Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-01-2022, 09:19 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I would imagine Luton, Milwall, Preston, Coventry all had equally if not more paltry budgets, yet managed to put together cohesive squads. I've never laid all the blame at Val's door, the problems run far deeper, but he brought in Hugill, Mowatt, Reach and Molumby, that is just a fact. If he didn't and they were brought in against his will, then what would have been the point of giving him more windows anyway?
The money situation is what it is, we can't magic up money that we don't have, that's why we need a manager who can build a squad based on the budget he has and that just wasn't Val.
The notion that under these owners, what is the point of anything is one I can firmly agree with.
Posts: 8,004
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(03-01-2022, 09:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 09:19 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I would imagine Luton, Milwall, Preston, Coventry all had equally if not more paltry budgets, yet managed to put together cohesive squads. I've never laid all the blame at Val's door, the problems run far deeper, but he brought in Hugill, Mowatt, Reach and Molumby, that is just a fact. If he didn't and they were brought in against his will, then what would have been the point of giving him more windows anyway?
The money situation is what it is, we can't magic up money that we don't have, that's why we need a manager who can build a squad based on the budget he has and that just wasn't Val.
The notion that under these owners, what is the point of anything is one I can firmly agree with. But then he got Dike?
Did they suddenly say, this plan we have of forcing players on the manager, that he doesn't really want, isn't working, let's give him £7m from down the back of the sofa.
I'm not defending the hierarchy, they are useless, but I genuinely believe that Val was happy with that midfield and that has to raise questions about his ideals.
I know who didn't sanction or recruit them and that's the fans, so to blame them is just silly. Yes we were angry, frustrated and impatient but to say we got what we deserve is wrong.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
03-01-2022, 09:41 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-01-2022, 09:41 AM by Ted Maul.)
(03-01-2022, 09:33 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-01-2022, 09:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 09:19 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I would imagine Luton, Milwall, Preston, Coventry all had equally if not more paltry budgets, yet managed to put together cohesive squads. I've never laid all the blame at Val's door, the problems run far deeper, but he brought in Hugill, Mowatt, Reach and Molumby, that is just a fact. If he didn't and they were brought in against his will, then what would have been the point of giving him more windows anyway?
The money situation is what it is, we can't magic up money that we don't have, that's why we need a manager who can build a squad based on the budget he has and that just wasn't Val.
The notion that under these owners, what is the point of anything is one I can firmly agree with. But then he got Dike?
Did they suddenly say, this plan we have of forcing players on the manager, that he doesn't really want, isn't working, let's give him £7m from down the back of the sofa.
I'm not defending the hierarchy, they are useless, but I genuinely believe that Val was happy with that midfield and that has to raise questions about his ideals.
I know who didn't sanction or recruit them and that's the fans, so to blame them is just silly. Yes we were angry, frustrated and impatient but to say we got what we deserve is wrong.
Maybe he was, for the most part it worked. Barring the last few games I didn't hear too many dissenting voices about Mowatt, he's gone backwards just as quickly as players Val didn't sign. Clarke should be in the team as part of a back three and until recent weeks was a key part of the best defence in the division. Dike was the missing piece of the puzzle and it took the board 25 games of watching Jordan Hugill miss sitters to sanction that.
Fact is, if we're going to task a bloke with a rebuild, at least let him try and build something. We'd be better off missing out on the play offs this season with a manager who's got a year under his belt, knows what needs changing than having to find another new manager to turn us around this summer, with a totally different idea of how to play and even less money to sign players with. I genuinely feel the impatience of a vocal minority of fans has led to this and will cost us over the coming seasons.
No need for me to say anymore on the subject I think. Fair play if you go every week.
Posts: 1,352
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
Where do we go from here?
We start with basics. We go back to three at the back with five across midfield and two up top. We have to stop leaking goals first and foremost. We get hard to beat and organised:
............Johnstone
OShea Bartley Clarke
..................Molumby
Furlong Livermore TGH Townsend
...........Carroll Robinson
If Bruce has any idea at all that's the way he would go on Saturday. Players that are hiding like Mowatt, - OUT! Get proper strong defenders in, get competitive Players in midfield and start from there.
Get your wingback wide and get service to Carroll. Townsend statistically is one of the best crossers in the Championship (check out the stats). Since Carroll came in Townsend has barely put in a cross as we've reverted to a back four (which will and has led to us conceding two a game).
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(03-01-2022, 08:57 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-01-2022, 08:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2022, 07:56 AM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote: The only way forward is to address the lack of consistency in our vision and approach to building the club back to a promotion drive in the medium term. If we keep aiming for short term fixes (so that Lai can sell the club on promotion), we will continue to go backwards, who knows where that would end.
We were half a season into doing this but then took a huge risk because Jordan Hugill kept missing sitters essentially.
This is he most confusing thing for me Ted, if he'd have managed to score some of the chances it would have obviously improved the results but also the confidence of the team. This and Val's stubbornness in not changing formation to suit the players or the opposition every now and again are what have led to the '4 year project' being thrown out at the 1st sign of an issue. 4 year fucking project chucked in the bin after 6 months, I ask ya.
The same morons now saying we need to give Bruce time to sort the mess out. The mess that was created by our own impatience and entitlement.
As I've said, we're getting what we deserve now.
Not true though is it? Not even remotely.
The mess was created by Val and his inept signings and compounded by his inflexibility. The fact that Bruce is also rubbish and has just carried on where Val left off, does not make Val the messiah. The fact that you would lay the blame at fans who have followed the club for decades, through thick and thin, in order to defend someone who was at the club for 6 months and had us in a downward spiral is just beyond bizarre.
The truth is we would likely be where we are whichever of them were in charge because they have the same group of players. In that sense Bruce gets some sympathy because he inherited them, whereas Val had 2 windows, but both are culpable. The fans most certainly are not.
Bob, do you seriously believe Val was happy with Hugill and Reach FFS?
He was given Mowatt who he wanted, he was then told loans and free's were his sum lot until January when it would be reviewed
We did well to get Dike, who then got injured, he was desperate for a midfielder which we didn't deliver and then he got sacked
This wasn't of "Val's doing" I think it's clear to see now he was getting way more out of these primadonna's than most managers would, still, we have no patience do we
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(03-01-2022, 09:50 AM)Atomic Wrote: Where do we go from here?
We start with basics. We go back to three at the back with five across midfield and two up top. We have to stop leaking goals first and foremost. We get hard to beat and organised:
............Johnstone
OShea Bartley Clarke
..................Molumby
Furlong Livermore TGH Townsend
...........Carroll Robinson
If Bruce has any idea at all that's the way he would go on Saturday. Players that are hiding like Mowatt, - OUT! Get proper strong defenders in, get competitive Players in midfield and start from there.
Get your wingback wide and get service to Carroll. Townsend statistically is one of the best crossers in the Championship (check out the stats). Since Carroll came in Townsend has barely put in a cross as we've reverted to a back four (which will and has led to us conceding two a game).
I never want to see Furlong and Townsend as our “attacking” wide players again.
Posts: 239
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
0
I remember when Albion fans turned on the board in 1999 when we lost 5-1 to Crewe, It got worse with the defeat against Blues (22 years ago on Thursday) being a watershed.
Looked at the table we are higher when we lost to Crewe then we are currently
Look at the team that day
Phil Whitehead, Paul Holmes, Daryl Burgess, Matt Carbon, Jason Van Blerk, Kevin Kilbane, Mario Bortolazzi, Enzo Maresca, Richard Sneekes, Mark Angel, Lee Hughes
Subs: Graham Potter, Shaun Murphy (Who was booed by Albion fans), Brian Quailey
What would a combined team of that and yesterday result in?
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(03-01-2022, 10:41 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: I remember when Albion fans turned on the board in 1999 when we lost 5-1 to Crewe, It got worse with the defeat against Blues (22 years ago on Thursday) being a watershed.
Looked at the table we are higher when we lost to Crewe then we are currently
Look at the team that day
Phil Whitehead, Paul Holmes, Daryl Burgess, Matt Carbon, Jason Van Blerk, Kevin Kilbane, Mario Bortolazzi, Enzo Maresca, Richard Sneekes, Mark Angel, Lee Hughes
Subs: Graham Potter, Shaun Murphy (Who was booed by Albion fans), Brian Quailey
What would a combined team of that and yesterday result in?
Hughes, Maresca, Kilbane and Sneekes are all better than anything we currently have…
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(03-01-2022, 10:41 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: I remember when Albion fans turned on the board in 1999 when we lost 5-1 to Crewe, It got worse with the defeat against Blues (22 years ago on Thursday) being a watershed.
Looked at the table we are higher when we lost to Crewe then we are currently
Look at the team that day
Phil Whitehead, Paul Holmes, Daryl Burgess, Matt Carbon, Jason Van Blerk, Kevin Kilbane, Mario Bortolazzi, Enzo Maresca, Richard Sneekes, Mark Angel, Lee Hughes
Subs: Graham Potter, Shaun Murphy (Who was booed by Albion fans), Brian Quailey
What would a combined team of that and yesterday result in?
For all of the inadequacies of our 90s sides, we don't have anyone of the attacking quality of Hughes, Maresca, Kilbane or Sneekes, or prior to that, Super Bob and Andy Hunt.
Andy Carroll could do well if given some service but the rest are just pathetic. I think Robinson is a decent player but half arsed and mentally and physically weak. Diangana threatens to be dangerous but there's no end product. Grant is anonymous 95% of the time he's on the pitch. I really don't know what the answer is as we're stuck with this lot and have no money to bring in replacements.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(03-01-2022, 10:44 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-01-2022, 10:41 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: I remember when Albion fans turned on the board in 1999 when we lost 5-1 to Crewe, It got worse with the defeat against Blues (22 years ago on Thursday) being a watershed.
Looked at the table we are higher when we lost to Crewe then we are currently
Look at the team that day
Phil Whitehead, Paul Holmes, Daryl Burgess, Matt Carbon, Jason Van Blerk, Kevin Kilbane, Mario Bortolazzi, Enzo Maresca, Richard Sneekes, Mark Angel, Lee Hughes
Subs: Graham Potter, Shaun Murphy (Who was booed by Albion fans), Brian Quailey
What would a combined team of that and yesterday result in?
Hughes, Maresca, Kilbane and Sneekes are all better than anything we currently have…
I was just looking at that and thinking about the creativity in there. I was at that Crewe game, and just looked it up but that was a Monday as well. I said to my mate at the time we were the youngest there and that there were no kids - they were dire times but this feels a whole lot worse, at that time I felt we'd hit the bottom, I don't think we are there yet with this lot.
|