Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(02-13-2022, 11:59 AM)standitupbackstick Wrote: Our forays into the Premiershit are purely for financial purposes. On that basis, going up via the playoffs should be our aim as that route is the most lucrative I think?
Exactly right.
I'm interested in this clear out theory, who is getting dumped. Very few contracts are up at the end of this season. Who are we getting in to replace any leavers. Assuming our budget will be next to nothing.
As for challenging next season, who ever comes down will be more difficult to beat then the dross in the championship today.
We must have the PL money, how can we survive with £50million less then we get now. Without it wim doomed.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
TETLEY74 Wrote:MrFizz Wrote:WorcsWBA Wrote:Following on from "we're slipping out of play-off contention and it's vital that we get promoted this season, so Val has to go", it now seems to be moving towards "we're not good enough to go up anyway, so there's no point in getting into the play-offs - best to build for next season and change the squad".
Largely because of the fans, Ismael was hounded out 7 months into a 4 year rebuilding project because instant success this season was regarded as non-negotiable, but now that suddenly doesn't matter anymore and we can just write this season off?
Many people were regarding Ismael as the problem when he was here and his tactics were holding the players back, but now he's gone some of those people have switched to saying it's the players who aren't good enough and we need a big clear-out.
Double standards and/or revisionism at play here?
Its an interesting point Worcs. I was late to the 'Val out' party. I was still backing him in the pub before the Preston game. By full-time it was clear the players had lost faith/given up and he needed to go. Millwall reinforced that.
Now we have a more flexible, experienced man in charge we are hoping for a bounce, a late run into the play-offs and then who knows.
However, the choice is this: stay down, give Bruce a Summer to get rid of some, get some in and have a crack at it, or go up, keep what we have, spend money on additions to try and keep us up, come back down and be right back where we are now.
I've got more faith in Bruce to build a squad with decent enough players to get us up, and with a few additions, give us a fair chance of staying up. If that takes a year and a half, so be it.
This is sort of where i am at moment, unfortunately those that wanted Val gone will no doubt be screaming abuse and bile at Bruce in the next few games if we dont win them all and go up ,he will then be hounded out and the next man moves then rinse and repeat!
Honestly don't know what some of our fans want anymore some become more deluded and seal like with every passing day.
Lets just get behind the manager and team as one unified voice starting tomorrow for the remainder of the season and see where we are at seasons end COYB . This is where I am. I don't blame Val, I blame whoever appointed him and then got spooked. Whether or not he was the right appointment is the moot point, the fact is we will never know. By going back to the experienced manager model, we are just reverting to type, as we have done throughout these recent years of decline. I would argue, it doesn't serve us well. Just my onions and I'll be backing Bruce all the way regardless of this.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
02-13-2022, 07:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-13-2022, 07:29 PM by MassDebater.)
(02-13-2022, 10:36 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Following on from "we're slipping out of play-off contention and it's vital that we get promoted this season, so Val has to go", it now seems to be moving towards "we're not good enough to go up anyway, so there's no point in getting into the play-offs - best to build for next season and change the squad".
Largely because of the fans, Ismael was hounded out 7 months into a 4 year rebuilding project because instant success this season was regarded as non-negotiable, but now that suddenly doesn't matter anymore and we can just write this season off?
Many people were regarding Ismael as the problem when he was here and his tactics were holding the players back, but now he's gone some of those people have switched to saying it's the players who aren't good enough and we need a big clear-out.
Double standards and/or revisionism at play here?
Thing is, which you are completely overlooking, we are where we are because of Six and his shyteball. It's going to take anyone, especially with only free agents to call upon a good while to get the players feeling and playing confidently again. yes the squad is weaker, again mainly down to who Six bought in.
This is likely why some are saying Bruce gets a free hit, I'm not, but I realise he has a heck of a lot of slack to take up before things are his fault. Ergo if he doesn't achieve play offs, then it's to be expected, if he does then great... If he gets to the PO final then that would be a stunning turnaround, if he wins it I'd call it a miracle.
Six has really fucked us up, and yes he may be the final nail in a long line of coffins, some would say Slav, but definitely BFS was another expensive experiment that we could not afford... The Sixperiment though has completely fecked us up this season, which was likely our best promotion prospect for the next few years.
Bruce has one hell of a job to do, but if he fails this next few months then it really will be hard to blame him. Had Six gone in early December and then Bruce came in and things stayed as bad then yes Bruce would deserve some blame, as it is, the guy has got to work with what we've already got.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(02-13-2022, 11:09 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (02-13-2022, 11:04 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: I certainly didn't see much "building" from Ismael. I get the feeling we will look back at his time in charge as a bit of a disaster.
Not sure how people think Bruce will be able to build if we stay down. I can just see cost cutting and a further reduction in quality.
In terms of finances theres no actual difference, as apparently we have budgeted to spread the parachute payments over 3yrs. Whether thats true or not i don't know.
As we only stayed up for one season last time we only get 2 years of parachute payments this time.
Posts: 3,594
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-13-2022, 09:30 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (02-13-2022, 11:09 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (02-13-2022, 11:04 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: I certainly didn't see much "building" from Ismael. I get the feeling we will look back at his time in charge as a bit of a disaster.
Not sure how people think Bruce will be able to build if we stay down. I can just see cost cutting and a further reduction in quality.
In terms of finances theres no actual difference, as apparently we have budgeted to spread the parachute payments over 3yrs. Whether thats true or not i don't know.
As we only stayed up for one season last time we only get 2 years of parachute payments this time.
I presume Fizz means we are spreading those two year payments over three years in bookkeeping terms.
Posts: 8,001
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
I always thought that top 6 was nailed on, now I find it highly unlikely. We just went a few too many games with Val and allowed draws to turn to defeats. We now, probably, have to average over 2 points a game to reel in enough of the clubs above us, but they are all more consistent than we are, so fear it's slipped away.
That being said, in Bruce, we have a manager more than capable of putting pressure on some of the young uns above him, so not completely given up. The "run" needs to start soon though, preferably tonight. If we are there or thereabouts when Dike gets fit, maybe we will find the impetus to get us over the line, just not sure where the goals come from in the meantime.
With regards Bruce, however, I disagree that he can only be a short term appointment, for me, he is the perfect long-term option that we have been craving and here's why.
He knows the Championship better than any of his competitors and has an excellent track record
If we do go up, we then have a manager with bags of Prem experience and success. We would still be favourites for relegation, however, based purely on budget, so, if we did come back down, we go back to point 1.
He is past the point where he will attract interest from bigger clubs or International opportunities.
He's still got plenty of years in the tank at 13 years Roy's junior.
His style is fluid and transferable and suits most players, so we'd have a wider range to look at within our budget.
I know most think that a long term project has to involve a younger more dynamic manager, but I disagree. If we did that and they were successful, they'd be picked off anyway. With Bruce we have our only real chance of longevity.
For that reason, barring disaster in the next 16 games, I'd be looking to keep him on next year, whichever league we are in.
|