Posts: 264
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(03-01-2022, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem is we have set the team up to play Val Ball. It completely limits the way you can play, notably our midfield. Look at our options in central midfield, they have no creativity but will run all day. That was a choice of the previous managers. We didn’t need to be creative in central midfield because we bypassed the middle of the park, playing the statistical percentages.
The wheels started to quickly come off that way of playing no matter where we were before Bruce took over. Bruce is clearly trying to get the team to play more expansive football in the hope we create and convert more chances but the problem is we don’t have the players in central midfield who can do that job. We have filled it with expensive Sean Flynn’s. We are now stuck trying to play a completely different way under Bruce because we can’t score goals and we increasingly can’t create chances.
That was always the risk of playing a very particular way under Val. It leaves little or no flexibility if you try and change the way you play. The seasons a write off and it’ll get harder rather than easier to win promotion from this point onwards but whoever manages next year has to be given the season but realises the urgency of trying to win promotion. Long term fixes will only work with investment (money) and we dint have that luxury.
You end a post criticising a manager who wasn't given enough time to turn the squad over by saying the next manager needs to be given at least a season. The investment in Val should have meant he was given at least a season. There are plenty of managers with one way of playing. It's not like he was given the best tools for the job either was it.
Largely agree with you though. Bruce has been stupid in trying to change too much. 75% of the team under Val worked, now we create less and can't defend. Well done Steve.
I criticise Val for making the team / squad so limited to one way of playing. The fact it inevitably stopped working once coaches had seen us play for a few weeks was always going leave us in a mess. What did you expect Bruce to do? Try and play Val ball?
I’ve said all season we are one dimensional and that our midfield lacked creativity. That was a choice Val made for a squad he said he was very happy with. And yet not so long ago you said that we had a squad that was top 3 and all that was needed was a manager that would use a formation and a style of play that suited the players we had and things would improve.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-01-2022, 11:57 AM)GMBaggie Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem is we have set the team up to play Val Ball. It completely limits the way you can play, notably our midfield. Look at our options in central midfield, they have no creativity but will run all day. That was a choice of the previous managers. We didn’t need to be creative in central midfield because we bypassed the middle of the park, playing the statistical percentages.
The wheels started to quickly come off that way of playing no matter where we were before Bruce took over. Bruce is clearly trying to get the team to play more expansive football in the hope we create and convert more chances but the problem is we don’t have the players in central midfield who can do that job. We have filled it with expensive Sean Flynn’s. We are now stuck trying to play a completely different way under Bruce because we can’t score goals and we increasingly can’t create chances.
That was always the risk of playing a very particular way under Val. It leaves little or no flexibility if you try and change the way you play. The seasons a write off and it’ll get harder rather than easier to win promotion from this point onwards but whoever manages next year has to be given the season but realises the urgency of trying to win promotion. Long term fixes will only work with investment (money) and we dint have that luxury.
You end a post criticising a manager who wasn't given enough time to turn the squad over by saying the next manager needs to be given at least a season. The investment in Val should have meant he was given at least a season. There are plenty of managers with one way of playing. It's not like he was given the best tools for the job either was it.
Largely agree with you though. Bruce has been stupid in trying to change too much. 75% of the team under Val worked, now we create less and can't defend. Well done Steve.
I criticise Val for making the team / squad so limited to one way of playing. The fact it inevitably stopped working once coaches had seen us play for a few weeks was always going leave us in a mess. What did you expect Bruce to do? Try and play Val ball?
I’ve said all season we are one dimensional and that our midfield lacked creativity. That was a choice Val made for a squad he said he was very happy with. And yet not so long ago you said that we had a squad that was top 3 and all that was needed was a manager that would use a formation and a style of play that suited the players we had and things would improve.
I still think the squad is better than most, sadly I don’t think it works as a whole anymore, but I suspect it will get better at what Bruce is trying to do given more than a month in the job. There is quality underneath the rubble of teams shattered confidence but after months of failure it’s hardly surprising it’s not on display in matches.
I did think our midfield would adapt better and more quickly but it’s become obvious that their specific skills of running around a lot, whilst letting go of decent players at this level like Snodgrass and Sawyers may have made us a bit of a one dimensional than I thought.
I’m very happy others are getting a chance to say I told you so though, if it makes them feel better when we are akin to Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich in a couple of seasons then it’ll have been worth it
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-01-2022, 12:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I still think the squad is better than most, sadly I don’t think it works as a whole anymore, but I suspect it will get better at what Bruce is trying to do given more than a month in the job. There is quality underneath the rubble of teams shattered confidence but after months of failure it’s hardly surprising it’s not on display in matches.
I did think our midfield would adapt better and more quickly but it’s become obvious that their specific skills of running around a lot, whilst letting go of decent players at this level like Snodgrass and Sawyers may have made us a bit of a one dimensional than I thought.
I’m very happy others are getting a chance to say I told you so though, if it makes them feel better when we are akin to Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich in a couple of seasons then it’ll have been worth it 
We are more likely to end up like Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich if we sack a manager every six months because some fans don't like the way he plays.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(03-01-2022, 12:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I still think the squad is better than most, sadly I don’t think it works as a whole anymore, but I suspect it will get better at what Bruce is trying to do given more than a month in the job. There is quality underneath the rubble of teams shattered confidence but after months of failure it’s hardly surprising it’s not on display in matches.
I did think our midfield would adapt better and more quickly but it’s become obvious that their specific skills of running around a lot, whilst letting go of decent players at this level like Snodgrass and Sawyers may have made us a bit of a one dimensional than I thought.
I’m very happy others are getting a chance to say I told you so though, if it makes them feel better when we are akin to Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich in a couple of seasons then it’ll have been worth it 
We are more likely to end up like Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich if we sack a manager every six months because some fans don't like the way he plays. Stick with Bruce then?
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(03-01-2022, 12:40 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I still think the squad is better than most, sadly I don’t think it works as a whole anymore, but I suspect it will get better at what Bruce is trying to do given more than a month in the job. There is quality underneath the rubble of teams shattered confidence but after months of failure it’s hardly surprising it’s not on display in matches.
I did think our midfield would adapt better and more quickly but it’s become obvious that their specific skills of running around a lot, whilst letting go of decent players at this level like Snodgrass and Sawyers may have made us a bit of a one dimensional than I thought.
I’m very happy others are getting a chance to say I told you so though, if it makes them feel better when we are akin to Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich in a couple of seasons then it’ll have been worth it 
We are more likely to end up like Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich if we sack a manager every six months because some fans don't like the way he plays. Stick with Bruce then?
When he was appointed I said he should be given a free pass whatever happens so he can rebuild in the summer. However, tactically he’s been far worse than I could imagine. It’s clearly not working having Adam Reach at CAM. He’s not the only problem, but that system doesn’t work. Bruce is doing the same thing week after week when the system he’s playing has never worked.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-01-2022, 12:40 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I still think the squad is better than most, sadly I don’t think it works as a whole anymore, but I suspect it will get better at what Bruce is trying to do given more than a month in the job. There is quality underneath the rubble of teams shattered confidence but after months of failure it’s hardly surprising it’s not on display in matches.
I did think our midfield would adapt better and more quickly but it’s become obvious that their specific skills of running around a lot, whilst letting go of decent players at this level like Snodgrass and Sawyers may have made us a bit of a one dimensional than I thought.
I’m very happy others are getting a chance to say I told you so though, if it makes them feel better when we are akin to Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich in a couple of seasons then it’ll have been worth it 
We are more likely to end up like Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich if we sack a manager every six months because some fans don't like the way he plays. Stick with Bruce then?
I'd agree if he wasn't a short term, jobs for the boys appointment who's managed to break the only thing about this team that worked in five games.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(03-01-2022, 12:46 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:40 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 12:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I still think the squad is better than most, sadly I don’t think it works as a whole anymore, but I suspect it will get better at what Bruce is trying to do given more than a month in the job. There is quality underneath the rubble of teams shattered confidence but after months of failure it’s hardly surprising it’s not on display in matches.
I did think our midfield would adapt better and more quickly but it’s become obvious that their specific skills of running around a lot, whilst letting go of decent players at this level like Snodgrass and Sawyers may have made us a bit of a one dimensional than I thought.
I’m very happy others are getting a chance to say I told you so though, if it makes them feel better when we are akin to Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich in a couple of seasons then it’ll have been worth it 
We are more likely to end up like Blues, Sunderland or Ipswich if we sack a manager every six months because some fans don't like the way he plays. Stick with Bruce then?
When he was appointed I said he should be given a free pass whatever happens so he can rebuild in the summer. However, tactically he’s been far worse than I could imagine. It’s clearly not working having Adam Reach at CAM. He’s not the only problem, but that system doesn’t work. Bruce is doing the same thing week after week when the system he’s playing has never worked. Same, I thought he would get a reaction from the players, which he may still do of course, but it doesn't look likely. I think it will be a moot point anyway because he'll do an Allardyce and walk in May, but, based on his first 5 games it doesn't look good long term.
I'll hold my hands up and say that I overestimated the quality of the squad and a lot of these players are just god awful so we need a proper clear out in summer, which probably means another new manager. 
As with any long term plan though, it has to be the right man and Val just wasn't. It doesn't appear Bruce is either.
I can put up with losing, even losing runs, god knows I've seen enough over the years, but when you add up how much these goons are on, and have cost, it just makes my piss boil and I think that's what frustrates the fans so much.
If we were like a Luton, or Cov and had some promising youth with a few old heads chucked in, on reasonable wages, I could almost accept what's being churned out now, in view of the greater good, but these players are just taking the piss and cannot in anyway justify what they earn.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(03-01-2022, 11:33 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-01-2022, 10:46 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think all this arguing about Ismael is a bit tedious to be honest.
A more pertinent question is why form fell completely off a cliff after xmas.
The last game I watched before xmas was Barnsley, not a great game, we were dominant without being pretty to watch and had enough chances to win the match. A game typical of the season at that point.
Since then every game I have seen since then has seen us play at a level way below that, whether Bruce or Ismael was in charge. Possibly the only exception was first half hour against Sheff U.
What has changed since Xmas. Is it just confidence, are other teams less afraid of us, it was a feature of the first half of the season how hardly anyone took the game to us. Was it the criticism of the players by Ismael after the Derby performance. Definitely confidence. We (fans) don't expect to score, let alone win, so they must be the same.
The thing is though, if you lack confidence in a fight, you have to have guts and that's what's letting this mob down, they have no balls for it and are all either shrinking or shirking. Val's hard nosed disciplined approach failed and now Bruce's come on lads keep plodding on approach is failing just as badly.
They are bottlers to a man and I've no idea what sort of manager can change it.
Best I can offer is give youth a chance for the rest of the season and have a fire sale in summer. I know they are crap but you only have to listen to commentators and pundits to know how overrated some of them are, especially the likes of Furlong, Bartley, Livermore, Phillips and Grant. If Bruce, or whoever is next, has the courage to tell them they are not in his plans, they will get suitors. Might not generate much revenue but it will get them off the wage bill and allow us to bring in players with a bit of fight left in them.
This nails it - been saying it for about 2 years.
Bang for buck - this lot are worse than Little's bunch of losers from 99/00
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(03-01-2022, 10:07 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Anybody who has kicked a ball or managed a team at any level knows you play to your strengths, if we had 3 Pereira's in our squad you would play through the lines, on the deck, allow movement in behind etc
Our best players are our centre halves, we should be 3 at the back all season, Bruce tried to change this to gain popularity as clearly he was told the fans had enough of 3-4-3 when actually as we can now see 5 games in it's comfortably our best system. Clarke who I've stated has been our best defender by a distance this season, gets bombed and now under Bruce we've gone from the best defence in the league to one of the worse
Derek it's not rocked science fella, if you've got workers, grafters in the middle of the park playing thorugh midfield isn't a priority, Val was all about get the ball wide and get the ball in the box, as frustrated as I was at times with this and his stubbounress we did create, we were craving a number 9 and got Hugill and then Dike got injured, Val was desperate for a midfielder in Jan, the club didn't deliver
You play to your strengths, Val was doing this, Bruce hasn't a clue what our strengths are, season is gone, he should go after Saturday and let Mozza and Brunt finish the season and we start planning now for a summer of recruitment, change and a new manager
Absolute shitshow
Cuzer
Spot on. This spineless bunch stopped working the second they sensed they could be rid of the last manager. Lai racing over here to sanction the signing of Dike showed he was still keeping the faith. Then the injury to Dike was a huge moment that will shape our future for, quite possibly, many years. We all saw what happened next.
Now tell me honestly, would it not have been better to put up with some moaning from the fans (and the players who were unhappy about having to put a shift in), and wait for Dike to come back?
I'll also add, the SamJ debacle and the players that sided with him, AGAINST the club and it's fans should absolutely be told to get on with it- Fergie style.
Posts: 1,636
Threads: 52
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-01-2022, 04:47 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (03-01-2022, 10:07 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Anybody who has kicked a ball or managed a team at any level knows you play to your strengths, if we had 3 Pereira's in our squad you would play through the lines, on the deck, allow movement in behind etc
Our best players are our centre halves, we should be 3 at the back all season, Bruce tried to change this to gain popularity as clearly he was told the fans had enough of 3-4-3 when actually as we can now see 5 games in it's comfortably our best system. Clarke who I've stated has been our best defender by a distance this season, gets bombed and now under Bruce we've gone from the best defence in the league to one of the worse
Derek it's not rocked science fella, if you've got workers, grafters in the middle of the park playing thorugh midfield isn't a priority, Val was all about get the ball wide and get the ball in the box, as frustrated as I was at times with this and his stubbounress we did create, we were craving a number 9 and got Hugill and then Dike got injured, Val was desperate for a midfielder in Jan, the club didn't deliver
You play to your strengths, Val was doing this, Bruce hasn't a clue what our strengths are, season is gone, he should go after Saturday and let Mozza and Brunt finish the season and we start planning now for a summer of recruitment, change and a new manager
Absolute shitshow
Cuzer
Spot on. This spineless bunch stopped working the second they sensed they could be rid of the last manager. Lai racing over here to sanction the signing of Dike showed he was still keeping the faith. Then the injury to Dike was a huge moment that will shape our future for, quite possibly, many years. We all saw what happened next.
Now tell me honestly, would it not have been better to put up with some moaning from the fans (and the players who were unhappy about having to put a shift in), and wait for Dike to come back?
I'll also add, the SamJ debacle and the players that sided with him, AGAINST the club and it's fans should absolutely be told to get on with it- Fergie style.
Totally agree as far as I am concerned Johnstone should have never played for the club again. I don’t disagree with vals sacking but he stood up to someone who quite frankly doesn’t want to be here and had a tantrum because he showed a complete lack of discipline and then expected to come straight back in the starting 11. If I was Bruce now I would bomb him out of the squad and tell him a big fuck you. No one is bigger than the club and if any of the current squad kicked off aswell I would Bomb them out aswell. These overpaid uncaring cunts need teaching a lesson
|