Our Top 2 Squad
#51
SW4's post, even half pissed and full of oysters (Irish or English?) is a fairly accurate critique in my opinion. Moreover the wage bill we have is, I believe, a big problem. The simple fact is a lot of the players are not performing to the level they should be given the money they're on. I've never been resigned to being in the Championship (if we're lucky) but until we clear out a lot of this squad and replace it with younger (probably) hungrier (definitely) and mentally stronger players we can only decline even further.

Going up always meant a significant increase in spending power, but as has been pointed out ad infinitum on this bored, we seem only to excel in spending unbelievably unwisely, so that we get saddled with some players who are not worth what we've paid and effectively then block us from signing other more worthwhile acquisitions. Ashworth was a one-off, but until we get someone even half as good as him again (I doubt Gourlay is in his hemisphere let alone league) wim doomed - or should I say Semi-doomed.
Reply
#52
(02-09-2022, 09:40 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: The Ismael project has been a disaster for Albion. Below the likes of Luton and Huddersfield in the league whose whole squads cost less than we paid for Karlan Grant. Bruce has a huge job on his hands.

He knew this needed a massive rebulid. This was years in the making & we were stupid to think otherwise. Val was harshly sacked and i know you hated him but he not to blame
Reply
#53
Val has to be held, at least partly responsible, for any signings made on his watch. Clarke has been solid, Mowatt started well then faded and is now pretty useless and the rest were generally awful. The limitations with the budget are all on the club, however.
Val also, publicly, sanctioned the sale of Pereira, which the club then ballsed up in terms of the deal. At no point did Val ever stress any importance, however, of replacing him. He stated on numerous occasions that he was happy with the squad, as were most of us during those heady first few games. It was also clear that he was happy to wait for Dike
The problems started when the original system hit the skids and he started to tweak. It's at that point that it all got a bit confused and the frailties of both manager and squad were exposed.

The upshot for me is:

Val is a poor, one-dimentional manager, who made bad choices both in the transfer window and on the pitch.

Everyone above him, from recruitment to deal negotiators also had an absolute mare of a summer.

We have a very poor squad, both old and new, which is far worse on grass than it appears on paper

Good look Brucie.
Reply
#54
I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.
Reply
#55
(02-10-2022, 09:47 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: SW4's post, even half pissed and full of oysters (Irish or English?) is a fairly accurate critique in my opinion. Moreover the wage bill we have is, I believe, a  big problem. The simple fact is a lot of the players are not performing to the level they should be given the money they're on.  I've never been resigned to being in the Championship (if we're lucky) but until we clear out a lot of this squad and replace it with younger (probably) hungrier (definitely) and mentally stronger players we can only decline even further.

Going up always meant a significant increase in spending power, but as has been pointed out ad infinitum on this bored, we seem only to excel in spending unbelievably unwisely, so that we get saddled with some players who are not worth what we've paid and effectively then block us from signing other more worthwhile acquisitions.  Ashworth was a one-off, but until we get someone even half as good as him again (I doubt Gourlay is in his hemisphere let alone league) wim doomed - or should I say Semi-doomed.

For the record, Spanish.
I’m in Barcelona!
Reply
#56
Bob Fossil Wrote:Val has to be held, at least partly responsible, for any signings made on his watch. Clarke has been solid, Mowatt started well then faded and is now pretty useless and the rest were generally awful. The limitations with the budget are all on the club, however.
Val also, publicly, sanctioned the sale of Pereira, which the club then ballsed up in terms of the deal. At no point did Val ever stress any importance, however, of replacing him. He stated on numerous occasions that he was happy with the squad, as were most of us during those heady first few games. It was also clear that he was happy to wait for Dike
The problems started when the original system hit the skids and he started to tweak. It's at that point that it all got a bit confused and the frailties of both manager and squad were exposed.

The upshot for me is:

Val is a poor, one-dimentional manager, who made bad choices both in the transfer window and on the pitch.

Everyone above him, from recruitment to deal negotiators also had an absolute mare of a summer.

We have a very poor squad, both old and new, which is far worse on grass than it appears on paper

Good look Brucie.
True but, as when things have gone wrong before, it is not down to just one person. (Pardew is the exception to that, mind). Once again we had a perfect storm.  An unbalanced squad. Under-investment due to covid -although that probably left us better fixed than most after relegation- and a lack of interest from the owner. Poor recruitment, because we had no one to do it. The under-researched appointment (and subsequent 4 year contract) of a 'project' manager, and the cost of then not seeing it through. This is why I am happy for SB to take over for now.
I'm not certain Val, for all his obvious faults, is a poor manager. The U23s are effective and good to watch. He was the wrong man for this job though. We also don't know for certain it was his decision to wait for Dike. After all, the savings by waiting for him were surely eaten up by the replacement temporary measure of Hugill. But that is water under the bridge now.
Bruce (like Sam before him) is the new fire fighter but until we get the decision making right off the field, we are doomed to repeat the same mistakes. It is all about getting the right backroom guy in. Right now, the situation is not irretrievable. A good run could see us hitting the play offs and we might get lucky. If we don't go up, maybe there will be enough good feeling or realism to take us into next season with a plan and some hope.
Reply
#57
(02-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.

So when we get results it's because the squad is good. When we don't get results it's because the manager is crap.

OK
Reply
#58
(02-10-2022, 10:52 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.

So when we get results it's because the squad is good. When we don't get results it's because the manager is crap.

OK

No, I think our relatively good squad compared to those around us bar Fulham will do better under Bruce than Val. However I recognise it may take more than one game and less than a handful of training sessions for him to turn around a team bereft of confidence and asked to play in a very one dimensional and ineffective way for months. 

Last season you were arguing that the manager can mitigate for the lack of quality in a team, now you’re arguing that it’s only the squad that determines where we will finish. Val had a squad far better than the  results and performances the team produced. 

Even if you are proven right by the end of the season and we languish outside the play-off places, that will surely seem like a very hollow victory?
Reply
#59
(02-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:52 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I suspect we will see better performances and results until the end of the season. Bruce has had one game and two, three training sessions to turn around a very poor run of form. Let’s see how bad the squad is when we get to May.

So when we get results it's because the squad is good. When we don't get results it's because the manager is crap.

OK

No, I think our relatively good squad compared to those around us bar Fulham will do better under Bruce than Val. However I recognise it may take more than one game and less than a handful of training sessions for him to turn around a team bereft of confidence and asked to play in a very one dimensional and ineffective way for months. 

Last season you were arguing that the manager can mitigate for the lack of quality in a team, now you’re arguing that it’s only the squad that determines where we will finish. Val had a squad far better than the  results and performances the team produced. 

Even if you are proven right by the end of the season and we languish outside the play-off places, that will surely seem like a very hollow victory?

You are right the manager does have an important influence on a team's fortunes, but so does the players he has to work with.

I am very confident that under Bruce both results and performance will pick up, because yes the players are better than current results and performances suggest. And Bruce is a good manager at this level.

And with a strong wind at our back and a bit of luck at key moments, it's not far fetched to think we can reach the play offs and win them.

But it's not the most likely outcome.

And going forward, whatever happens, we need to have a revamp of our recruitment strategies, because it hasn't been working for some time.
Reply
#60
(02-09-2022, 10:00 PM)Mickyfudge Wrote: I think we are finally realising what a poor squad this is ,a complete lack of pace or creativity throughout the team

Despite the individual 'names' you've hit the nail on the head Micky.  The likes of Grant, Diangana and Robinson are stealing a living at the moment they should be ripping this league apart. 

Let's hope when O'shea, Bartley and Dike are back he can somehow find a formula to win games.

After tge last three defeats, Auto is a pipe dream but 1 point off the playoffs with a new manager and Dike to come back it's still all to play for.

The season has however been nothing short of a disaster. 10 defeats already which is shameful and we never look like scoring a goal. I tbink I've just doused my own hope of a resurrection!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)