Team for next season
#21
The bigger picture needs looking at IMO.
Starting with the recruitment team.
Who keeps bringing players in who don't improve anything.
Managers bring in more players then they do 
Who keeps losing the academy starlets. Yes I know moves are money motivated, but why don't they want to stay.
Who messes contracts up as so players leave for pennies.
Time for the whole recruitment team to get binned no acceptions. All of them and bring people in who deliver results.
Reply
#22
My main objection to flooding the team with loan signings is that it leaves us with far too much to do if we get promoted. We either blow our entire budget making the moves permanent (Diangana) or it leaves us needing to replace five key first time players, with players good enough for the PL and given our current recruitment strategy I wouldn't bet on us being able to replace one.
Reply
#23
(03-21-2022, 08:45 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The bigger picture needs looking at IMO.
Starting with the recruitment team.
Who keeps bringing players in who don't improve anything.
Managers bring in more players then they do 
Who keeps losing the academy starlets. Yes I know moves are money motivated, but why don't they want to stay.
Who messes contracts up as so players leave for pennies.
Time for the whole recruitment team to get binned no acceptions. All of them and bring people in who deliver results.

Depends who you believe Remi... recruitment team here claim they have more often than not been sidelined in favour of managers' personal targets which has led to the unbalanced squad and generally poor performance in the market over the last 3 seasons. FWIW I think Fat Sam was the most joined up when it came to using the recruitment team, with Okay and Diagne both identified and offered to Slav in the summer, only for him to want Krov and Grant instead - fortunately we were able to avoid spending £10m on Krov!!!

I do think the football board that Gourlay is implementing is a good idea in theory... Liverpool's transfer record has been fantastic since they introduced the Transfer Acquisition Panel which effectively brings together all the same functions to assess the fit of a player before making a move for him... it seems obvious, but involving the scouting, medical and finance teams at an early stage and then involving the academy manager to understand if there are any kids we feel could be used in that position instead just hasn't been happening here.
Reply
#24
(03-21-2022, 08:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-21-2022, 08:45 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The bigger picture needs looking at IMO.
Starting with the recruitment team.
Who keeps bringing players in who don't improve anything.
Managers bring in more players then they do 
Who keeps losing the academy starlets. Yes I know moves are money motivated, but why don't they want to stay.
Who messes contracts up as so players leave for pennies.
Time for the whole recruitment team to get binned no acceptions. All of them and bring people in who deliver results.

Depends who you believe Remi... recruitment team here claim they have more often than not been sidelined in favour of managers' personal targets which has led to the unbalanced squad and generally poor performance in the market over the last 3 seasons. FWIW I think Fat Sam was the most joined up when it came to using the recruitment team, with Okay and Diagne both identified and offered to Slav in the summer, only for him to want Krov and Grant instead - fortunately we were able to avoid spending £10m on Krov!!!

I do think the football board that Gourlay is implementing is a good idea in theory... Liverpool's transfer record has been fantastic since they introduced the Transfer Acquisition Panel which effectively brings together all the same functions to assess the fit of a player before making a move for him... it seems obvious, but involving the scouting, medical and finance teams at an early stage and then involving the academy manager to understand if there are any kids we feel could be used in that position instead just hasn't been happening here.

It's not been happening for years. Even we are lacking in having a clear picture on players rational. Our mental weakness is shocking. The whole department does need a massive overhaul. Get the foundations right and we have a chance of building something.
Reply
#25
(03-21-2022, 08:47 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: My main objection to flooding the team with loan signings is that it leaves us with far too much to do if we get promoted. We either blow our entire budget making the moves permanent (Diangana) or it leaves us needing to replace five key first time players, with players good enough for the PL and given our current recruitment strategy I wouldn't bet on us being able to replace one.

I agree with what you say but when /if we get promoted I doubt we will ever be in a position to stay there too long .We need to get promoted firstly to get rid of Lai and whoever buys the club I can't see us establishing ourselves as a midtable prem side so it will be up/ down situation for many years .
Reply
#26
(03-21-2022, 08:59 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: It's not been happening for years. Even we are lacking in having a clear picture on players rational. Our mental weakness is shocking. The whole department does need a massive overhaul. Get the foundations right and we have a chance of building something.

Point I'm trying to make Remi is that we don't know for sure the foundations are broken... In Okay and Diagne we clearly isolated the right players and within budget, however for whatever reason we prioritised other, ill-fitting signings. Similarly, our academy is producing talented players, but it's taking an injury crisis for them to get chance in the team, or they're leaving as soon as they take on an agent.

What appears broken is communication and planning, and that comes from the top down, not from the foundations. Before we write off Pearce and the recruitment department, we need to know more about whether they have been making the lazy recommendations like Reach and Hugill, or whether they have been ignored to favour the demands of incoming managers and/'or agents with a disproportionate amount of influence at the senior level in the club.
Reply
#27
(03-21-2022, 08:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-21-2022, 08:45 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The bigger picture needs looking at IMO.
Starting with the recruitment team.
Who keeps bringing players in who don't improve anything.
Managers bring in more players then they do 
Who keeps losing the academy starlets. Yes I know moves are money motivated, but why don't they want to stay.
Who messes contracts up as so players leave for pennies.
Time for the whole recruitment team to get binned no acceptions. All of them and bring people in who deliver results.

Depends who you believe Remi... recruitment team here claim they have more often than not been sidelined in favour of managers' personal targets which has led to the unbalanced squad and generally poor performance in the market over the last 3 seasons. FWIW I think Fat Sam was the most joined up when it came to using the recruitment team, with Okay and Diagne both identified and offered to Slav in the summer, only for him to want Krov and Grant instead - fortunately we were able to avoid spending £10m on Krov!!!

I do think the football board that Gourlay is implementing is a good idea in theory... Liverpool's transfer record has been fantastic since they introduced the Transfer Acquisition Panel which effectively brings together all the same functions to assess the fit of a player before making a move for him... it seems obvious, but involving the scouting, medical and finance teams at an early stage and then involving the academy manager to understand if there are any kids we feel could be used in that position instead just hasn't been happening here.
No. But it is in Gourlay's plan, shared a couple of weeks ago.
Hope he gets to deliver it, but at least he's spotted the problem. 
IMO it's the main one, far beyond the identity of the current manager.
Reply
#28
(03-21-2022, 11:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-21-2022, 08:59 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: It's not been happening for years. Even we are lacking in having a clear picture on players rational. Our mental weakness is shocking. The whole department does need a massive overhaul. Get the foundations right and we have a chance of building something.

Point I'm trying to make Remi is that we don't know for sure the foundations are broken... In Okay and Diagne we clearly isolated the right players and within budget, however for whatever reason we prioritised other, ill-fitting signings. Similarly, our academy is producing talented players, but it's taking an injury crisis for them to get chance in the team, or they're leaving as soon as they take on an agent.

What appears broken is communication and planning, and that comes from the top down, not from the foundations. Before we write off Pearce and the recruitment department, we need to know more about whether they have been making the lazy recommendations like Reach and Hugill, or whether they have been ignored to favour the demands of incoming managers and/'or agents with a disproportionate amount of influence at the senior level in the club.

If it's as you say and they aren't recommending / signing anybody what are they doing? 
Realistically we never get that information and signed non disclosure contracts always prevent us from seeing the details. The evidence is as we see it that's all we can go on. 
Our ability to search out and nab rough diamonds is rubbish.
Reply
#29
(03-21-2022, 01:01 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-21-2022, 11:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-21-2022, 08:59 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: It's not been happening for years. Even we are lacking in having a clear picture on players rational. Our mental weakness is shocking. The whole department does need a massive overhaul. Get the foundations right and we have a chance of building something.

Point I'm trying to make Remi is that we don't know for sure the foundations are broken... In Okay and Diagne we clearly isolated the right players and within budget, however for whatever reason we prioritised other, ill-fitting signings. Similarly, our academy is producing talented players, but it's taking an injury crisis for them to get chance in the team, or they're leaving as soon as they take on an agent.

What appears broken is communication and planning, and that comes from the top down, not from the foundations. Before we write off Pearce and the recruitment department, we need to know more about whether they have been making the lazy recommendations like Reach and Hugill, or whether they have been ignored to favour the demands of incoming managers and/'or agents with a disproportionate amount of influence at the senior level in the club.

If it's as you say and they aren't recommending / signing anybody what are they doing? 
Realistically we never get that information and signed non disclosure contracts always prevent us from seeing the details. The evidence is as we see it that's all we can go on. 
Our ability to search out and nab rough diamonds is rubbish.

In the Bilic promotion season, our record wasn't too bad;Furlong, Semi, Sawyers were all excellent value, however Austin and Zohore were complete messes... Willock would have also proven to be a snip if we'd perservered with him, but for whatever reason Slav wanted nothing to do with him. We know Grady, Pereira and Krov were entirely Slav's doing, but we don't know who recommended the others. There are rumours around Austin and Zohore sharing agents with Dowling, and him being influenced by that relationship... We were also very quick to react to bring in Robinson, Grosicki and Peltier to shore up the squad in January.  If that was the work of our recruitment team, then they deserve credit. Similarly, the previous summer, whilst Moore deserves immense credit for Barnes and Gayle being convinced to join, we plucked Townsend from obscurity, Bartley was a solid signing (if not a little overpriced) and our January business was pretty promising following Barnes' exit.

The PL summer's recruitment was awful, but it seems Slav was really the driving force behind Grant, Ivanovic, Gallagher and making the loanees permanent... Kipre with hindsight looks a useful acquisition for the price, and I very much doubt Fat Sam had spent his time off watching the Turkish league and came armed with Diagne and Yoksulu as recommendations... AMN and Snodgrass were certainly his picks however.

This summer, we know Dike and Mowatt were 100% Val's boys, quite who authorised Clarke, Molumby, Hugill and Reach... 

Overall, it's a mixed bag, but I don't think our recruitment team have been as bad as we make out... we've been influenced by some poor managerial picks, and the lack of a coherent strategy has really gone against us in terms of bringing players in. We've had a mix of excellent value signings and huge wastes of money, and very little in between. We need to start getting big money purchases right, or if we can't do this (many clubs our size have the same issue) having more faith in our ability to pick up bargains from lower down the divisions as we're actually pretty good at it!
Reply
#30
Agree SW4.

We could offset the money on big money signings and invest into the infrastructure.

The Hawthorns needs a good 20-30m spent on it as does the training ground.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: