Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Vaughan is uncompromising and arguably our best captain for many a year
Just what we need to rebuild the shambles this side and the current set up currently is, however I’m sure there will be another “yes” man along to take the top role shortly
By the way that was as woeful as they’ve been for a long time today, some of that batting had to be seen to be believed, truly woeful
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 7,972
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(03-26-2022, 10:14 PM)Fido Wrote: (03-26-2022, 08:50 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (03-26-2022, 08:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Managing to nearly lose by an innings when the other side don't get 300 is some going.
(03-26-2022, 08:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-24-2022, 08:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Can I ask, genuinely because I can't think of another reason, is Crawley only in the England team because he's posh? He's worse than Sibley and Burns, I see no reason why he should be out there.
Bumping this
Nope. He's a bizzare selection. Doesn't even have a decent FC record. A very average cricketer, yet loved by the ECB and pundits alike. Just before the start of this test Michael Vaughan was on BT saying he's one who should be around the team for years. Yeah, a bloke barely averaging 30 in the County Champ Division 2. Vaughan is a tit of the highest order.
+1.
Afraid so.
Great captain (after Hussain did a lot of legwork with an inferior side in the early 00s) but an absolute knobhead
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I agree with Cuz that Vaughan was an excellent captain. Arguably only Strauss has come close to him since he packed it in. It took them a while to give Strauss the job, there was the failed experiment with Flintoff and after Strauss the Pieterson fiasco. With Cook they settled into a routine of giving the job to the next most obvious candidate within the clique - which is why a poor captain like Root gets to captain the side 60 times.
When Cook took over, he had Anderson and Broad just getting into their prime, the last couple of years of Swann and Matt Prior behind the pegs. Batting wise there was Trott, Bell and Pieterson.
Fast forward to Root, he had Broad and Anderson still at their peak, plus Moeen with bat and ball, Cook still in the side as well. Stokes and Bairstow were starting to tantalise us with their potential. So he got off to a storming start.
Now where are we? The supply of solid batsmen has dried up. The way the game is now, players get no preparation for Test cricket and many don't want to play it. With the dominance of Broad and Anderson, there has been no real effort to replace them. Failed experiments with true quick bowlers (Roland-Jones, Finn, Ball) none of whom have stood the test of time, Wood being the only partial success but painfully injury prone. Woakes has been a fringe player, which is why he struggles to step up now as he gets older. Potential replacements like Robinson have been left in county cricket when maybe they were worth a look sooner. And the attempts to ignore Mahmood in the last couple of seasons have been quite remarkable.
So Root doesn't any longer have the players to boss the opposition. This tour was when captaincy skills were needed, and we've seen that Root doesn't have any. Time to appoint a genuine captain from outside the clique, someone with plenty of County cricket experience. Give them time to grow into the job.
Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(03-27-2022, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I agree with Cuz that Vaughan was an excellent captain. Arguably only Strauss has come close to him since he packed it in. It took them a while to give Strauss the job, there was the failed experiment with Flintoff and after Strauss the Pieterson fiasco. With Cook they settled into a routine of giving the job to the next most obvious candidate within the clique - which is why a poor captain like Root gets to captain the side 60 times.
When Cook took over, he had Anderson and Broad just getting into their prime, the last couple of years of Swann and Matt Prior behind the pegs. Batting wise there was Trott, Bell and Pieterson.
Fast forward to Root, he had Broad and Anderson still at their peak, plus Moeen with bat and ball, Cook still in the side as well. Stokes and Bairstow were starting to tantalise us with their potential. So he got off to a storming start.
Now where are we? The supply of solid batsmen has dried up. The way the game is now, players get no preparation for Test cricket and many don't want to play it. With the dominance of Broad and Anderson, there has been no real effort to replace them. Failed experiments with true quick bowlers (Roland-Jones, Finn, Ball) none of whom have stood the test of time, Wood being the only partial success but painfully injury prone. Woakes has been a fringe player, which is why he struggles to step up now as he gets older. Potential replacements like Robinson have been left in county cricket when maybe they were worth a look sooner. And the attempts to ignore Mahmood in the last couple of seasons have been quite remarkable.
So Root doesn't any longer have the players to boss the opposition. This tour was when captaincy skills were needed, and we've seen that Root doesn't have any. Time to appoint a genuine captain from outside the clique, someone with plenty of County cricket experience. Give them time to grow into the job. Difficult to disagree with much of that Chesh.
We need a genuine captain that will lead the team and try different tactics. The morning session yesterday summed up the approach under Root. Great batsman, top bloke, but an average captain.
Not sure who's out there in the county game, and good enough to step up, but we need to try someone else. What's Mike Brearley up to these days
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I think most the captaincy these days is driven by the analytics off the field and Root just captains by numbers, no feel for what is happening. So I think that also needs looking at.
England are paying for taking all the emphasis off red ball cricket, even at county level these days. The players all want 6s, flashing lights and the IPL money. We seem to struggle with this and yet other nations can produce both styles of player. That’s the biggest issue.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 2,881
Threads: 106
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
Michael Vaughan is an arrogant, annoying cunt. I wouldn't listen to the rubbish that he comes out with.
Clarnet v2.0
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-27-2022, 10:20 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (03-27-2022, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I agree with Cuz that Vaughan was an excellent captain. Arguably only Strauss has come close to him since he packed it in. It took them a while to give Strauss the job, there was the failed experiment with Flintoff and after Strauss the Pieterson fiasco. With Cook they settled into a routine of giving the job to the next most obvious candidate within the clique - which is why a poor captain like Root gets to captain the side 60 times.
When Cook took over, he had Anderson and Broad just getting into their prime, the last couple of years of Swann and Matt Prior behind the pegs. Batting wise there was Trott, Bell and Pieterson.
Fast forward to Root, he had Broad and Anderson still at their peak, plus Moeen with bat and ball, Cook still in the side as well. Stokes and Bairstow were starting to tantalise us with their potential. So he got off to a storming start.
Now where are we? The supply of solid batsmen has dried up. The way the game is now, players get no preparation for Test cricket and many don't want to play it. With the dominance of Broad and Anderson, there has been no real effort to replace them. Failed experiments with true quick bowlers (Roland-Jones, Finn, Ball) none of whom have stood the test of time, Wood being the only partial success but painfully injury prone. Woakes has been a fringe player, which is why he struggles to step up now as he gets older. Potential replacements like Robinson have been left in county cricket when maybe they were worth a look sooner. And the attempts to ignore Mahmood in the last couple of seasons have been quite remarkable.
So Root doesn't any longer have the players to boss the opposition. This tour was when captaincy skills were needed, and we've seen that Root doesn't have any. Time to appoint a genuine captain from outside the clique, someone with plenty of County cricket experience. Give them time to grow into the job. Difficult to disagree with much of that Chesh.
We need a genuine captain that will lead the team and try different tactics. The morning session yesterday summed up the approach under Root. Great batsman, top bloke, but an average captain.
Not sure who's out there in the county game, and good enough to step up, but we need to try someone else. What's Mike Brearley up to these days 
James Vince. I’d happily take a number 3 who can average 35 at this level as a 2-year interim captain. Possibly Tom Abell at Somerset if he has established himself in the Test team by then.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(03-27-2022, 11:28 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Michael Vaughan is an arrogant, annoying cunt. I wouldn't listen to the rubbish that he comes out with.
He knows a lot about cricket. We love to diss celebrities on here for all sorts of reasons or none at all, but you can't dismiss his cricket knowledge.
Posts: 2,881
Threads: 106
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
03-27-2022, 12:31 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2022, 12:31 PM by KratosBaggie.)
(03-27-2022, 11:57 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (03-27-2022, 11:28 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Michael Vaughan is an arrogant, annoying cunt. I wouldn't listen to the rubbish that he comes out with.
He knows a lot about cricket. We love to diss celebrities on here for all sorts of reasons or none at all, but you can't dismiss his cricket knowledge.
Given he made a career out it, and captained his country, that's a given.
He still spouts a lot drivel.
Clarnet v2.0
Posts: 3,075
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-27-2022, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I agree with Cuz that Vaughan was an excellent captain. Arguably only Strauss has come close to him since he packed it in. It took them a while to give Strauss the job, there was the failed experiment with Flintoff and after Strauss the Pieterson fiasco. With Cook they settled into a routine of giving the job to the next most obvious candidate within the clique - which is why a poor captain like Root gets to captain the side 60 times.
When Cook took over, he had Anderson and Broad just getting into their prime, the last couple of years of Swann and Matt Prior behind the pegs. Batting wise there was Trott, Bell and Pieterson.
Fast forward to Root, he had Broad and Anderson still at their peak, plus Moeen with bat and ball, Cook still in the side as well. Stokes and Bairstow were starting to tantalise us with their potential. So he got off to a storming start.
Now where are we? The supply of solid batsmen has dried up. The way the game is now, players get no preparation for Test cricket and many don't want to play it. With the dominance of Broad and Anderson, there has been no real effort to replace them. Failed experiments with true quick bowlers (Roland-Jones, Finn, Ball) none of whom have stood the test of time, Wood being the only partial success but painfully injury prone. Woakes has been a fringe player, which is why he struggles to step up now as he gets older. Potential replacements like Robinson have been left in county cricket when maybe they were worth a look sooner. And the attempts to ignore Mahmood in the last couple of seasons have been quite remarkable.
So Root doesn't any longer have the players to boss the opposition. This tour was when captaincy skills were needed, and we've seen that Root doesn't have any. Time to appoint a genuine captain from outside the clique, someone with plenty of County cricket experience. Give them time to grow into the job.
You should be a cricket journalist. A brilliant and spot on assessment.
|