The rugby
#21
(02-05-2022, 06:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Bloody pub is full of twats. Why does everyone that can't kick a football automatically believe they are a expert on rugby?

The six nations brings out all the twats. 
It’s never been a sport that has grabbed my attention but used to know a handful of players like in the days of the Underwoods, Carling, Guscott etc. Now I genuinely don’t know one player. It was on in the background as I made a fish pie and put some pictures up, following some DIY. Looks a gripping game if it’s your thing. 
Loads of rugger types have tried to get my son to play rugby as he’s a very tall strong kid, but he has the same ambivalence towards the sport as me. Each to their own but I’m glad he’s ducked that.
Reply
#22
(02-05-2022, 07:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-05-2022, 07:30 PM)Peachy Wrote: I don't profess to know the rules of Rugby with any deep knowledge but watching that game has annoyed me.

Firstly Scotlands penalty try. That seems like a crazy rule. Our player basically intercepted their kick and knocked it out so their player couldn't catch it. They deemed it done on purpose so awarded a penalty try. So if the England player legitimately tried to catch it and it went out it wouldn't have been a penalty try? Bizarre. Surely its just defending?

Not only that giving them points for a try, which is debatable whether he would have caught it anyway, is one thing. To give them the full 7 points for a converted try is a ridiculous rule. Then to top it all off our player gets a 10 minute penalty.

The non awarding of a penalty to us at the end was a joke. Even the commentators said the ref will not award a penalty no matter how many times Scotland collapse the scrum. Just because it was in extra time that apparently means the ref won't give a penalty because its too contentious. Ridiculous.

England were much the better side I thought. In total control until the crazy triple substitution. I know Jones likes his "finishers" but the game swung straight away.

You're not allowed to deliberately knock the ball forward, it's an infringement and a yellow card. That is the rule. It was a penalty try because Cowan-Dickie was last man.

Not giving us a penalty was just bizarre though, there were two clear opportunities.

So if he had deliberately knocked it out sideways or backwards it wouldn't have ended in the penalty try? 

If that's the case thats just a ridiculous rule.....
Reply
#23
What a farcical rule. You give a penalty try AND sin bin the player. It's a double punishment. The penalty try was the punishment. There is no ability for a football referee to give a penalty goal hence why it's right to send someone off who stops a clear goal scoring opportunity but if, in a sport, you have the opportunity, as an official, to award a penalty score you shouldn't be allowed to also add the additional punishment of sending off or sinbinning the player. Should be one or the other.
Reply
#24
(02-05-2022, 08:50 PM)Peachy Wrote: So if he had deliberately knocked it out sideways or backwards it wouldn't have ended in the penalty try? 

If that's the case thats just a ridiculous rule.....

Yeah, basically. The rule this comes under is throwing forward and if you throw sideways or backwards you're not throwing forwards.

As for whether the rule is ridiculous, the reason for it is to stop players from just throwing the ball over someone and catching it to beat a man.
Reply
#25
(02-05-2022, 10:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-05-2022, 08:50 PM)Peachy Wrote: So if he had deliberately knocked it out sideways or backwards it wouldn't have ended in the penalty try? 

If that's the case thats just a ridiculous rule.....

Yeah, basically. The rule this comes under is throwing forward and if you throw sideways or backwards you're not throwing forwards.

As for whether the rule is ridiculous, the reason for it is to stop players from just throwing the ball over someone and catching it to beat a man.

Yeah I get that but thats a totally different scenario. I can see why you can't throw it forward and run onto it. 

Today's was a simple knocking out of play as a defensive move. The mere fact that if it had gone out either sideways or backwards it would have resulted in a line out proves how silly it is.
Reply
#26
Bloke in the Chinese last night with a velcro wallet and a Mercedes F1 jacket who asked for his order "extra spicy" I presume he'd been watching the rugby.
Reply
#27
(02-06-2022, 07:08 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Bloke in the Chinese last night with a velcro wallet and a Mercedes F1 jacket who asked for his order "extra spicy" I presume he'd been watching the rugby.

Don’t get me onto people walking down the High St wearing F1 coats….
Reply
#28
This thread.

It's déjà vu all over again.
Reply
#29
I rest my case, the game is far too complicated, with most people watching ignorant of the layers, upon layers of rules added and tweaked seemingly annually.
Reply
#30
(02-06-2022, 08:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I rest my case, the game is far too complicated, with most people watching ignorant of the layers, upon layers of rules added and tweaked seemingly annually.

As someone very on the fringes I watched for 5 minutes intently and I said to my wife I may as well be watching American football as I really couldn’t work out what was happening. 
I thought it wasn’t this complicated 30 years ago and then continued my fish pie recipe.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: