Val gone
#51
(02-08-2022, 04:56 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-08-2022, 04:18 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: Val's demise was odd. I can't recall any manager, even during the dark days, who received such abuse so early on in their time here. It really was turning very nasty on the part of some of our fanbase. Ultimately he was just the wrong person at the wrong time for us.

I think there were issues with Val which meant some of the fans wouldn't warm to him. Lack of charisma, being French and/or German, being black, who knows what? But he didn't get the appreciation which for example Bilic achieved in a short space of time. Having said which, if we'd kept on winning, Val would have ridden that out. When it went bad (and let's be fair, the trend was bad for many weeks) he was always going to get abuse because they day like him much anyway and he hadn't got a promotion under his belt.

There was a lot of "how very dare you?" on here when it was suggested that some tiny percentage of the fans might take against a black French/German bloke. Yet many people always defend the abuse James McClean got, due to his birth and upbringing in a hotbed of anti-British sentiment. I thought he behaved with dignity, as did Val. No-one deserves the level of abuse footie fans can summon up.

Many didn't want him to begin with but the most biased person would struggle to criticise the two 4-0s.   

For me the P'Boro performance and two 0-0s v Derby and Millwall were when the seeds of doubt were sown and after the awful performance at Stoke - despite wins that followed - there was a growing disatisfaction with his style and apparent inability or stubbornness to change tactics - though I do personally think he tweaked things,  certainly the press and not hoofing it. 

Shame but I guess he had to go or close the ground one of the two (the authorities may have closed the ground if there was further trouble, I think sadly this was a factor in the decision).
Reply
#52
I think this data analysis of Val's time with us is very interesting. To me it shows that the system itself worked absolutely fine, we just didn't score enough of the multitude of chances that we created.

I can't help feeling that, to a significant extent, Val was a victim of the kind of infectious torches and pitchforks mentality that the proliferation of social media these days engenders. It could be argued that the players can get caught up in that too, which could result in their heads being turned more easily than should be the case for supposed professionals who are being paid obscene amounts of money every week.

Yes the form was going in the wrong direction, but you have to wonder how much of that was due to the players' attitudes more than the system failing? In the end, Val probably paid the price for not rotating the squad enough, which enabled some players to get precious about not being selected in some games.
Reply
#53
(02-09-2022, 01:51 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I think this data analysis of Val's time with us is very interesting. To me it shows that the system itself worked absolutely fine, we just didn't score enough of the multitude of chances that we created.

I can't help feeling that, to a significant extent, Val was a victim of the kind of infectious torches and pitchforks mentality that the proliferation of social media these days engenders. It could be argued that the players can get caught up in that too, which could result in their heads being turned more easily than should be the case for supposed professionals who are being paid obscene amounts of money every week.

Yes the form was going in the wrong direction, but you have to wonder how much of that was due to the players' attitudes more than the system failing. In the end, Val probably paid the price for not rotating squad enough, which enabled some players to get precious about not being selected in some games.

You could argue that we quite a long period where we were creating plenty of good chances, enough to win games, but weren't taking them so ended up getting draws or defeats when we should have been winning. This then led to players losing confidence and eventually the chances dried up and we ended up with the Preston and Millwall performances. Think there's a good chance Val would still be here if we'd signed DK in the Summer
Reply
#54
TartanRug Wrote:
WorcsWBA Wrote:I think this data analysis of Val's time with us is very interesting. To me it shows that the system itself worked absolutely fine, we just didn't score enough of the multitude of chances that we created.

I can't help feeling that, to a significant extent, Val was a victim of the kind of infectious torches and pitchforks mentality that the proliferation of social media these days engenders. It could be argued that the players can get caught up in that too, which could result in their heads being turned more easily than should be the case for supposed professionals who are being paid obscene amounts of money every week.

Yes the form was going in the wrong direction, but you have to wonder how much of that was due to the players' attitudes more than the system failing. In the end, Val probably paid the price for not rotating squad enough, which enabled some players to get precious about not being selected in some games.

You could argue that we quite a long period where we were creating plenty of good chances, enough to win games, but weren't taking them so ended up getting draws or defeats when we should have been winning. This then led to players losing confidence and eventually the chances dried up and we ended up with the Preston and Millwall performances. Think there's a good chance Val would still be here if we'd signed DK in the Summer
True. I also think the players, low on confidence or not, hung him out to dry as they sensed the mood of the fans get worse.
Reply
#55
All the above, absolutely spot on

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#56
Really enjoyed that read WorcsWBA! Cheers. Never seen that site before.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#57
(02-09-2022, 02:09 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really enjoyed that read WorcsWBA! Cheers. Never seen that site before.

You're welcome. If you use Twitter, keep an eye on Albion Analytics.
Reply
#58
(02-09-2022, 01:51 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I think this data analysis of Val's time with us is very interesting. To me it shows that the system itself worked absolutely fine, we just didn't score enough of the multitude of chances that we created.

I can't help feeling that, to a significant extent, Val was a victim of the kind of infectious torches and pitchforks mentality that the proliferation of social media these days engenders. It could be argued that the players can get caught up in that too, which could result in their heads being turned more easily than should be the case for supposed professionals who are being paid obscene amounts of money every week.

Yes the form was going in the wrong direction, but you have to wonder how much of that was due to the players' attitudes more than the system failing? In the end, Val probably paid the price for not rotating the squad enough, which enabled some players to get precious about not being selected in some games.

He was definitely guilty of not changing the system enough, as for not rotating the squad enough; realistically we didn't have enough viable options in a very thin squad. That's why tonight under a new manager 80% of the first team picks itself, especially with Bartley and Phillips out.

Agree with the rest though. It got a bit painful towards the end but it was only the last 2 or 3 matches where we didn't dominate
Reply
#59
(02-02-2022, 04:27 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
TETLEY74 Wrote:
YoYoBaggie Wrote:Must admit I'm shocked but not disappointed, wonder what it's cost the club in payments but it was obvious to all who attended games that things didn't seem right, let's hope whoever replaces him will play players to to there strengths.

And what exactly are these players strengths, they've been asked by at least the last few managers to play 100mph high press football, pragmtic defensive hit on the counter football, attacking front foot style football and have eventually contrived to fugg it all up , not a lot left to try really is there.

Good point. Val didn't help himself but these players have fucked over a few managers now. I personally hope we get someone more hardline than Stalin in to knock a few heads together.
Come late to this. But I really take issue with this belief that only a hard taskmaster style works.
Professional players know better than do we that fans want blood sweat and tears. Hence the badge kissing.
But any manager who's achieved anything does not do it by being a martinet. Sure, that's one string to the bow. But getting the best out of your subordinates demands a far better understanding of people. Some need the clichéd arm round the shoulder, some a kick from time to time. 
I think of the managers I worked for who got the best out of me. They were on my side, and I on theirs. 
Constant screaming soon wears off. Ask Roy Keane!
I've always been impressed by Bruce's manner- described by his best player at Newcastle as "gentle".
Reply
#60
(02-09-2022, 01:51 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I think this data analysis of Val's time with us is very interesting. To me it shows that the system itself worked absolutely fine, we just didn't score enough of the multitude of chances that we created.

I can't help feeling that, to a significant extent, Val was a victim of the kind of infectious torches and pitchforks mentality that the proliferation of social media these days engenders. It could be argued that the players can get caught up in that too, which could result in their heads being turned more easily than should be the case for supposed professionals who are being paid obscene amounts of money every week.

Yes the form was going in the wrong direction, but you have to wonder how much of that was due to the players' attitudes more than the system failing? In the end, Val probably paid the price for not rotating the squad enough, which enabled some players to get precious about not being selected in some games.

Has Derek come along and told us he saw all of this with his own eyes yet? Cool
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)