Acclaimed albums that are shit
#71
I'm not a fan of Queen but I'm OK if you like them. It takes all sorts etc. I think it is the theatrical aspect that puts me off. If anything I find their early stuff more decent but I must lack the sophistication to keep up with their magnificence.
Reply
#72
(03-07-2022, 11:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

I've kept out of this thread because it's so subjective. Just an opportunity to display your prejudices. I agree that "musos" ( not just blokes) of all types take themselves and their music tastes too seriously. I played in a band whose drummer was a big Genesis fan, hated Indie music and dismissed most of my favourites as "just pub rock".

So,  Meatloaf and Queen. Excellent music, clever, complicated and theatrical. If you can't appreciate a bit of musical theatre you have a chip missing IMO. But then I'm biased because I love a bit of real opera, travelled the world to see it. Many people dismiss opera as bollocks, but will pay good money to watch Cats or Les Mis.

Back to the OP. Can't think of a "classic album" that I would describe as crap, but Rumours by Fleetwood Mac doesn't hold my attention at all these days and Second Coming by Stone Roses really wasn't worth the 5 year wait.

And finally, for the benefit of Spandau, I reckon pop music mostly turned to shit after 1977. Just my onions.
What’s your age? It has a huge bearing on your mindset.
Reply
#73
(03-08-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 11:06 PM)hudds Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 10:32 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

Pity me.

Queen two good songs.  Brighton Rock (too much instrumental though) and Tie Your Mother Down.  The rest either overdose of Mercury poisoning or grim pointless shite.

Ay it.
The final two words of one of Brian May's greatest compositions.
I know that song and no way could it be called great.  A song on an overblown album.

You may glean
I hate Queen

But it's OK
For your gainsay

I'm now going to hear
Der Rosenkavalier

It's not rap or house
It's Richard Strauss
Reply
#74
hudds Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
hudds Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:Meatloaf - Bat out of Hell awful
Queen - rock music for BBC Children’s light entertainment shows and 1980s housewives

1)What's wrong with 1980s housewives? Most of the dreck mentioned on this thread is beloved by muso blokes who take themselves far too seriously.

2)You clearly have never heard Brighton Rock or The Whote Queen.

I was listening to the On Air album which is Queen's BBC sessions. Just so good. I pity people who don't like Queen.

Pity me.

Queen two good songs.  Brighton Rock (too much instrumental though) and Tie Your Mother Down.  The rest either overdose of Mercury poisoning or grim pointless shite.

Ay it.
The final two words of one of Brian May's greatest compositions.
I know that song and no way could it be called great.  A song on an overblown album.

You may glean
I hate Queen

But it's OK
For your gainsay

I'm now going to hear
Der Rosenkavalier

It's not rap or house
It's Richard Strauss
Dunno about that but I do know someone has dissed Astral Weeks, and the Sex Pistols, on this thread. I'm seriously considering my membership.
Reply
#75
For the Queen fans, I think Brian May seems like a great person, whose outlook on life is a refreshing change from the likes of Roger Daltrey, Eric Clapton, Morrissey etc. I’m sure Freddie Mercury wouldn’t have gone down the old man shouting at a cloud route either, so from a personal point of view this isn’t about them as people. It’s just the music, it’s far too bombastically theatrical for me, I don’t like indulgent instrumentals etc. I like rock music but I was grateful that the likes of Nirvana (as Punk had earlier) came along and changed the rock scene as it had become stale and clichéd and Queen were part of that. I don’t like Kiss either, because again it was all very ott.
Reply
#76
I've never understood the reverence held for The Clash.
Reply
#77
(03-08-2022, 08:49 PM)Arti Wrote: I've never understood the reverence held for The Clash.

You didn't see them live, I take it?
Reply
#78
(03-08-2022, 08:49 PM)Arti Wrote: I've never understood the reverence held for The Clash.

I bought Sandinista. It was dog shite.
Reply
#79
(03-08-2022, 07:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: For the Queen fans, I think Brian May seems like a great person, whose outlook on life is a refreshing change from the likes of Roger Daltrey, Eric Clapton, Morrissey etc. I’m sure Freddie Mercury wouldn’t have gone down the old man shouting at a cloud route either, so from a personal point of view this isn’t about them as people. It’s just the music, it’s far too bombastically theatrical for me, I don’t like indulgent instrumentals etc. I like rock music but I was grateful that the likes of Nirvana (as Punk had earlier) came along and changed the rock scene as it had become stale and clichéd and Queen were part of that. I don’t like Kiss either, because again it was all very ott.

But music can be OTT, just as it can be very simple and visceral. Different types and styles aren't mutually exclusive. It's a rich Tapestry (great album by the way, Carole King, my sister bought it back in the day).
Reply
#80
(03-08-2022, 09:49 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 08:49 PM)Arti Wrote: I've never understood the reverence held for The Clash.

I bought Sandinista. It was dog shite.

They were gone by then. The first  3 albums was when to see them, I've never seen anything like that energy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)