Another youth going?
#11
The rather large flaw in building a long term squad around our academy players. They get poached and families get greedy. Without Prem money we shall see more and more if this or those players will simply go to Villa or Wolves.
Reply
#12
(02-20-2022, 12:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The rather large flaw in building a long term squad around our academy players. They get poached and families get greedy. Without Prem money we shall see more and more if this or those players will simply go to Villa or Wolves.

More like Chelsea, Man City and Newcastle.
Reply
#13
(02-20-2022, 09:48 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: It's absolutely galling seeing our kids being poached and enjoying so much success elsewhere.

I know, like....look at......for example.......

All that happens is they drop into a huge pool of equally talented kids who are farmed out to who knows where on loan and then, if the are really good, sold for a million quid back down the divisions to top up the allready endless money pot.

It's a awful pathway.  But the money being offered sets the parents up very nicely.

Another part of the beautiful game.
Reply
#14
(02-20-2022, 12:25 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(02-20-2022, 09:48 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: It's absolutely galling seeing our kids being poached and enjoying so much success elsewhere.

I know, like....look at......for example.......

All that happens is they drop into a huge pool of equally talented kids who are farmed out to who knows where on loan and then, if the are really good, sold for a million quid back down the divisions to top up the allready endless money pot.

It's a awful pathway.  But the money being offered sets the parents up very nicely.

Another part of the beautiful game.

I found some archive footage of the parents of some of these kids. 


https://youtu.be/mBS0OWGUidc
Reply
#15
Derek Hardballs Wrote:The rather large flaw in building a long term squad around our academy players. They get poached and families get greedy. Without Prem money we shall see more and more if this or those players will simply go to Villa or Wolves.

We have no guarantee any other method will get us to the Prem either. It's fine for many on here to point out how we need to go up this season as if it is a straight choice of "long term plan" versus "Sod it, lets get promoted and see what happens". It is not a choice. No business anywhere remains successful without a clear plan. Albion need an identity to get back to being a well run club. Our last successful model was copied by some (successfully for a while in the case of Swansea). It doesn't start with the manager, it starts with appointing the guy that appoints the manager and having the entire club behind the method.
Reply
#16
The Brentford model of cast-offs from the youth structure and coach them in a B team looks increasingly attractive.
Reply
#17
(02-20-2022, 12:35 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:The rather large flaw in building a long term squad around our academy players. They get poached and families get greedy. Without Prem money we shall see more and more if this or those players will simply go to Villa or Wolves.

We have no guarantee any other method will get us to the Prem either. It's fine for many on here to point out how we need to go up this season as if it is a straight choice of "long term plan" versus "Sod it, lets get promoted and see what happens". It is not a choice. No business anywhere remains successful without a clear plan. Albion need an identity to get back to being a well run club. Our last successful model was copied by some (successfully for a while in the case of Swansea). It doesn't start with the manager, it starts with appointing the guy that appoints the manager and having the entire club behind the method.

No one has said that though. What they have said as a self sufficient club we need Prem money to support every area of the football department including the academy. Who is going to pay to keep our academy competitive? The owner? Hmm no evidence that’s going to happen. Long term plans with no investment in football flounder.
Reply
#18
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:The rather large flaw in building a long term squad around our academy players. They get poached and families get greedy. Without Prem money we shall see more and more if this or those players will simply go to Villa or Wolves.

We have no guarantee any other method will get us to the Prem either. It's fine for many on here to point out how we need to go up this season as if it is a straight choice of "long term plan" versus "Sod it, lets get promoted and see what happens". It is not a choice. No business anywhere remains successful without a clear plan. Albion need an identity to get back to being a well run club. Our last successful model was copied by some (successfully for a while in the case of Swansea). It doesn't start with the manager, it starts with appointing the guy that appoints the manager and having the entire club behind the method.

No one has said that though. What they have said as a self sufficient club we need Prem money to support every area of the football department including the academy. Who is going to pay to keep our academy competitive? The owner? Hmm
I still don't see it as a binary choice. For all our poaching issues, by offering a route to the 1st team squad we become more attractive as a career, than the top clubs (and than our wastrel neighbours). There will always be parents that prefer instant cash to the betterment of their child's career but that is a problem for most clubs. With almost as many subs as players, we should always include at least 2 in the matchday squad. I bet we have not done too badly over the last few years by selling some of the lads. Longer term, Gourlay should be looking at clubs like Coventry and anyone else that has been good at providing decent players. We should also be casting the net wider, beyond children, to those like Hughsey and Cyrille that came good relatively late. What I am rambling on about, in a nutshell, is we have wasted far greater income on rubbish pros and failed managers than it costs to have a decent network of coaches and scouts.
Reply
#19
(02-20-2022, 01:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:The rather large flaw in building a long term squad around our academy players. They get poached and families get greedy. Without Prem money we shall see more and more if this or those players will simply go to Villa or Wolves.

We have no guarantee any other method will get us to the Prem either. It's fine for many on here to point out how we need to go up this season as if it is a straight choice of "long term plan" versus "Sod it, lets get promoted and see what happens". It is not a choice. No business anywhere remains successful without a clear plan. Albion need an identity to get back to being a well run club. Our last successful model was copied by some (successfully for a while in the case of Swansea). It doesn't start with the manager, it starts with appointing the guy that appoints the manager and having the entire club behind the method.

No one has said that though. What they have said as a self sufficient club we need Prem money to support every area of the football department including the academy. Who is going to pay to keep our academy competitive? The owner? Hmm
I still don't see it as a binary choice. For all our poaching issues, by offering a route to the 1st team squad we become more attractive as a career, than the top clubs (and than our wastrel neighbours). There will always be parents that prefer instant cash to the betterment of their child's career but that is a problem for most clubs. With almost as many subs as players, we should always include at least 2 in the matchday squad. I bet we have not done too badly over the last few years by selling some of the lads. Longer term, Gourlay should be looking at clubs like Coventry and anyone else that has been good at providing decent players. We should also be casting the net wider, beyond children, to those like Hughsey and Cyrille that came good relatively late. What I am rambling on about, in a nutshell, is we have wasted far greater income on rubbish pros and failed managers than it costs to have a decent network of coaches and scouts.
My older brother always says, many of our greatest players, cost nothing, or comparatively small fees. We used to get promising lads from Scotland, that never seems to happen now. Joe Masi from the Express & Star, said yesterday, that Lutons best player was a 23 year old midfielder who they got from Motherwell or somewhere, he probably cost the equivalent of 2 months worth of Livermores wages.
Reply
#20
As a club, over many years we have done our best recruitment by buying cheap. As soon as we get the big cheque book out it has backfired. When was the last time we bought a player for over £5m who went on to be worth a lot more? Pereira and we still sold him at half his value. Hopefully Dyke bucks that trend.

We need a good blend of recruiting talented young players on the up, which needs good scouting, along with making sure that we don’t let our best Academy players fall through the net.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: