may or may not make the play-offs with Blackburn this year. Not a ringing endorsment considering he left us 13 years ago after another relegation.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
As I’ve said before I would stick with Bruce for now can’t see a reason for change, yes he’s had a crap start, but with Players who had already downed tools so had to try to pick them up. Ismael has gone but by a lot of you not forgotten just remember Preston , Swansea and Millwall. Absolutely hoof ball. The crowd showed he was no longer wanted. Ok Bruce hasn’t pulled up any trees but the Hull and Fulham games shows he’s on the right path. So for me give him a season to implement his players as I said yes today I believe there will be more changes than a lot of us think. Those who want Bruce gone are probably the same fans who didn’t want him in the first place.
Reply
Why can't we all agree that managers aren't always the issue?

Could Val have done better? Yes.

Could Bruce be doing a better job? Probably, yes.

But have either had a squad capable of really pushing for promotion? No.

It's not always the manager fault for a poor season.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
(04-05-2022, 09:00 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Huge difference -if you asked fans after the Preston game was it time for Val to go they would have said yes, it was overwhelming. We'd been sliding for months, getting worse. We were going backwards. He had overseen a summer and recruitment.

Bruce has kept us performing mid table thus far, with the duff players he inherited.

He's underwhelming so far, but he has a pedigree.

Fans screaming for Bruce's head are making all kinds of weird and wonderful statistical stories to back up their impatience, but anyone half reasonable knows he has to be given a chance to rebuild.

Taking us from 5th to 12th is "kept us performing mid-table" is it? Good job Brucie! Please remind me what his remit was when he arrived at the club? I must have missed the bit where it was stated that this season was a write-off so we need to focus on next season.

Also, how is pointing out the fact that Bruce has done worse in his first 10 games than the (according to some) hapless and clueless Ismael did in his last 10 games a "weird and wonderful statistical story"?

Fans were booing the side when we were unbeaten during the first 10 games and top of the table, so we can be in no doubt that if Ismael had been in charge of a local derby defeat in which we had no shots on target and generally didn't have a clue, there would have been raucous booing and loud renditions of "you're getting sacked in the morning". Bruce, on the other hand, continues to get a free pass for some reason.
Reply
(04-05-2022, 10:15 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Why can't we all agree that managers aren't always the issue?

Could Val have done better? Yes.

Could Bruce be doing a better job? Probably, yes.

But have either had a squad capable of really pushing for promotion? No.

It's not always the manager fault for a poor season.

Fuck me

Josh with probably the most sensible post in the thread for a while.

Seriously though, totally correct. Both managers have been disappointments, but the constant is the players because they are just, well, awful.
Reply
The Players are the problem
Reply
(04-05-2022, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(04-05-2022, 10:15 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Why can't we all agree that managers aren't always the issue?

Could Val have done better? Yes.

Could Bruce be doing a better job? Probably, yes.

But have either had a squad capable of really pushing for promotion? No.

It's not always the manager fault for a poor season.

Fuck me

Josh with probably the most sensible post in the thread for a while.

Seriously though, totally correct. Both managers have been disappointments, but the constant is the players because they are just, well, awful.

I've recently suffered a concussion, so that may explain the bizarre nature of my post.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
(04-05-2022, 10:27 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: The Players are the problem

What have they done, is it to do with the pre-match music? I'd have thought a bit of ska would get the players going. 

https://theplayersband.com
Reply
(04-05-2022, 10:27 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: The Players are the problem

That's my initial stance. I don't think I've ever felt so much disgust and anger toward a single squad in my time of being a Baggies fan. I actively detest this group of players. 

However, when I take a step back, I realise that the managers have played their part with poor tactics, selections and in-game decisions, our owner has also played a part in recruiting poorly, at board level, managerial appointments and finally playing staff. 

It's a little frustrating reading these debates with posters fighting amongst themselves, with one side blaming Val, the other Bruce, then the others the players. It's been a collective shitshow where each party deserves a share of blame. 

When we've been successful it's due to hard work off and on the field, with all parties pulling in the same direction. We haven't been promoted because of one player or because we've got a manager who has worked miracles, the success has happened because we've got the correct mixture of a good squad and coaching staff, including the manager. 

The same holds true, but in the opposite way, when we are unsuccessful.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
(04-05-2022, 10:15 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Why can't we all agree that managers aren't always the issue?

Could Val have done better? Yes.

Could Bruce be doing a better job? Probably, yes.

But have either had a squad capable of really pushing for promotion? No.

It's not always the manager fault for a poor season.

Do agree, Kratos, managers aren`t always the issue.
My issue was / is though, why according to Gourlay, was Bruce `a no brainer, a shortlist of one`? To some, that just smacked of him being desperate to give his mate a job. Surely, a few calls could have been made to sound out others.
Also, Bruces 4 promotions were a few years ago now, he is 61, are his methods now a bit dated ? His record in his last several months at Newcastle was poor, what was it, 4 wins and 5 draws in 30 games or something. I also heard that several players up there felt his coaching was not the best, ( maybe their squad was full of overpaid money grabbers and bone idle wastes of oxygen also ).  I read when he got sacked, an article in one of the papers, that his training sessions were very slack, players being given afternoons off , early finishes etc.
I know we can`t keep sacking managers, but wonder if Bruce should have got the job, based on his recent record.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)