Our Top 2 Squad
#61
Will 45 points be enough to stay up?
Reply
#62
(02-10-2022, 12:24 PM)SophLad Wrote: Will 45 points be enough to stay up?

Probably just about. Barnsley have been gone for ages and the next four up are all very terrible - can't see the posh getting another 25 points, for example.

So yeah, we should be just about OK.
Reply
#63
(02-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:52 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.

So when we get results it's because the squad is good. When we don't get results it's because the manager is crap.

OK

No, I think our relatively good squad compared to those around us bar Fulham will do better under Bruce than Val. However I recognise it may take more than one game and less than a handful of training sessions for him to turn around a team bereft of confidence and asked to play in a very one dimensional and ineffective way for months. 

Last season you were arguing that the manager can mitigate for the lack of quality in a team, now you’re arguing that it’s only the squad that determines where we will finish. Val had a squad far better than the  results and performances the team produced. 

Even if you are proven right by the end of the season and we languish outside the play-off places, that will surely seem like a very hollow victory?

No, I'm not, and I don't know why you keep misrepresenting my position, just like yesterday it was said that I was criticising Steve Bruce when I haven't criticised him even once. I have never ever said that it's only the squad that determines where we finish, not once, and I don't believe that.

However, squad quality (obviously) plays a part. I think right now that we have one of the best managers in the Championship. Unfortunately the squad is unbalanced, thin, and a lot weaker than you think it is.

I've also not said that Val should have stayed, I literally said he should go.

With regards to being "proven right", neither of us can be proven definitively right or wrong about the players quality because it's both the players quality and the manager that contributes to whether we win games or not.
Reply
#64
(02-10-2022, 01:51 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:52 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.

So when we get results it's because the squad is good. When we don't get results it's because the manager is crap.

OK

No, I think our relatively good squad compared to those around us bar Fulham will do better under Bruce than Val. However I recognise it may take more than one game and less than a handful of training sessions for him to turn around a team bereft of confidence and asked to play in a very one dimensional and ineffective way for months. 

Last season you were arguing that the manager can mitigate for the lack of quality in a team, now you’re arguing that it’s only the squad that determines where we will finish. Val had a squad far better than the  results and performances the team produced. 

Even if you are proven right by the end of the season and we languish outside the play-off places, that will surely seem like a very hollow victory?

No, I'm not, and I don't know why you keep misrepresenting my position, just like yesterday it was said that I was criticising Steve Bruce when I haven't criticised him even once. I have never ever said that it's only the squad that determines where we finish, not once, and I don't believe that.

However, squad quality (obviously) plays a part. I think right now that we have one of the best managers in the Championship. Unfortunately the squad is unbalanced, thin, and a lot weaker than you think it is.

I've also not said that Val should have stayed, I literally said he should go.

With regards to being "proven right", neither of us can be proven definitively right or wrong about the players quality because it's both the players quality and the manager that contributes to whether we win games or not.

When I used the argument that no matter what Bilic did, it was akin to moving the deckchairs around the Titanic, you did argue it wasn’t the case and that a decent manager would be able ti mitigate for the squads weaknesses or have I got that wrong? Apologies if I have.  That squad was never good enough to stay up and yet both Bilic and Allardyce got way ott criticism last season. 

However thanks mainly due to Covid this seasons squad is no worse than any other decent squad in the division bar Fulham. The reason the rest of the league down to is it Blackpool in 14th? Can have a shout currently at getting into the play-offs is testament to the paucity of quality in all the clubs squads more so than the quality. 

It’s not always the case that a manager can succeed if the players aren’t good enough like last year but I see little evidence that our squad isn’t capable of promotion given the very poor standard in the league this season. 

My point was yesterday that some posters were seemingly eager to prove their point either about the old and new manager or squad. Way too early to judge either imo in this league in this specific Covid ravaged season.
Reply
#65
(02-10-2022, 02:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 01:51 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:52 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.

So when we get results it's because the squad is good. When we don't get results it's because the manager is crap.

OK

No, I think our relatively good squad compared to those around us bar Fulham will do better under Bruce than Val. However I recognise it may take more than one game and less than a handful of training sessions for him to turn around a team bereft of confidence and asked to play in a very one dimensional and ineffective way for months. 

Last season you were arguing that the manager can mitigate for the lack of quality in a team, now you’re arguing that it’s only the squad that determines where we will finish. Val had a squad far better than the  results and performances the team produced. 

Even if you are proven right by the end of the season and we languish outside the play-off places, that will surely seem like a very hollow victory?

No, I'm not, and I don't know why you keep misrepresenting my position, just like yesterday it was said that I was criticising Steve Bruce when I haven't criticised him even once. I have never ever said that it's only the squad that determines where we finish, not once, and I don't believe that.

However, squad quality (obviously) plays a part. I think right now that we have one of the best managers in the Championship. Unfortunately the squad is unbalanced, thin, and a lot weaker than you think it is.

I've also not said that Val should have stayed, I literally said he should go.

With regards to being "proven right", neither of us can be proven definitively right or wrong about the players quality because it's both the players quality and the manager that contributes to whether we win games or not.

When I used the argument that no matter what Bilic did, it was akin to moving the deckchairs around the Titanic, you did argue it wasn’t the case and that a decent manager would be able ti mitigate for the squads weaknesses or have I got that wrong? Apologies if I have.  That squad was never good enough to stay up and yet both Bilic and Allardyce got way ott criticism last season. 

However thanks mainly due to Covid this seasons squad is no worse than any other decent squad in the division bar Fulham. The reason the rest of the league down to is it Blackpool in 14th? Can have a shout currently at getting into the play-offs is testament to the paucity of quality in all the clubs squads more so than the quality. 

It’s not always the case that a manager can succeed if the players aren’t good enough like last year but I see little evidence that our squad isn’t capable of promotion given the very poor standard in the league this season. 

My point was yesterday that some posters were seemingly eager to prove their point either about the old and new manager or squad. Way too early to judge either imo in this league in this specific Covid ravaged season.

You have a good memory because at the start of last season I underestimated the quality of the Prem and thought there may have been a chance we could stay up. However, for the vast majority of last season I thought it was pretty clear that we weren't good enough. I actually though Allardyce did an ok job of making us semi-competitive briefly after the transfer window, but I'll happily admit I was wrong about the quality of our team in relation to the rest of the Prem.

My comments on the squad strength are because of the sheer disappointment that we find ourselves in this position, whereby we were miles out of our depth last season and yet we've gotten worse in terms of personnel this season.

It's not a comment on Val or anything else, I just genuinely don't know in what area you think we are strong. Especially as you accept that last season we were nowhere near Prem standard and we've gotten worse, but apparently should be waltzing into the playoffs no problem; even though a) the teams that got promoted last year are not cut adrift at the bottom of the Prem as we were and b) ourselves and Sheff U are struggling to make the playoffs. This suggests that the gap between the Prem and Champ isn't as monumental as it's made out and actually, we're just not that good.

It's been done to death so it's probably best to leave it here. Our squad is good enough to get into the playoffs, and there are weaker squads above us, I accept that. However, the manager is going to have his work cut out to pull it off and will deserve a lot of credit if he does IMO
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: