The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument...
(02-16-2022, 09:05 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-16-2022, 08:40 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Lurker, don't waste your breathe.

It's a sign of football fans weirdness that they really think the manager is the be all and end all, if its going wrong, sack him and get a new one. If then results don't improve, well that one is shit too.

Never players fault, never look for bigger issues, just sack and hire managers. Might get lucky at some point and one does a miracle job short term.
Well, three attacks on the majority of Albion fans - they're not worth wasting your breathe on, are weird and can't discern when a manager is "screwing up"  Without a shadow of doubt VI was the worst managager for 22 years by a country mile and there's been getting near to 25 of them choose from. It was apparent from the end of October last year that he was becoming intransigent,  misguided, predictable and players weren't buying into it. How can you blame the players, pick on one or two OK, but surely a managers job is to control them, lead them and mold them into a promotion winning side and he is the be all and end all.

I won't be blaming Bruce if things go tits up - the job is too difficult now

Bold #1 - AFI, Pardew, come on mate... And that's just 2 theres a few more that are far more incompetent!

Bold #2 - They have downed tools many time over a number of years, for a number of managers.

Bold #3 - No chance. The squad is fundamentally flawed, both in terms of ability and personality. I wont doubt their character as they all seem like "decent" people, but they lack real drive and balls.

P.s. I dont think anybody will blame Brucey to be honest. Because there are those who think Val is the devil, and the rest of us who know it isnt the managers fault full stop. It wont stop some of us being dismayed at another sort term, boring, predictable appointment, which will lead to boring, predictable, old fashioned football.
This is where your argument falls over. You have listed two extreme and almost non-existent views.

No-one thinks he's the devil. A lot do think he's a poor manager, based on performance and results, mainly down to inflexibility.
No-one can claim it's the manager's fault full stop. Pretty much everyone accepts that, the board, owners, recruitment and players all have to share responsibility.

None of this means that Val deserved to stay, he was in the hot seat and got his ass burned due to poor signings, his inflexible and rigid approach and, most importantly, a rapidly decreasing points haul.

All the other issues remain, but at least with a manager of Bruce's experience, we have a slightly better chance of overcoming them.

The one element that can't be blamed is the fans.
Reply
(02-16-2022, 10:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: This is where your argument falls over. You have listed two extreme and almost non-existent views.

No-one thinks he's the devil. A lot do think he's a poor manager, based on performance and results, mainly down to inflexibility.
No-one can claim it's the manager's fault full stop. Pretty much everyone accepts that, the board, owners, recruitment and players all have to share responsibility.

None of this means that Val deserved to stay, he was in the hot seat and got his ass burned due to poor signings, his inflexible and rigid approach and, most importantly, a rapidly decreasing points haul.

All the other issues remain, but at least with a manager of Bruce's experience, we have a slightly better chance of overcoming them.

The one element that can't be blamed is the fans.

I was being some what facetious, but your next sentence is what I mean. There are some that blame all the ills of this season on Val. The majority of Valxiteers were constantly peddling the second line of your reply, even when we were battering teams and just not converting. With the experienced Bruce, we have changed the hated shape, passed shorter, and got worse (IMO). That's all I know. Now, as I have said, I hope he find a nice short term bodge to appease some, and allow us all to enjoy winning together as a fan base Smile   

Oh I absolutely can, and do lay some blame at the fans door. They are the reason I stopped going after 20odd years as a STH, and their petulance and entitled attitude is what continues to keep me away. As I have stated, if that's the atmosphere/culture the majority want/will accept on a matchday, that's fine, I will just continue to stay away as I can "enjoy" watching my teams via other platforms. .
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(02-16-2022, 10:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-16-2022, 10:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: This is where your argument falls over. You have listed two extreme and almost non-existent views.

No-one thinks he's the devil. A lot do think he's a poor manager, based on performance and results, mainly down to inflexibility.
No-one can claim it's the manager's fault full stop. Pretty much everyone accepts that, the board, owners, recruitment and players all have to share responsibility.

None of this means that Val deserved to stay, he was in the hot seat and got his ass burned due to poor signings, his inflexible and rigid approach and, most importantly, a rapidly decreasing points haul.

All the other issues remain, but at least with a manager of Bruce's experience, we have a slightly better chance of overcoming them.

The one element that can't be blamed is the fans.

I was being some what facetious, but your next sentence is what I mean. There are some that blame all the ills of this season on Val. The majority of Valxiteers were constantly peddling the second line of your reply, even when we were battering teams and just not converting. With the experienced Bruce, we have changed the hated shape, passed shorter, and got worse (IMO). That's all I know. Now, as I have said, I hope he find a nice short term bodge to appease some, and allow us all to enjoy winning together as a fan base Smile   

Oh I absolutely can, and do lay some blame at the fans door. They are the reason I stopped going after 20odd years as a STH, and their petulance and entitled attitude is what continues to keep me away. As I have stated, if that's the atmosphere/culture the majority want/will accept on a matchday, that's fine, I will just continue to stay away as I can "enjoy" watching my teams via other platforms. .
So you stay at home and blame those that spend thousands, give up their time, holidays etc. to travel the country, in all weathers?
Very noble.
Reply
Every game saw the same same shape, same tactics, like for like subs, subs on sixty and so predictable it was easy for the oppostion to prepare - apparent at the end of August (Peterborough Away) . The fans were getting increasingly frustrated watching the team fail and mega frustrated at VIs intransigence and lack of flexibility, the decline was obvious.

VI had conrol over bringing players in and screwed up
Playing 3 halfbacks instead of two and having a better more creative extra midfielder was daft. The football was guileless and a VI version of hoofball
Putting it down to the players not doing their best is unfair and not true until they lost the plot and VI had to go

It was clearly VI's fault and a few people decided in their infinite wisdom to back him and cant admit they were wrong. How can you have watched that rubbish and not believe what was in front of your eyes.
Reply
(02-16-2022, 10:42 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: So you stay at home and blame those that spend thousands, give up their time, holidays etc. to travel the country, in all weathers?
Very noble.

Yes I do... I have been there and done that so don't bother with the high and mighty, "super fan" lark. for best part of a decade I travelled from/to York & Manchester to watch the team. My opinion didn't hold more weigh then, and it sure as hell doesn't hold less now. 

But yes, I find a substantial proportion of "football fans" moronic, but i find that with society in general as I am a miserable bugger these days.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(02-16-2022, 11:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-16-2022, 10:42 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: So you stay at home and blame those that spend thousands, give up their time, holidays etc. to travel the country, in all weathers?
Very noble.

Yes I do... I have been there and done that so don't bother with the high and mighty, "super fan" lark. for best part of a decade I travelled from/to York & Manchester to watch the team. My opinion didn't hold more weigh then, and it sure as hell doesn't hold less now. 

But yes, I find a substantial proportion of "football fans" moronic, but i find that with society in general as I am a miserable bugger these days.

No high and mighty from me, you don't need to go to games to form a valid opinion of the game, I've never alluded to that, you get just as good a view, if not better on the telly.

What I take exception to is your sweeping generalisation of football fans when you don't go. You can't judge that from the telly I'm afraid.

My cousin is 66 and rarely misses a game with her husband and their 2 grown up daughters and grand-kids, are they moronic?

My mate is in a wheelchair but doesn't let it stop him travelling hundreds of miles to follow his passion. His he moronic?

Football crowds are made up of all sorts of different people, living different lives, so, the only thing moronic is your judgement of them made from your armchair.
Reply
(02-16-2022, 10:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-16-2022, 10:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: This is where your argument falls over. You have listed two extreme and almost non-existent views.

No-one thinks he's the devil. A lot do think he's a poor manager, based on performance and results, mainly down to inflexibility.
No-one can claim it's the manager's fault full stop. Pretty much everyone accepts that, the board, owners, recruitment and players all have to share responsibility.

None of this means that Val deserved to stay, he was in the hot seat and got his ass burned due to poor signings, his inflexible and rigid approach and, most importantly, a rapidly decreasing points haul.

All the other issues remain, but at least with a manager of Bruce's experience, we have a slightly better chance of overcoming them.

The one element that can't be blamed is the fans.

I was being some what facetious, but your next sentence is what I mean. There are some that blame all the ills of this season on Val. The majority of Valxiteers were constantly peddling the second line of your reply, even when we were battering teams and just not converting. With the experienced Bruce, we have changed the hated shape, passed shorter, and got worse (IMO). That's all I know. Now, as I have said, I hope he find a nice short term bodge to appease some, and allow us all to enjoy winning together as a fan base Smile   

Oh I absolutely can, and do lay some blame at the fans door. They are the reason I stopped going after 20odd years as a STH, and their petulance and entitled attitude is what continues to keep me away. As I have stated, if that's the atmosphere/culture the majority want/will accept on a matchday, that's fine, I will just continue to stay away as I can "enjoy" watching my teams via other platforms. .

Bob - I 100% agree with what you say in this comment. 

Lurker - I understand your frustration about an appointment to be given faith and stick with him but for me we threw that away with Bilic - for all his faults. I cannot agree about VI. Forget about wearing his clothes- he had borrowed the Emperors entire wardrobe. 
I think you have gone way too early with Bruce. He is not a long term fit but I think we will be in with a chance of the PO’s now and if we don’t nothing is lost because Ismael had us en-route to lower mid table IMO.
Reply
(02-14-2022, 10:08 PM)Deeleys Wrote: I think Bruce will improve is and sneak into the play offs. Then it’s a lottery. We’ve been on the slide for the last 5 years, diluting the team with mediocre players. If you going to buy cheap you need to make sure you have someone like Ashworth to get you something for nothing.

We certainly looked better for 38 mins at Sheff U until Jake gave the game away. 

The other night was disappointing and saw no difference really to how we've been playing under Val. 

He has to go 5-4-1 or 4-5-1 and play two out and out wingers whether that be Diang/Phillips or Fellows.  

I don't see where Dumb and Dumber fit into this side at all in that formation and neither did Allardyce who bombed them straight away. 

This saturday I would go; 

                  Sam 

       Ajayi    Barts   Clarke
Furlong                         Townsend

Phillips   Mowatt   TGH   Diangana
(Fellows)
                  Carroll

With Furlong and Townsend pushing on we should be able to swamp the midfield and get more bodies in the box.
Reply
A very interesting thred, heres my take.

Val is a manager with a formula based on statistics. It is a more than valid way to excell in sport, look at Clive Woodward, Dave Brailsford, Eoin Morgan who have been sucessful by basing descisions on the available data and Val was one of the few who used it to such a great extent.

He inherited a ragbag group of comfortable pros and asked them to do something that was very hard, required fitness and stamina that was way out of their comfort zone.

We started the season like a train and were a fantastic watch. then along came Derby and Millwall who countered our style by just lumping the ball giving us no opportunity to press. Except they didnt, we still did more than enough to win.

At this point it seems that he players started to have more of a say in the style of play and we started playing a more blended style. This was perhaps Vals biggest mistake, it let the players off and once they started to dictate how things were to go that really was the beginning of the end.

We still continued to grind out results but never returned to what we once were.

All the ime Val acted as head coach, manager, director of football and club spokesman, The only voice coming from the club was him, a very lonly position I would think.

The moment the players sensed dissent from the fans they knew they had won, down tools for a bit, get him gone and no more being asked to run so hard.

Vals last game at Millwall, the week before after the Preston game he said his minjd was clear and he knew what he needed to do and for 20 mins we returned to the high press val ball but 20 minutes was all the players gave him before they just shrugged their shoulders and got him the sack

So maybe, just maybe Vals downfall was his flexibility?

I am sad that it didnt work but more worried that the club put in place a 4 year plan and allowed it to go tits up in 6 months, Val needed support back in september and never got it
Reply
(02-14-2022, 10:07 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: It's a confidence issue. We need a win quickly.

You could be right BDC.  

Let's face it confidence has gradually drained away.  

We just never really seem to get the rub of the green but as they you create your own 'luck'.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)