Sawyers and Edwards
#1
I said back in August that releasing them was a mistake and I stand by it. Both would improve us at the moment.

Sawyers for all his faults was the only midfielder on the books who could actually pass a football. He was poor at PL level without doubt but has been consistently good as a Championship player for years. The stick he got from our rabble was disproportionate to his shortcomings as a player and often IMO had darker intent (the shit about him chewing gum for example). People said he wouldn’t fit Val’s style but we abandoned that fast paced football after about five games when it became clear the players weren’t fit enough to play it. Even when we did win the ball we didn’t have a clue what to do with it, Sawyers was one of the few players we had who could actually look up and pass.

As for Edwards, I’ll admit I haven’t been paying attention to his time at Ipswich, but based on his time with us I can’t see how he could offer any less than what we currently have. At least he was prepared to try and beat a player and get forward.
Reply
#2
Sawyers yes. Edwards no.
Reply
#3
Completely agree
Reply
#4
Edwards isn’t getting in the Ipswich team
Reply
#5
As I said, I’ve not been following Edwards closely, but I can’t see how he’d offer less than the likes of Reach.
Reply
#6
I would keep both because of the lack of alternative options. Usually if players are off form you drop them, we hardly have a squad big enough to drop players
Reply
#7
Edwards can improve.

Reach can't
Reply
#8
I’d have kept HRK and Sawyers. They’d both improve us.

Johnstone
Furlong O’Shea Bartley Townsend
Phillips Sawyers Mowatt Diangana
Carroll HRK
Reply
#9
Edwards hasn’t achieved anything at Ipswich in a side which has had a poor season. I don’t recall anyone saying at the time that it was a mistake moving Sawyers on.
Reply
#10
Not allowed to say HRK should have been kept on here, trust me, really upsets people, even though its true.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: