Keep Bruce and reward failure!
#1
Looks like from what I’m hearing that Bruce will be here next season.I know we can’t keep swapping managers but to keep Bruce is like rewarding failure,we might not of been entertaining under Val but at least we controlled the game and came away bemoaning missed chances.All I’ve seen under Bruce is an Albion team who apart from the Hull match have been second best and even the draws against Blackburn and Huddersfield we got lucky and outplayed for long periods.Unfortunately Bruce so far hasn’t surprised me at all,he’s old school management and seems to send his teams out with very little structure.Don’t forget Gourlay appointed his mate on the back of Bruce’s reputation of getting teams promoted,did he know how long ago that was.If we went by that we might of even had Mad Mick on the list.I’m amazed the fans can’t see already what a bad choice Bruce is and it will hardly encourage people to renew season tickets for next season.
Reply
#2
(03-12-2022, 03:58 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Looks like from what I’m hearing that Bruce will be here next season.I know we can’t keep swapping managers but to keep Bruce is like rewarding failure,we might not of been entertaining under Val but at least we controlled the game and came away bemoaning missed chances.All I’ve seen under Bruce is an Albion team who apart from the Hull match have been second best and even the draws against Blackburn and Huddersfield we got lucky and outplayed for long periods.Unfortunately Bruce so far hasn’t surprised me at all,he’s old school management and seems to send his teams out with very little structure.Don’t forget Gourlay appointed his mate on the back of Bruce’s reputation of getting teams promoted,did he know how long ago that was.If we went by that we might of even had Mad Mick on the list.I’m amazed the fans can’t see already what a bad choice Bruce is and it will hardly encourage people to renew season tickets for next season.

He only has the same players at his disposal but there's one or two signs of improvement - 4 points from 6 and 4 goals for starters and broke the away hoodoo - now needs a home win, hopefully Tuesday. 

He's brought TGH in and bombed Reach and I like the way Ajayi is bombing forward.   He's playing two up top (which should improve further when Dike is back, hopefully at Blues) and maybe last night he struck on a winning formula with the late changes.  Yes, the finishing 11 is not as solid as the starting 11 but we're running out of games so need to take some risks to win games.  

He needs to speak to Sam to make sure he's absolutely focussed on the job in hand and has not taken his eye off the ball.  The first goal last night was a colossal misjudgement for someone of his so-called class.  He had plenty of time to hoof it into safety.  The second is more difficult to decide as to whether he's at fault as the ball could have slightly bobbled. 

The time to judge Bruce's brief tenure is when it's mathematically impossible to reach the play-offs as that is what he was brought in to achieve as a minimum.  As it stands we could win 7, draw 3 and scrape in - who knows?
Reply
#3
(03-12-2022, 04:16 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 03:58 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Looks like from what I’m hearing that Bruce will be here next season.I know we can’t keep swapping managers but to keep Bruce is like rewarding failure,we might not of been entertaining under Val but at least we controlled the game and came away bemoaning missed chances.All I’ve seen under Bruce is an Albion team who apart from the Hull match have been second best and even the draws against Blackburn and Huddersfield we got lucky and outplayed for long periods.Unfortunately Bruce so far hasn’t surprised me at all,he’s old school management and seems to send his teams out with very little structure.Don’t forget Gourlay appointed his mate on the back of Bruce’s reputation of getting teams promoted,did he know how long ago that was.If we went by that we might of even had Mad Mick on the list.I’m amazed the fans can’t see already what a bad choice Bruce is and it will hardly encourage people to renew season tickets for next season.

He only has the same players at his disposal but there's one or two signs of improvement - 4 points from 6 and 4 goals for starters and broke the away hoodoo - now needs a home win, hopefully Tuesday. 

He's brought TGH in and bombed Reach and I like the way Ajayi is bombing forward.   He's playing two up top (which should improve further when Dike is back, hopefully at Blues) and maybe last night he struck on a winning formula with the late changes.  Yes, the finishing 11 is not as solid as the starting 11 but we're running out of games so need to take some risks to win games.  

He needs to speak to Sam to make sure he's absolutely focussed on the job in hand and has not taken his eye off the ball.  The first goal last night was a colossal misjudgement for someone of his so-called class.  He had plenty of time to hoof it into safety.  The second is more difficult to decide as to whether he's at fault as the ball could have slightly bobbled. 

The time to judge Bruce's brief tenure is when it's mathematically impossible to reach the play-offs as that is what he was brought in to achieve as a minimum.  As it stands we could win 7, draw 3 and scrape in - who knows?

All about opinions but we can't keep having 2 managers a season. IF SB stays then we need to a least give him a full season. I for one doubt he will be able to improve this current bunch enough to get close to promotion next season but let's see if get can  wheel n deal in the summer and see what happens
Reply
#4
(03-12-2022, 04:27 PM)YoYoBaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 04:16 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 03:58 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Looks like from what I’m hearing that Bruce will be here next season.I know we can’t keep swapping managers but to keep Bruce is like rewarding failure,we might not of been entertaining under Val but at least we controlled the game and came away bemoaning missed chances.All I’ve seen under Bruce is an Albion team who apart from the Hull match have been second best and even the draws against Blackburn and Huddersfield we got lucky and outplayed for long periods.Unfortunately Bruce so far hasn’t surprised me at all,he’s old school management and seems to send his teams out with very little structure.Don’t forget Gourlay appointed his mate on the back of Bruce’s reputation of getting teams promoted,did he know how long ago that was.If we went by that we might of even had Mad Mick on the list.I’m amazed the fans can’t see already what a bad choice Bruce is and it will hardly encourage people to renew season tickets for next season.

He only has the same players at his disposal but there's one or two signs of improvement - 4 points from 6 and 4 goals for starters and broke the away hoodoo - now needs a home win, hopefully Tuesday. 

He's brought TGH in and bombed Reach and I like the way Ajayi is bombing forward.   He's playing two up top (which should improve further when Dike is back, hopefully at Blues) and maybe last night he struck on a winning formula with the late changes.  Yes, the finishing 11 is not as solid as the starting 11 but we're running out of games so need to take some risks to win games.  

He needs to speak to Sam to make sure he's absolutely focussed on the job in hand and has not taken his eye off the ball.  The first goal last night was a colossal misjudgement for someone of his so-called class.  He had plenty of time to hoof it into safety.  The second is more difficult to decide as to whether he's at fault as the ball could have slightly bobbled. 

The time to judge Bruce's brief tenure is when it's mathematically impossible to reach the play-offs as that is what he was brought in to achieve as a minimum.  As it stands we could win 7, draw 3 and scrape in - who knows?

All about opinions but we can't keep having 2 managers a season. IF SB stays then we need to a least give him a full season. I for one doubt he will be able to improve this current bunch enough to get close to promotion next season but let's see if get can  wheel n deal in the summer and see what happens

It's a monumental task now - even if he'd only picked up 2/3 more points we'd obviously be in a much better position. 

The unknown at the moment is what impact Dike might have in the last 8/9 games.  And what a win over Fulham might do for confidence.  

We shall see, at least the embers of this season are still just about glowing.
Reply
#5
Come on folks be realistic we aren’t going to make the playoffs on this form and standard of play.I do agree we need to stick with a manager through a complete season and if anything Val was the one to stick with.My gripe is that we have appointed the worst possible appointment in Bruce and I don’t buy into” he’s only got this group of players to work with”.That’s garbage it’s his job to organise and get the best out of the players like any good manager would.We are not playing in the Premier League ,we are playing in a sub standard Championship.I can’t believe fans would happily go along with Bruce for next season,just look at his recent record.The guy is a fraud and gullible fans are being taken in by him.It made me angry when we appointed him and watching the team have no direction and organisation is there for all to see.We have won one and lost four and the two games we drew we should of lost.Let’s get to the end of the season and have a total reset with a good management appointment,where in the summer there should be more managers to choose from.
Reply
#6
(03-12-2022, 05:22 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Come on folks be realistic we aren’t going to make the playoffs on this form and standard of play.I do agree we need to stick with a manager through a complete season and if anything Val was the one to stick with.My gripe is that we have appointed the worst possible appointment in Bruce and I don’t buy into” he’s only got this group of players to work with”.That’s garbage it’s his job to organise and get the best out of the players like any good manager would.We are not playing in the Premier League ,we are playing in a sub standard Championship.I can’t believe fans would happily go along with Bruce for next season,just look at his recent record.The guy is a fraud and gullible fans are being taken in by him.It made me angry when we appointed him and watching the team have no direction and organisation is there for all to see.We have won one and lost four and the two games we drew we should of lost.Let’s get to the end of the season and have a total reset with a good management appointment,where in the summer there should be more managers to choose from.
You really dont like him at all do you chap.  You say have a reset in summer when more managers are available ,exactly who will be available for fugg all( as we wont be paying compo) in the summer who would be a " good management appointment, comon name names build a case chap or your in danger of looking like having a vendetta against the guy.  Bruce wouldn't have been my 1st choice but he is here now so lets just get behind him and show a  united front for once ,see how he does in the summer getting rid of a few of these clowns and see if he brings in  anyone better or with a better stronger mental attiude. We just cant keep changing  managers at the rate we are and expect to consistently do well.
Reply
#7
(03-12-2022, 05:22 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Come on folks be realistic we aren’t going to make the playoffs on this form and standard of play.I do agree we need to stick with a manager through a complete season and if anything Val was the one to stick with.My gripe is that we have appointed the worst possible appointment in Bruce and I don’t buy into” he’s only got this group of players to work with”.That’s garbage it’s his job to organise and get the best out of the players like any good manager would.We are not playing in the Premier League ,we are playing in a sub standard Championship.I can’t believe fans would happily go along with Bruce for next season,just look at his recent record.The guy is a fraud and gullible fans are being taken in by him.It made me angry when we appointed him and watching the team have no direction and organisation is there for all to see.We have won one and lost four and the two games we drew we should of lost.Let’s get to the end of the season and have a total reset with a good management appointment,where in the summer there should be more managers to choose from.

