Should they stay or should they go
#11
(03-14-2022, 10:09 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 08:55 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: List of players who in an Ideal world would you keep or not 


Goalkeepers

Johnstone - Wants to go & out of Contract
Button - Keep would be handy as keeper next season IMO
Palmer - A good back up keep him 

Left Back

Townsend - Poor this year, But we not going to get much for him so keep him
Reach - Release him

Right Back

Furlong - Has been poor for months, Bin him

Centre Backs

Kipre - Out of favour, We should get a decent price for him. Bin Him
Bartley - Over the hill lets cut our losses and bin him
Clarke - Wouldn't sign him again we need to move on from that
Ajayi - Clumsy on the ball, Would hope that Norwich are keen Bin Him
O'Shea - Make him Captain (Keep him)
Bryan - Injury prone so release him 

Midfield

Livermore - Thanks for the service, But get him Binned
Sawyers - Stoke should come with any offer and its enough Bin him
Moloumby  I would sign him like what been rumoured in the press
Mowatt - Keep as a squad Player
Phillips- Get him out, Over the hill 
Gardner-Hickman -  Obviously keep him 


Forwards

Robinson - Offers nothing- Get him binned
Grant - I would keep, Top Scorer
Carroll - Would offer him a new contract
Diagnana - Wants to leave and we should not stop him....Bin Him
Dyke - Keep him obviously

So in conclusion, We need a massive revamp & you can see the squad in not balanced 

Button, Palmer, O'Shea, Townsend, Moloumby, Mowatt, Taylor-Hickman, Carroll, Grant & Dyke  Plus Castro, Tulloch, Taylor, Ashworth etc 

We would need 8-9 players in the summer, its what's needed really

It's DIKE.  We are not going to get rid of 13 players some of whom have two years left on a lucrative contract.

Your correct.
Reply
#12
Can't see a major overhaul:

SJ has been going since last summer - I'd be disappointed if we ended up with Button in goal for the season, not good enough and isn't going to get better now. Either one of the kids to come in or find a replacement and keep Button (whose contract is also up) as No2. He signed when SJ was here so he's clearly happy to be a second choice Champ keeper and loan the kids out again for more experience. At some point you have to make a decision on if they're likely to ever be good enough.

Defence:
Need to decide are we playing 3 CBs or a flat 4.
Bartley, O'Shea, Kipre, Ajayi, Bryan & Clarke plus the kids is clearly too many. I'd take Clarke for the right price, subject to what little budget we have stretching that far, and I'd sacrifice any of the others bar O'Shea to do so.
Full backs or wing backs? - We need to decide and this is part of the problem with chopping and changing managers. Either way we've got to look at the kids (Ingram\TGH*) or we need a couple in to challenge.

Midfield - oh dear. Livermore and Mowatt will be here. If we can get out the Molumby deal I would hope we do so. We need energy and drive in there Reed\Norwood type).
We also need someone to get ahead of the ball, someone who could play further forward in the Pereira type role.
Reach - will be difficult to shift him, maybe our utility player that can fill in at LWB and various midfield positions for 30 mins here and there. If he's playing regularly we're staying mid-table at best.
TGH* RWB or CM?
Castro - there's ability in him just not sure if he'd be better suited playing 6 a side with his mates rather than professional football. Send him to L1/2 and see if he can play 90 mins and be disciplined enough to play to a shape and pattern required for a team game rather than flashes of individual skill.

Wingers - I'd take offers on Diangana, Robinson* and Phillips. I doubt any will be forthcoming though.

Forwards - I'd offer Carroll another year, DK will be staying. If anyone offered us the balance back on Grant I'd let him go and I'd happily let Robinson* go too. Grant is such a conundrum - leading scorer but we consistently look poorer with him playing. Cleary is obviously off too.

I'd hope for 3-4 permanent signings and making full use of the loan market dependent upon people far better qualified than I am determining the readiness of a few youth players coming through.

Absolute must signings - 2 midlfielders, a right sided midfielder\winger and a forward.

As already said - it's all determined by having clear vision at the top of how we're going to play (shape and style) and if it's not working for that particular manager then making sure we get someone with similar ideals. The squad needs to have continuity of this otherwise you end up with 3 left sided forwards, 1 right winger and a midfield unable to get ahead of the ball...
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#13
Can see there being a Clash here...
In the form of his life.
Reply
#14
FFS sorry Dike

or Deekay
Reply
#15
(03-14-2022, 10:23 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Can see there being a Clash here...

Can't help but think Palmer has been recalled but he'll be on the train in vain and won't get a look in.
Reply
#16
Our squad is really thin. We need to add to it, not ditch half the players.

First teamers need to become back ups and the following should probably leave:

Johnstone, Zohore. Wouldn't be sad to see the back of Bartley either.

We then need to have a cracking go at the loan market. If we do that then next season we'll have a chance of doing well. As tempting as it is if we get rid of a lot of players then we'll just get worse

Basically our team should be along the lines of:

Palmer
Townsend Ajayi O'Shea NewRightBack
NewCM Mowatt/Livermore
NewWinger TGH Grant
Dike

Bench: Button, Furlong, Kipre, Mowatt/Livermore, Diangana, Carroll, NewStriker

Squad Players: Molumby, Reach, Bryan, Robinson
Reply
#17
(03-14-2022, 10:40 AM)SophLad Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 10:23 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Can see there being a Clash here...

Can't help but think Palmer has been recalled but he'll be on the train in vain and won't get a look in.

We’re having a Clampdown on bad puns like this.
Reply
#18
Duffers Wrote:
SophLad Wrote:
Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:Can see there being a Clash here...

Can't help but think Palmer has been recalled but he'll be on the train in vain and won't get a look in.

We’re having a Clampdown on bad puns like this.
Birdmon has Complete Control.
Reply
#19
The squad is not thin on keepers (4 have played in the Championship & League One this season) and central defenders

Our real problems are
-too many players on long contracts who we do not want and neither does anybody else!
-few clubs outside the Premier League can now afford transfer fees
-little interest in these players from overseas (e.g. China and Saudi) although Derby sold Jozwiak to an American club last week

Gourlay said last week in the E &D we need to be creative so we need to try and do some part exchanges and loan players out. We will probably have to subsidize some players wages as well (e.g. Phillips, Livermore, Reach and Zohore) I would also be reluctant to cancel contracts and pay players off fully. If Snodgrass was paid till the end of the season then he has financially benefited by the move to Luton as he is now being paid by two clubs!

I hope we also give Taylor and Morton a go next season and bring in some young loanees from the top clubs (like Barnes) I suspect we will not do this any continue to sign "experienced pros" for one last payday which is why I would steer clear of Gayle and Carroll
Reply
#20
The midfield will be key. None of the current crop, of recognised CM's, should be first choice next season.
Livermore is on a long contract, so will be difficult to shift, but I don't mind him as cover or to come of the bench and shore up the back line occasionally.
I liked Mowatt in his first few games, but he seems to have lost his way, to the point where I wouldn't mind him going if it means we bring in someone more creative.
If TGH is to be recognised as a CM, going forward, then he has earned the right to establish himself, depends if Bruce still sees him as a defender.
Furlong can go and I think we'd get offers. Townsend probably has enough credits to stay, but we need competition.
Up front, only Grant deserves to stay. Get what we can for Grady and Robinson and, of course, the lesser spotted Zohore. Phillips will end up staying but hopefully, just as cover. If we get an offer, however, we should take it.
Johnstone is definitely going so it's whether we offer Button an extension to compete with Palmer.
CB is probably covered, whether or not we follow up on Clarke, so anyone coming in would have to be a real improvement otherwise they all become a much of a muchness.

Carroll's a difficult one as he's certainly done enough to be considered for a contract and he will always offer something different, but he's another one who's age is against him.

Inbound priorities have to be a creative CM, RB, LB a more mobile DM and a forward or 3. On a diminishing budget, Ron is on the money when he says we have to be creative.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: