Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(03-26-2019, 02:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (03-26-2019, 07:38 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: So basically you're saying we should have picked potential replacements, interviewed them and shook hands with one of them willing to come to us. All while Darren was doing the job. Then sack him with his replacement waiting in the wings. The only other alternative would be to secretly talk to agents about the possibility of certain managers joining us again behind Darren's back. I think the bloke deserved better than that and that ain't the way it happens at the Albion. Words fail me
But that's what happened effectively at Leicester recently, Puel sacked on Saturday and Rogers in within a couple of days.
It's not a particularly nice way of doing business, but then sacking managers isn't a particularly pleasant business anyway.
Not having a replacement lined up, in my opinion makes what was a really bad decision to start with a whole lot worse.
We're West Bromwich Albion, not Leicester City. We don't do that sort of thing. Other clubs ignore other ethics and rules. Doesn't mean we will.
(03-26-2019, 02:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (03-26-2019, 07:38 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: So basically you're saying we should have picked potential replacements, interviewed them and shook hands with one of them willing to come to us. All while Darren was doing the job. Then sack him with his replacement waiting in the wings. The only other alternative would be to secretly talk to agents about the possibility of certain managers joining us again behind Darren's back. I think the bloke deserved better than that and that ain't the way it happens at the Albion. Words fail me
But that's what happened effectively at Leicester recently, Puel sacked on Saturday and Rogers in within a couple of days.
It's not a particularly nice way of doing business, but then sacking managers isn't a particularly pleasant business anyway.
Not having a replacement lined up, in my opinion makes what was a really bad decision to start with a whole lot worse.
Agreed. No other business just fires someone at the top without having the replacement ready to go. It's called succession planning and prudence.
We fire managers quickly with what seems like no replacement and then we hold on to chronic managers like Pulis and Pardew for months later than we should. You really couldn't make it up.
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
Other clubs find it easier to attract a replacement manager because they're a more attractive proposition and generally pay what the respective candidate wants without any haggling. We will have our lists of potential targets like anyone else but our budgetary restraints and general lesser appeal will cause deals to drag out or break down. There isn't a disease that every owner we have had or gonna have contracts that makes them dithering idiots. It's a similar issue in transfer windows. We look shabby because we are either budget buying or waiting for other clubs to have their pick. It's been that way the majority of the time of me supporting us since the sixties. Like it or not we ain't fookin Chelsea.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-26-2019, 04:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Other clubs find it easier to attract a replacement manager because they're a more attractive proposition and generally pay what the respective candidate wants without any haggling. We will have our lists of potential targets like anyone else but our budgetary restraints and general lesser appeal will cause deals to drag out or break down. There isn't a disease that every owner we have had or gonna have contracts that makes them dithering idiots. It's a similar issue in transfer windows. We look shabby because we are either budget buying or waiting for other clubs to have their pick. It's been that way the majority of the time of me supporting us since the sixties. Like it or not we ain't fookin Chelsea.
+1.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
You make it sound like we are novices but you name the clubs who are a better proposition.Derby got lampard who is a novice, villa got Smith we rejected him , Falke at Norwich you ever heard of him till now.Wagner at Huddersfield we had never heard of him.Houghton Brighton we turned him down. Johnson Bristol city below us, warnock clown ,Pulis we know what happened there and he was well paid so stop the rubbish about other clubs are a better proposition. Sometimes you get lucky Bielsa at Leeds or Dingles boss. Sometimes in life things aren’t available at the right time,Moore had to go because the players did not know wether to stick or twist with his or Jones style of football. So now we wait when the time is right a new man will be employed ,but to say we’re not attractive is utter hogwash.
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(03-26-2019, 05:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: You make it sound like we are novices but you name the clubs who are a better proposition.Derby got lampard who is a novice, villa got Smith we rejected him , Falke at Norwich you ever heard of him till now.Wagner at Huddersfield we had never heard of him.Houghton Brighton we turned him down. Johnson Bristol city below us, warnock clown ,Pulis we know what happened there and he was well paid so stop the rubbish about other clubs are a better proposition. Sometimes you get lucky Bielsa at Leeds or Dingles boss. Sometimes in life things aren’t available at the right time,Moore had to go because the players did not know wether to stick or twist with his or Jones style of football. So now we wait when the time is right a new man will be employed ,but to say we’re not attractive is utter hogwash.
You’re more club shop than Tony Pulis.
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(03-26-2019, 05:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: You make it sound like we are novices but you name the clubs who are a better proposition.Derby got lampard who is a novice, villa got Smith we rejected him , Falke at Norwich you ever heard of him till now.Wagner at Huddersfield we had never heard of him.Houghton Brighton we turned him down. Johnson Bristol city below us, warnock clown ,Pulis we know what happened there and he was well paid so stop the rubbish about other clubs are a better proposition. Sometimes you get lucky Bielsa at Leeds or Dingles boss. Sometimes in life things aren’t available at the right time,Moore had to go because the players did not know wether to stick or twist with his or Jones style of football. So now we wait when the time is right a new man will be employed ,but to say we’re not attractive is utter hogwash.
I make it sound like we are a club that works within its limited means in comparison to most of the clubs you mention. People like to think we're more attractive than we actually are but everything points to the opposite. We are unfashionable and now a tier 2 club. We couldn't win a villa scarf in a raffle while we were in the Prem. Like it or not, Dings and Vile are a bigger draw for players and managers. That JP statement that bunched everybody's tights up wasn't far off. We have punched above our weight with comparable limited resources for a long time. How many billionaire owners have both our local rivals had in the last 30 years? We were holding our own up there for a while then suddenly that wasn't enough. Remember the soiled knickers when we dropped off the pace when close to Everton? Oh how we'd love to be there now. People didn't care if we were relegated as long as it meant an end to TP but now there's soiled underwear at the thought of not getting back first time. The bollox on here is limitless at times. Start of the season we were so shite we would be relegated according to some. Now top 4 ain't good enough. You may say that the squad now looks better but that implies the club has done well!!!!! People moan about our loan system when it's our best option. If you can't attract quality players that would be good if we did get promoted there's no point building a bomb squad that'll need shifting. Loan players good or bad go back at the end of the season and will have given us either success or failure that we will have to cut our cloth to accordingly for next season. It's the opposite of being novices, it's something we're rather good at most of the time. Getting the best from the least spent. We got the sensible Chinese owner. Wolves got the ambitious one and Villa got the clown. Wolves look like Portsmouth did years ago and we all know how that fared once the owners got bored and fucked off. We'll always be what we are hopefully still punching above our weight. Time to be proud of that not a green eyed tit eyeing up the neighbours.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
03-26-2019, 06:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-26-2019, 06:41 PM by Baggiejacko.)
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS
It isn't a negative or zero investment policy. It's one of not buying players that won't improve the current squad. If we can't find any or persuade any to come here we will loan them. This will leave funds available for any player that does come along. The days of filling up the squad with expensive bodies on high wages have gone. Youth players will begin to feature more as a result of this. We will only spend money on what will be considered dead certs
Basically the money's there but not the desired players willing to join us. All the slagging off of staff at the club won't change that.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Wether the money there or not is not for any of us to know,with the right manager and yes I believe no matter which league we are in the players will come. I still think the crop of youngsters along with the the right recruitment players and manager we can be a force in any division. I agree with a lot that baggie says And things could change dramatically with a poor display this Friday.
|