The Miserable Existence of Steve Bruce
#31
No 44 pager just every football thread on here mentioning a certain ex manager maliciously
Reply
#32
(03-17-2022, 12:41 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: No 44 pager just every football thread on here mentioning a certain ex manager maliciously

But not everyone uniformly against him.  Whoever he is.
Reply
#33
In the Ashley years Newcastle have been bottom half of the Prem. Bruce has done about the same as most. I still think they would have been ok if they'd stuck with him.

Trying to put into context the 44 pagers, what has to be in mind is they are a one club city, and do have huge support, so they will have an element of fuckwits that will help entice more fuckwits to the party.

By and large though, until this Saudi money has arrived they've underperformed for a club of their potential. They've been a virtually unmanageable club.
Reply
#34
It's now on page 127, and still going strong.

You've only had him for 8 months, Newcastle had him for nearly 2 and a half years and I see it's the same droning nonsense about dusting worselves doon, rolling wor sleeves up, licking wor wounds, keep bashing away, burying hatchets, gloves coming off, all a load of you know what, when in reality, there's no tactics, no plan, no fitness, no inspiration, nothing - just trying to pick your best 11 players and hoping something comes off, 'nick a result', and it's 100% unsustainable. It might have worked 15-20 years ago, but the game has moved on.

I have been browsing both of your main forums for a while, and it makes for sad reading, pretty much how we were 12 months ago - a mix of anger and apathy - shall I go to the match, do I actually want my team to win, will it be better in the long term if we lose, and that's an awful position for a fan to be in. It was bad enough appointing him in the first place, but even worse that you actually had a break clause deal in place and didn't utilise it.

It seems more and more are seeing through this lovely fella, nice family man image, great for a pint and bacon sarnie etc., and things go south, the mask soon starts slipping. He might appear a good bloke on the outside, but when it's your club, and you see and hear from him pretty much everyday, it's a totally different story. Lots of similarities - playing down expectations - only 8 months ago his main aim was to 'get the Albion back in the Premier League', and then soon it'll be 'you've struggled for 2 and a half years'. Subtly blaming fans and 'not being everyone's cut of tea' (there's probably a reason for that, Steve), always the victim, shifting the blame by saying 'it's not going how we'd like, but you know, there's 7 or 8 others in the same boat', and he always seems to have his media mates defend him - Hal Robson Kanu being the latest and trying his best the other night, when in reality, 7 wins in 29 league matches is absolutely abysmal for a team like West Brom, who have, or rather had, never finished below 26th in the pyramid for over 20 years. You've still got the players to be doing far better than that. 22nd in the league having played more than half of the teams in the league. Crazy.

I could honestly go on for hours with my sheer disdain and contempt, and no surprise that particular thread is so active on that forum. We've had our share of poor managers and unsavoury characters in the Premier League era, a few of them ended up at the Hawthorns not long after, and while he may not be the worst statistically, taking everything in to account, I think for most Newcastle fans, he'll absolutely go down as our worst ever these past 30 years.
Reply
#35
Until his final season, didn't he have an almost identical record to Rafa? The hatred here is nowhere near as strong, and his record here is much worse. Time for him to go of course but I'd like to think (and be has) that Bruce has been treated better here than up at Newcastle.
Reply
#36
I've read bits of that that thread and I think I quite like 'em.

Some very funny observations and uncanny how Bruce's time (and quotes) there are similar to with us.

Steve is just really very rubbish.
Reply
#37
(10-07-2022, 05:55 PM)HLS Wrote: Until his final season, didn't he have an almost identical record to Rafa? The hatred here is nowhere near as strong, and his record here is much worse. Time for him to go of course but I'd like to think (and be has) that Bruce has been treated better here than up at Newcastle.

As I say, he's only been at your place 8 months, not years, give it time, if he's allowed it...

Yes, Rafa finished 10th and 12th, Bruce 12th and 13th, both on very similar points, but I'll C&P a reply from earlier today on p126 of that thread which answers it well:


"Sure, he finished 13th and 12th which as you say look OK on paper. But he took over Benitez's team which was 7th in form the second half of his last season and even better in the last quarter of that season. We were playing expansive football, looking really good. Then he comes in and torpedoes it. Plus although the 13th placed season was a fair reflection of us, anyone who watched us the year after will remember how utterly dogshit we were but outperformed our XG massively by loads of flukey wins. There was no chance that was sustainable long-term, and the following season it all unravelled to the surprise of absolutely nobody at all.[/font][/size][/color]

It was so lazy (or disingenuous) when journalists would say "But they averaged about the same over a few years" when Rafa took over a dogsh*t team on the way down and turned us into a team that could go toe to toe with nearly anyone, then Bruce took over that team and turned us into one heading back down again. Yeah sure, the average is the same, but hell, factor in the start and end points of each of their reigns."


Not to mention the fact that Rafa's side was a newly promoted side, whereas Bruce took over an in form team with 2 years back in the league, and had a relatively OK budget, certainly by Ashley's standards and a hell of a lot more than what Rafa had - 40m on Joelinton, 20m on ASM, 20m on Wilson, 15m on Lewis, 25m on Willock, although admittedly the latter was the only purchase during the summer of his final year, and one we had on loan.

But seriously, at his age, it's obviously not going to get significantly better, you might get a result here and there to prolong the inevitable, where the needless longevity will ultimately only serve to turn an apparent minority into a majority and make them more vocal (or apathetic), like at the other bigger clubs he has managed. He'll look more and more angrier, start interrupting more journalists, and thinking the whole world is against him.

Anyway, I've said my peace in response to some of the initial replies. Good luck for the rest of the season (well, as soon as the big man goes anyway...)
Reply
#38
BruceBall Wrote:It's now on page 127, and still going strong.

You've only had him for 8 months, Newcastle had him for nearly 2 and a half years and I see it's the same droning nonsense about dusting worselves doon, rolling wor sleeves up, licking wor wounds, keep bashing away, burying hatchets, gloves coming off, all a load of you know what, when in reality, there's no tactics, no plan, no fitness, no inspiration, nothing - just trying to pick your best 11 players and hoping something comes off, 'nick a result', and it's 100% unsustainable. It might have worked 15-20 years ago, but the game has moved on.

I have been browsing both of your main forums for a while, and it makes for sad reading, pretty much how we were 12 months ago - a mix of anger and apathy - shall I go to the match, do I actually want my team to win, will it be better in the long term if we lose, and that's an awful position for a fan to be in. It was bad enough appointing him in the first place, but even worse that you actually had a break clause deal in place and didn't utilise it.

It seems more and more are seeing through this lovely fella, nice family man image, great for a pint and bacon sarnie etc., and things go south, the mask soon starts slipping. He might appear a good bloke on the outside, but when it's your club, and you see and hear from him pretty much everyday, it's a totally different story. Lots of similarities - playing down expectations - only 8 months ago his main aim was to 'get the Albion back in the Premier League', and then soon it'll be 'you've struggled for 2 and a half years'. Subtly blaming fans and 'not being everyone's cut of tea' (there's probably a reason for that, Steve), always the victim, shifting the blame by saying 'it's not going how we'd like, but you know, there's 7 or 8 others in the same boat', and he always seems to have his media mates defend him - Hal Robson Kanu being the latest and trying his best the other night, when in reality, 7 wins in 29 league matches is absolutely abysmal for a team like West Brom, who have, or rather had, never finished below 26th in the pyramid for over 20 years. You've still got the players to be doing far better than that. 22nd in the league having played more than half of the teams in the league. Crazy.

I could honestly go on for hours with my sheer disdain and contempt, and no surprise that particular thread is so active on that forum. We've had our share of poor managers and unsavoury characters in the Premier League era, a few of them ended up at the Hawthorns not long after, and while he may not be the worst statistically, taking everything in to account, I think for most Newcastle fans, he'll absolutely go down as our worst ever these past 30 years.
Funnily enough, those quotes were recited to me by villa fans when I suggested they treated him harshly. Some of the phrases almost word for word.  The media like him and he uses them well. I've no axe to grind with Brucie as a bloke but I really wonder why he is so addicted to doing a job he isn't very good at, and taking all the abuse when well off enough not to have to. He really should find something better to do.
Reply
#39
Hope he’s off to Australia to watch the T20 World Cup because that means he’s gone from our club.
Reply
#40
(10-07-2022, 06:16 PM)BruceBall Wrote:
(10-07-2022, 05:55 PM)HLS Wrote: Until his final season, didn't he have an almost identical record to Rafa? The hatred here is nowhere near as strong, and his record here is much worse. Time for him to go of course but I'd like to think (and be has) that Bruce has been treated better here than up at Newcastle.

As I say, he's only been at your place 8 months, not years, give it time, if he's allowed it...

Yes, Rafa finished 10th and 12th, Bruce 12th and 13th, both on very similar points, but I'll C&P a reply from earlier today on p126 of that thread which answers it well:


"Sure, he finished 13th and 12th which as you say look OK on paper. But he took over Benitez's team which was 7th in form the second half of his last season and even better in the last quarter of that season. We were playing expansive football, looking really good. Then he comes in and torpedoes it. Plus although the 13th placed season was a fair reflection of us, anyone who watched us the year after will remember how utterly dogshit we were but outperformed our XG massively by loads of flukey wins. There was no chance that was sustainable long-term, and the following season it all unravelled to the surprise of absolutely nobody at all.[/font][/size][/color]

It was so lazy (or disingenuous) when journalists would say "But they averaged about the same over a few years" when Rafa took over a dogsh*t team on the way down and turned us into a team that could go toe to toe with nearly anyone, then Bruce took over that team and turned us into one heading back down again. Yeah sure, the average is the same, but hell, factor in the start and end points of each of their reigns."


Not to mention the fact that Rafa's side was a newly promoted side, whereas Bruce took over an in form team with 2 years back in the league, and had a relatively OK budget, certainly by Ashley's standards and a hell of a lot more than what Rafa had - 40m on Joelinton, 20m on ASM, 20m on Wilson, 15m on Lewis, 25m on Willock, although admittedly the latter was the only purchase during the summer of his final year, and one we had on loan.

But seriously, at his age, it's obviously not going to get significantly better, you might get a result here and there to prolong the inevitable, where the needless longevity will ultimately only serve to turn an apparent minority into a majority and make them more vocal (or apathetic), like at the other bigger clubs he has managed. He'll look more and more angrier, start interrupting more journalists, and thinking the whole world is against him.

Anyway, I've said my peace in response to some of the initial replies. Good luck for the rest of the season (well, as soon as the big man goes anyway...)

I understand it more now than I did back then, but the magnitude of the collapse we've seen is way beyond what happened at Newcastle. We were 5th in the Championship and now relegation to League One is a genuine possibility. It's horrendous.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)