Why we have to move heaven and earth to keep Carroll
#11
Avoid at all costs.

We need to bring in better and younger.
Reply
#12
Well Ziz says no.

Biggest backing to say sign him yet.
Reply
#13
There were some posts during the game that were particularly unpleasant about Carroll and a few agreeing. I didn't comment and in the heat of the game I can sometimes understand - but I thought them not just unnecessary but demeaning to a guy who has shown more commitment than anyone else in this team.

As has been remarked upon all over this thread he gives everything and for that alone he deserves a contract. I think he shames half the team but if there's one word for a guy who has no need to put himself through the rigours of matchplay as often as he does, given his terrible injury history, then it's "professional".

He earns his living over and over. He clearly has a real sense of pride and commitment. I only hope he stays injury-free. His cuddle of the little girl after his goal was a lovely touch. I used to always laugh at how Olsen and Gmac had him in their pockets every time they played him but now? Hats off, I admire him.
Reply
#14
(03-12-2022, 10:26 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: There were some posts during the game that were particularly unpleasant about Carroll and a few agreeing.  I didn't comment and in the heat of the game I can sometimes understand - but I thought them not just unnecessary but demeaning to a guy who has shown more commitment than anyone else in this team.

As has been remarked upon all over this thread he gives everything and for that alone he deserves a contract.  I think he shames half the team but if there's one word for a guy who has no need to put himself through the rigours of matchplay as often as he does, given his terrible injury history, then it's "professional".

He earns his living over and over.  He clearly has a real sense of pride and commitment.  I only hope he stays injury-free. His cuddle of the little girl after his goal was a lovely touch. I used to always laugh at how Olsen and Gmac had him in their pockets every time they played him but now? Hats off, I admire him.
Bang on, Brent. Professional. many of ours are unprofessional while others are simply low on confidence and might improve with a bit more drive in the team. TBH, I don't care either way but at least get their agents working on loan deals to ship them out.  Carroll on a 12 month deal is a no brainer for me.
Reply
#15
(03-12-2022, 09:43 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Avoid at all costs.

We need to bring in better and younger.

Agreed, he is 33 not quick and injury prone. We should have learned our lesson now about giving contracts to older players, Snodgrass and Reach being the latest examples
Reply
#16
(03-12-2022, 10:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 09:43 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Avoid at all costs.

We need to bring in better and younger.

Agreed, he is 33 not quick and injury prone. We should have learned our lesson now about giving contracts to older players, Snodgrass and Reach being the latest examples

Reach was 28 when we signed him… age isn’t an issue, the issue is he’s gash.
Reply
#17
He is everything this team needs. We have a squad of timid players who shrink at the first sign of adversity. They were playing well until we gave them the lead and only pepped up when carroll came on and dragged them up a notch. What they need next season is a captaini in the middle of the park who can keep them on their game.
Reply
#18
(03-12-2022, 10:38 AM)petty sniper Wrote: He is everything this team needs.  We have a squad of timid players who shrink at the first sign of adversity.  They were playing well until we gave them the lead and only pepped up when carroll came on and dragged them up a notch.  What they need next season is a captaini in the middle of the park who can keep them on their game.

Exactly. Even with Carroll we desperately need a leader in midfield. This lot's heads drop at the first sign of a battle.
Reply
#19
(03-12-2022, 10:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 10:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(03-12-2022, 09:43 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Avoid at all costs.

We need to bring in better and younger.

Agreed, he is 33 not quick and injury prone. We should have learned our lesson now about giving contracts to older players, Snodgrass and Reach being the latest examples

Reach was 28 when we signed him… age isn’t an issue, the issue is he’s gash.

Agreed , at 28 though he is unlikely to get better. We could have kept Sam Field instead
Reply
#20
(03-12-2022, 10:26 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: There were some posts during the game that were particularly unpleasant about Carroll and a few agreeing.  I didn't comment and in the heat of the game I can sometimes understand - but I thought them not just unnecessary but demeaning to a guy who has shown more commitment than anyone else in this team.

As has been remarked upon all over this thread he gives everything and for that alone he deserves a contract.  I think he shames half the team but if there's one word for a guy who has no need to put himself through the rigours of matchplay as often as he does, given his terrible injury history, then it's "professional".

He earns his living over and over.  He clearly has a real sense of pride and commitment.  I only hope he stays injury-free. His cuddle of the little girl after his goal was a lovely touch. I used to always laugh at how Olsen and Gmac had him in their pockets every time they played him but now? Hats off, I admire him.

That's interesting, because at the ground he got the loudest applause of the night just for warming up. Fans know when a player tries. 


As long as the contract is short term, I see no issue in keeping him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)