Huggy, you are getting really boring now. What happens if we get into the play-offs this season, or even next? Will you back down and accept you were talking rubbish? One particular point - Steve Bruce was not the worst possible appointment. I can assure you that if they'd given the job to me we would be in serious deep shit  Big Grin

Ignoring my self-avowed lack of football knowledge or ability, I think Val Ismael was a fraud who took in gullible fans. I'm not expecting his xG statistics driven game to make any impact on the real world of football. We are well rid of him. Now we need to be rid of the core of this rotten and serially failing squad. Then we might give a coach a chance of success.
Reply
#8
Totally undecided at present. Just like BFS there was scant rebound effect, but I doubt that these players could rebound if they’d been dumped by an ex on a trampoline.

At least certain players (Furlong, Ajayi) seem to be improving. Would be nice to see a few more (notably Townsend, Mowatt, Diangana, Robinson) up their game too though. But in fairness, we really need to add O’Shea and Dick into the mix before we see what the entirety of this side can do under Bruce.

I’d echo the sentiment above that we need to break this cycle of 2 managers per season. There’s only been one out of the last how many (Bilic promotion season) that hasn’t been the case… Pulis’ last full season was it? Yet - coincidentally - it’s the only one during which we really went forwards.

Bruce isn’t perfect by any means. But neither is the job, the constraints, the owners and management structure, and certainly not the squad. The biggest error in recent times was not appointing Wilder who was head-and-shoulders the best fit; and eager to join too. But that of course can’t be undone now.
Reply
#9
(03-12-2022, 05:55 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 05:22 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Come on folks be realistic we aren’t going to make the playoffs on this form and standard of play.I do agree we need to stick with a manager through a complete season and if anything Val was the one to stick with.My gripe is that we have appointed the worst possible appointment in Bruce and I don’t buy into” he’s only got this group of players to work with”.That’s garbage it’s his job to organise and get the best out of the players like any good manager would.We are not playing in the Premier League ,we are playing in a sub standard Championship.I can’t believe fans would happily go along with Bruce for next season,just look at his recent record.The guy is a fraud and gullible fans are being taken in by him.It made me angry when we appointed him and watching the team have no direction and organisation is there for all to see.We have won one and lost four and the two games we drew we should of lost.Let’s get to the end of the season and have a total reset with a good management appointment,where in the summer there should be more managers to choose from.
You really dont like him at all do you chap.  You say have a reset in summer when more managers are available ,exactly who will be available for fugg all( as we wont be paying compo) in the summer who would be a " good management appointment, comon name names build a case chap or your in danger of looking like having a vendetta against the guy.  Bruce wouldn't have been my 1st choice but he is here now so lets just get behind him and show a  united front for once ,see how he does in the summer getting rid of a few of these clowns and see if he brings in  anyone better or with a better stronger mental attiude. We just cant keep changing  managers at the rate we are and expect to consistently do well.
Listen Tetley the big problem we have had is the clowns in charge of our club who see fit to change the manager because of fan pressure halfway through a season.Big Dave,Slaven and Val who all probably should of finished the season.It is not the fact of keep changing the manager it is the timing,as long as a manager is in for pre season or just before then it’s ideal but stick with it unless of course we are in a relegation battle.You ask for names and it’s not my job but I do read up on managers and coaches.Read up on Michael Beale the Villa assistant who players rate as a great coach.The MK Dons manager is interesting,they are out there and that’s before you look at foreign managers.It’s not a vendetta against Bruce it is purely watching his teams play and reading up on him.If you want a me to give a positive on him then he comes across as a really nice guy who conducts himself well.
Reply
#10
(03-12-2022, 05:22 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Come on folks be realistic we aren’t going to make the playoffs on this form and standard of play.I do agree we need to stick with a manager through a complete season and if anything Val was the one to stick with.My gripe is that we have appointed the worst possible appointment in Bruce and I don’t buy into” he’s only got this group of players to work with”.That’s garbage it’s his job to organise and get the best out of the players like any good manager would.We are not playing in the Premier League ,we are playing in a sub standard Championship.I can’t believe fans would happily go along with Bruce for next season,just look at his recent record.The guy is a fraud and gullible fans are being taken in by him.It made me angry when we appointed him and watching the team have no direction and organisation is there for all to see.We have won one and lost four and the two games we drew we should of lost.Let’s get to the end of the season and have a total reset with a good management appointment,where in the summer there should be more managers to choose from.

Bruce's start is similar to Sam's - though not as brutal - and without the bonus of being able to bring in three good players. 

We have 4 points from the last two, could have been 6 without Johnstone's aberration so there are gradual improvements - too slow as I've documented elsewhere.   Hull was better than last night but the opposition were far superior and in 2nd place if I'm not mistaken, yet we could have won.  As I said getting into the playoffs now will be a monumental task.  

Who are these gullible fans who have said they will be happy to go along with Bruce next season?  I must have missed it.  I never wanted him and would be glad to see him replaced with one proviso - that somehow he doesn't miraculously get us up!  

As you say there will be plenty of managers available to replace Bruce, if that's what Lai/Gourlay decide.

PS, please explain why he's a 'fraud'?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: