Should they stay or should they go
#21
(03-14-2022, 10:15 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can't see a major overhaul:

SJ has been going since last summer - I'd be disappointed if we ended up with Button in goal for the season, not good enough and isn't going to get better now.  Either one of the kids to come in or find a replacement and keep Button (whose contract is also up) as No2.  He signed when SJ was here so he's clearly happy to be a second choice Champ keeper and loan the kids out again for more experience.  At some point you have to make a decision on if they're likely to ever be good enough. 

Defence:
Need to decide are we playing 3 CBs or a flat 4.
Bartley, O'Shea, Kipre, Ajayi, Bryan & Clarke plus the kids is clearly too many.  I'd take Clarke for the right price, subject to what little budget we have stretching that far, and I'd sacrifice any of the others bar O'Shea to do so.
Full backs or wing backs? - We need to decide and this is part of the problem with chopping and changing managers. Either way we've got to look at the kids (Ingram\TGH*) or we need a couple in to challenge.

Midfield - oh dear.  Livermore and Mowatt will be here.  If we can get out the Molumby deal I would hope we do so.  We need energy and drive in there Reed\Norwood type).
We also need someone to get ahead of the ball, someone who could play further forward in the Pereira type role.
Reach - will be difficult to shift him, maybe our utility player that can fill in at LWB and various midfield positions for 30 mins here and there.  If he's playing regularly we're staying mid-table at best.
TGH* RWB or CM? 
Castro - there's ability in him just not sure if he'd be better suited playing 6 a side with his mates rather than professional football.  Send him to L1/2 and see if he can play 90 mins and be disciplined enough to play to a shape and pattern required for a team game rather than flashes of individual skill.

Wingers - I'd take offers on Diangana, Robinson* and Phillips.  I doubt any will be forthcoming though.

Forwards - I'd offer Carroll another year, DK will be staying.  If anyone offered us the balance back on Grant I'd let him go and I'd happily let Robinson* go too.  Grant is such a conundrum - leading scorer but we consistently look poorer with him playing.  Cleary is obviously off too.

I'd hope for 3-4 permanent signings and making full use of the loan market dependent upon people far better qualified than I am determining the  readiness of a few youth players coming through.

Absolute must signings - 2 midlfielders, a right sided midfielder\winger and a forward.

As already said - it's all determined by having clear vision at the top of how we're going to play (shape and style) and if it's not working for that particular manager then making sure we get someone with similar ideals.  The squad needs to have continuity of this otherwise you end up with 3 left sided forwards, 1 right winger and a midfield unable to get ahead of the ball...

It depends on formation and dare I say it what division we're in!  You would hope we are developing two lists of targets with Yokuslu's name top of the list on both!  

A Goalkeeper.   Henderson is available. 

If Chump and we're playing three at the back we need wing-backs if not a right and left back to compete with who we have; though TGH could possibly fit either position on the right.

A right sided winger/attacking player - Josh Bowler looks promising.

Two Central midfielders to compete with what we've got - Sean Longstaff one possibly.   I would do everything we can to get Yokuslu who is only on loan and Celta are desperate to get rid.   There will be a number available at Toon that Bruce knows well;   

Forwards, if we're in the Champ - Carroll (if we give him a 12 month extension), Dike, Grant and Tulloch/Morton/Cleary et al should be ok. 

Carroll has done brilliant but he's not very mobile and Diagne might be a better option if he's interested in coming back.  Gayle is another who Bruce has been linked with.
Reply
#22
Wait, which Henderson? Dean Henderson!?
Reply
#23
(03-14-2022, 02:00 PM)Sliced Wrote: Wait, which Henderson? Dean Henderson!?

He’s always dreamed of playing for a mid-table Championship side.
Reply
#24
(03-14-2022, 02:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 02:00 PM)Sliced Wrote: Wait, which Henderson? Dean Henderson!?

He’s always dreamed of playing for a mid-table Championship side.

We should try and do a swap deal for De Gea when Sam Johnstone goes to United.
Reply
#25
(03-14-2022, 02:14 PM)SophLad Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 02:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 02:00 PM)Sliced Wrote: Wait, which Henderson? Dean Henderson!?

He’s always dreamed of playing for a mid-table Championship side.

We should try and do a swap deal for De Gea when Sam Johnstone goes to United.

I’ve heard Rashford wants to play in front of a less abusive set of fans too…
Reply
#26
Rather than think about what players we need to get rid off, we need to consider the gaps skills we have in the squad and to fill those.

For example we desperately need a midfield who can score goals. If we  continue to use wing backs, we are going to need to strengthen there. 

Whoever comes in, has to be a starter and not seen as squad filler. We need improvement,  not more of the same.

Our options to get rid off players is limited.

Would be surprised if we can bring in more than 3 or 4 new faces in the summer.
Reply
#27
Calls of changing 3/4 of our squad, even though most are overpayed, overpriced and on massive contacts and replacing them with the like of Dean Henderson.

Yeah right. Clueless.
Reply
#28
Think Barry bannon would be great for us ,playing really well ,some great assists and a few cracking goals
Reply
#29
At 32 Bannon would be a good example of us giving young players a chance!
Reply
#30
(03-14-2022, 02:00 PM)Sliced Wrote: Wait, which Henderson? Dean Henderson!?

Hoppy’s transfer targets are Dean Henderson, Sean Longstaff, Yokuslu, Gayle,  Diagne and Josh Bowler… 

I look forward to finding the £30m we’ll need for that, plus the massive wage bill increase.

Think there’s going to be a real dose of reality around our financial position this summer… Bowler probably the only one we can afford on that list!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: