Manager latest
#91
(03-20-2019, 11:05 AM)Sliced Wrote: Absolutely ridiculous

(03-20-2019, 10:18 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Matt Wilson
The feeling is it will be far easier to appoint the right permanent head coach in summer when #wba know what division they're in and more managers are available (Wagner/Neil etc.) Only time will tell if it's right call #wba

Wonderful, a "let's just see what happens" decision when we should be doing everything we can to ensure that the division we're in after the summer is the Premier League.
It does seem odd. The timing of the sacking of Moore, you'd have thought there would have been a plan in place.
Reply
#92
(03-20-2019, 10:50 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(03-20-2019, 10:37 AM)Brunty Wrote: I actually think this makes sense and is a logical decision.

I think the sacking of Mooro was more to do with Jones influence on the team and tactics. I think we all agree that we were going to struggle to go up carrying on like that and then the bloke who had us playing in that way was going to bugger off in the Summer anyway. Shan has got us back to basics and delivered two good results. I don't think we want to rock the boat too much like we did with Pardew.


To say the appointment of Pardew, rocked the boat's, a bit like saying the Titanic had a slight collision with an iceberg.

I just like asking questions and arguing against the status quo. With this in mind fans can’t have it both ways, in the Summer DM’s appointment and Jones was greeeted as great decisions by the majority of fans. Decisions recently seem muddled but this all stems from the clamour by fans and weakness of the club to appoint a rookie manager when promotion at the first attempt seems paramount. 

If we get promotion, if Shan is in charge etc will be seen as success for Jenkins if we don’t then you do have up question the decision making of the owners and CEO. All to play for at the moment though.
Reply
#93
(03-20-2019, 11:17 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-20-2019, 11:09 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(03-20-2019, 11:05 AM)Sliced Wrote: Absolutely ridiculous

(03-20-2019, 10:18 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Matt Wilson
The feeling is it will be far easier to appoint the right permanent head coach in summer when #wba know what division they're in and more managers are available (Wagner/Neil etc.) Only time will tell if it's right call #wba

Wonderful, a "let's just see what happens" decision when we should be doing everything we can to ensure that the division we're in after the summer is the Premier League.

As I said in my post - not sure there is anybody available that will make that any more likely in such a sort space of time?

We probably should've checked this before getting rid of Darren Moore with 10 games to go. 

Shan has won two games, home to Swansea and away to Brentford. He may turn out to be an unbelievable manager but two games means absolutely nothing, it certainly in the grand scheme of things says next to nothing about his abilities. This is undoubtedly our biggest appointment in recent history as the landscape changes completely for us next season if we fail to go up, and we're going with (or if what you've said is correct, we're stuck with) someone who has zero managerial experience.

People are saying Moore should never have been appointed despite the fact that without him last season we would've been about 13 points clear at the bottom of the league. This season he's taken us to 4th. Some might argue that he couldn't have turned things around, but he already did once earlier in the season.

No disrespect to Jimmy Shan, but getting rid of a manager who's got you into the top 4 10 games before the end of the season, with a side note of him not being experienced enough to turn it around, and then replacing him with someone even less experienced is absolute madness. Shocking from the club, genuinely shocking.

Correct.
Reply
#94
We had an experienced manager in Pardew who did an awful job and the man with no experience in management Darren Moore would have kept us up if the sacking happened earlier.

We could easily appoint someone who comes in and upsets the applecart.

I understand the logic of keeping Shan in charge for now. The players seem happy, we've got some good results, we're playing a style that suits the team, he's shown good in game management...we could easily destroy all that by bringing someone in.
Reply
#95
(03-20-2019, 11:17 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-20-2019, 11:09 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(03-20-2019, 11:05 AM)Sliced Wrote: Absolutely ridiculous

(03-20-2019, 10:18 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Matt Wilson
The feeling is it will be far easier to appoint the right permanent head coach in summer when #wba know what division they're in and more managers are available (Wagner/Neil etc.) Only time will tell if it's right call #wba

Wonderful, a "let's just see what happens" decision when we should be doing everything we can to ensure that the division we're in after the summer is the Premier League.

As I said in my post - not sure there is anybody available that will make that any more likely in such a sort space of time?

We probably should've checked this before getting rid of Darren Moore with 10 games to go. 

Shan has won two games, home to Swansea and away to Brentford. He may turn out to be an unbelievable manager but two games means absolutely nothing, it certainly in the grand scheme of things says next to nothing about his abilities. This is undoubtedly our biggest appointment in recent history as the landscape changes completely for us next season if we fail to go up, and we're going with (or if what you've said is correct, we're stuck with) someone who has zero managerial experience.

People are saying Moore should never have been appointed despite the fact that without him last season we would've been about 13 points clear at the bottom of the league. This season he's taken us to 4th. Some might argue that he couldn't have turned things around, but he already did once earlier in the season.

No disrespect to Jimmy Shan, but getting rid of a manager who's got you into the top 4 10 games before the end of the season, with a side note of him not being experienced enough to turn it around, and then replacing him with someone even less experienced is absolute madness. Shocking from the club, genuinely shocking.
Totally agree fella.

I'd love to be positive about the football club that I love, but it's difficult when there seems to be no real strategy at a senior level. It feels like we're making it up as we go along. Has the recent meeting between Lai & Jenkins led to a change in direction? I'm genuinely concerned about the long term future if we don't manage to somehow wing promotion this year. The mid-table Championship team comment from Peace may eventually become the extent of our ambitions.
Reply
#96
Can’t see how this appointment would be shocking ,6 points from 2games and the players obviously new what they were doing. In Darren’s last 3 games the players had not got a clue they were all over the place the because of the tactics and we were in free fall. Something had to be done Jones’s influence and his tactics were apparent and they weren’t working and Darren did not do nothing to stop the downfall,wether Darren went because he refused to get rid of Jones is for other people to debate but you could see that after the 3 performances against Leeds,Sheffield Utd and Ipswich things needed to change.I was Darren’s biggest fan and thought the sacking was a bit harsh but in hindsight if it’s true and Darren would not get rid of Jones then for me they both had to go.
Reply
#97
Inexperienced owner
Inexperienced chief exec
Inexperienced manager
Reply
#98
I definitely understand why people are a bit disgruntled but realistically who is there to bring in that will definitely do better than Shan right at this moment?

Neil is a no go as Preston may get up themselves.

Wagner is gardening and has said not now.

Jokanovic seems good but if he's not prepared to come in and do what it takes to get us over the line then the disruption of yet another new style of play isn't exactly going to end well is it?

Moyes if we appoint him then we're stuck with him which I don't think many of the fans are really interested in.

Yes - they could've have "thought about it before sacking Moore" but I think they were thinking more along the lines of....we're losing, the players are making noises (again), the experts in the stands are moaning if we don't change it now we could end up out of the play offs.

In terms of winning the play offs in theory we could get Frank Skinner and Tai Schoenberg in and still end up winning them if the players are up for it as they are such a lottery.
Reply
#99
(03-20-2019, 11:45 AM)MGalea Wrote: I definitely understand why people are a bit disgruntled but realistically who is there to bring in that will definitely do better than Shan right at this moment?

Neil is a no go as Preston may get up themselves.

Wagner is gardening and has said not now.

Jokanovic seems good but if he's not prepared to come in and do what it takes to get us over the line then the disruption of yet another new style of play isn't exactly going to end well is it?

Moyes if we appoint him then we're stuck with him which I don't think many of the fans are really interested in.

Yes - they could've have "thought about it before sacking Moore" but I think they were thinking more along the lines of....we're losing, the players are making noises (again), the experts in the stands are moaning if we don't change it now we could end up out of the play offs.

In terms of winning the play offs in theory we could get Frank Skinner and Tai Schoenberg in and still end up winning them if the players are up for it as they are such a lottery.

+1

The club is in a lose lose scenario, which they’ve admittedly brought upon themselves.
In the form of his life.
Reply
I’ve not read all the thread, so I don’t know if the point’s already been made, but it’s becoming increasingly obvious to me that players nowadays, the ones on comparatively big money anyway, have so much power that they demand everything to be just as they like it or they more or less down tools. 

Did I see a post somewhere that Brunt(?) had given an interview which suggested or hinted the players were happy or at least relieved that under your caretaker manager they’re playing in a style they’re more suited to? Did the players instigate the sackings? In which case, it’s also going to be the case that the players need to be kept happy, at least for the remainder of the season. Appointing a new manager could rock the boat if the players don’t take to him. 

If Shan is keeping things ticking over with the backing of the players, then appointing a permanent manager or even a temporary outsider now could prove quite risky, particularly when, as ever, there’ll probably be better options available in the summer, albeit there’ll also be more competition for their services.

Proper stick or twist situation.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: