Luka Lynch
#11
(03-05-2022, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 11:49 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 10:54 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can someone do a sticky of the all the names of the kids we’ve lost so we can remember the names and see how many actually make a career out of football (and at what level).

To date I don’t think any of our stolen players have had an impact in the top flight.

Since the Academy was established, these are the ones I can think of who have left it for other clubs:

Jerome Sinclair
Yan Dhanda
Izzy Brown
Louie Barry
Morgan Rogers
Nathan Ferguson
Tim Iroegbanum
Triston Rowe
Finley Thorndike
Finn Azaz
Leo Carduso

Any more?

Matt Smith

Also wouldn't count Ferguson as that wasn't really academy poaching but a more a bosman.

There needs to be more protections for Category 1 academies to keep players being poached by other Category 1 academies.

I did wonder if Ferguson couldn't count. Still wrankles though. That fee could have kept the academy going for for years. I'll update list.
Reply
#12
I think there should be a ruling that means a minimum of say £100k is paid to the club where the youngster is poached from, and a 25% sell on clause applied.

Villa are quite happy to pinch players from other academies, as they're trying to emulate Chelsea, and it's a way to overcome FFP rulings. They'd be less inclined to do this if there were greater costs / penalties up front. 

There's no way that all the players they've pinched of us will make their first team, but sadly money talks, and we unfortunately don't have any.
Reply
#13
(03-05-2022, 10:54 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can someone do a sticky of the all the names of the kids we’ve lost so we can remember the names and see how many actually make a career out of football (and at what level).

To date I don’t think any of our stolen players have had an impact in the top flight.

CAB - We don't play in the top flight Mate and when we do we are never likely to trouble the Trophy engravers.
Many of those on that list would/could have had an impact for us in the past/present/future and I venture to say that in the case of Dhanda Brown, Sinclair their own careers would be better than they are now.
Iroegbanum, Ferguson (minus injuries) and Barry would be in the first team squad now IMO.
Reply
#14
(03-05-2022, 12:37 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I think there should be a ruling that means a minimum of say £100k is paid to the club where the youngster is poached from, and a 25% sell on clause applied.

Villa are quite happy to pinch players from other academies, as they're trying to emulate Chelsea, and it's a way to overcome FFP rulings. They'd be less inclined to do this if there were greater costs / penalties up front. 

There's no way more that all the players they've pinched of us will make their first team, but sadly money talks, and we unfortunately don't have any.

Agree absolutely about paying the club who the player is poached from but I think the fee has to be higher. It has to make the club doing the poaching think twice about doing it, not just stockpiling loads of youngsters because it's cheap to do so
Reply
#15
(03-05-2022, 11:58 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 11:49 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 10:54 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can someone do a sticky of the all the names of the kids we’ve lost so we can remember the names and see how many actually make a career out of football (and at what level).

To date I don’t think any of our stolen players have had an impact in the top flight.

Since the Academy was established, these are the ones I can think of who have left it for other clubs:

Jerome Sinclair
Yan Dhanda
Izzy Brown
Louie Barry
Morgan Rogers
Nathan Ferguson
Tim Iroegbanum
Triston Rowe
Finley Thorndike
Finn Azaz
Leo Carduso

Any more?

Matt Smith

Also wouldn't count Ferguson as that wasn't really academy poaching but a more a bosman.

There needs to be more protections for Category 1 academies to keep players being poached by other Category 1 academies.

I did wonder if Ferguson couldn't count. Still wrankles though. That fee could have kept the academy going for for years. I'll update list.

Heavily weighted on add-ons which we'll probably never get as he's injured again!

(03-05-2022, 11:49 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 10:54 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can someone do a sticky of the all the names of the kids we’ve lost so we can remember the names and see how many actually make a career out of football (and at what level).

To date I don’t think any of our stolen players have had an impact in the top flight.

Since the Academy was established, these are the ones I can think of who have left it for other clubs:

Jerome Sinclair
Yan Dhanda
Izzy Brown
Louie Barry
Morgan Rogers
Matt Smith
Tim Iroegbanum
Triston Rowe
Finley Thorndike
Finn Azaz
Leo Carduso

Any more?

Tyler Roberts was I believe lured away with a lucrative offer from Leeds. 

Cleary next?  

Tbh - and I can understand why they leave at 15/16 to the likes of the European Champions! - but we don't want 'deserters' in our ranks.  If they feel they can ply their trade elsewhere and become successful their choice but I doubt any of the above will become established premier league players - time will tell. 

We actually got a good deal for Rogers with City.
Reply
#16
We’ll never stop the poaching but it’s the compensation system that needs fixing. It does absolutely nothing at present other than incentivise big clubs to cherry pick, and we cannot tie players down to a contract until their 17th birthday by which time they’ve already been tapped up via England age groups squads and told not to sign for us.

£100k for an U16 and £250k for a 17+ year old who hasn’t signed a contract, plus a share of any sell-on fees before the player’s 23rd birthday would seem fair.
Reply
#17
(03-05-2022, 01:07 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(03-05-2022, 10:54 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Can someone do a sticky of the all the names of the kids we’ve lost so we can remember the names and see how many actually make a career out of football (and at what level).

To date I don’t think any of our stolen players have had an impact in the top flight.

CAB - We don't play in the top flight Mate and when we do we are never likely to trouble the Trophy engravers.
Many of those on that list would/could have had an impact for us in the past/present/future and I venture to say that in the case of Dhanda Brown, Sinclair their own careers would be better than they are now.
Iroegbanum, Ferguson (minus injuries) and Barry would be in the first team squad now IMO.

Some may have been better served by staying, we’ll never know. 

The same Louie Barry that couldn’t get a game for Ipswich in League 1?
Trump is a Cunt
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)