Jos Buttler 'Mankad' dismissal: England batsman controversially run out in IPL
#1
Although mankading is within the rules of cricket, it's very unsporting.

This is the sort of behaviour that T20 is bringing into cricket given the amount of money involved in the format. 

Cricket has made its bed. Time for cricket to lie in it.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#2
I disagree. If the non-striker wants to steal an advantage he has to balance that with the risk of being run out.
Reply
#3
(03-25-2019, 07:14 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: I disagree. If the non-striker wants to steal an advantage he has to balance that with the risk of being run out.

Don’t be so pathetic if you can’t get him out with your bowling you resort to other means crap, if he had been given a warning fare enough, but Ashwin showed a total lack of respect to Butler by not giving him a warning. Also if you look Ashwin’s arm is on the way over before Butler moves so it’s only a slight advantage if any. Very bad sportsmanship and no need for it  Angry
Reply
#4
(03-25-2019, 07:24 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-25-2019, 07:14 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: I disagree. If the non-striker wants to steal an advantage he has to balance that with the risk of being run out.

Don’t be so pathetic if you can’t get him out with your bowling you resort to other means crap, if he had been given a warning fare enough, but Ashwin showed a total lack of respect to Butler by not giving him a warning. Also if you look Ashwin’s arm is on the way over before Butler moves so it’s only a slight advantage if any. Very bad sportsmanship and no need for it  Angry

He has been run out that way before. That should be warning enough.

Fair game if you ask me.
Reply
#5
(03-25-2019, 07:14 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: I disagree. If the non-striker wants to steal an advantage he has to balance that with the risk of being run out.

That'd be a valid point if Buttler was half way down the crease. He bearely moved.

Do you think being fans of football, where unsporting behaviour is normal and accepted, has softened us to when it happens in cricket?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#6
I used to be firmly in the “Mankad is unsporting” school, which was always within the laws of the game but not within the spirit of the game.

A couple of years ago the laws were changed to make it very clear that a batsman is trying to gain an advantage by stealing ground, and that it should no longer be considered “unsporting” to run out the batsman who is trying to do just that.

For those of us grew up under “the spirit of cricket” we have to accept that the game has moved on.

However, on this occasion the umpire was wrong to give it out because Ashwin’s front food had already landed and he was therefore past the point at which he should be completing the delivery of the ball. Buttler was not trying to gain an advantage here and was not stealing ground. It should have been given not out under the new laws. Nothing to do with the spirit of the game.
Reply
#7
(03-25-2019, 07:30 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(03-25-2019, 07:14 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: I disagree. If the non-striker wants to steal an advantage he has to balance that with the risk of being run out.

That'd be a valid point if Buttler was half way down the crease. He bearely moved.

Do you think being fans of football, where unsporting behaviour is normal and accepted, has softened us to when it happens in cricket?

Dunno mate. Cricket's had plenty of iffy moments itself. The Aussies are still whinging about England's Bodyline series 80 years after. The Windies removed batsmen by bowling at them, and not the wicket. Australia and ball tampering, steel bats, over the top sledging. Pakistan...well, where do you start?  We had Stuart Broad and his non walking. The Aussie underarm ball to avoid defeat to NZ. It goes on aplenty.
Reply
#8
(03-25-2019, 07:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I used to be firmly in the “Mankad is unsporting” school, which was always within the laws of the game but not within the spirit of the game.

A couple of years ago the laws were changed to make it very clear that a batsman is trying to gain an advantage by stealing ground, and that it should no longer be considered “unsporting” to run out the batsman who is trying to do just that.  

For those of us grew up under “the spirit of cricket” we have to accept that the game has moved on.

However, on this occasion the umpire was wrong to give it out because Ashwin’s front food had already landed and he was therefore past the point at which he should be completing the delivery of the ball. Buttler was not trying to gain an advantage here and was not stealing ground. It should have been given not out under the new laws.   Nothing to do with the spirit of the game.

Fair points Prag. Also a decent piece on Cricinfo
Reply
#9
(03-25-2019, 07:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I used to be firmly in the “Mankad is unsporting” school, which was always within the laws of the game but not within the spirit of the game.

A couple of years ago the laws were changed to make it very clear that a batsman is trying to gain an advantage by stealing ground, and that it should no longer be considered “unsporting” to run out the batsman who is trying to do just that.  

For those of us grew up under “the spirit of cricket” we have to accept that the game has moved on.

However, on this occasion the umpire was wrong to give it out because Ashwin’s front food had already landed and he was therefore past the point at which he should be completing the delivery of the ball. Buttler was not trying to gain an advantage here and was not stealing ground. It should have been given not out under the new laws.   Nothing to do with the spirit of the game.

Good post. Difficult to argue. 

Broad not walking was fucking hilarious, though!
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#10
(03-25-2019, 07:54 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(03-25-2019, 07:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I used to be firmly in the “Mankad is unsporting” school, which was always within the laws of the game but not within the spirit of the game.

A couple of years ago the laws were changed to make it very clear that a batsman is trying to gain an advantage by stealing ground, and that it should no longer be considered “unsporting” to run out the batsman who is trying to do just that.  

For those of us grew up under “the spirit of cricket” we have to accept that the game has moved on.

However, on this occasion the umpire was wrong to give it out because Ashwin’s front food had already landed and he was therefore past the point at which he should be completing the delivery of the ball. Buttler was not trying to gain an advantage here and was not stealing ground. It should have been given not out under the new laws.   Nothing to do with the spirit of the game.

Good post. Difficult to argue. 

Broad not walking was fucking hilarious, though!

That’s still one for “spirit of cricket”!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)