The cost of living crisis
#41
From the MP Zarah Sultana 

“When you hear Rishi Sunak propose a £200 *loan* as a solution for households facing energy bills rocketing by £693, remember:

He's the richest MP, who last night in Parliament pushed through a tax cut for bankers worth £1,000,000,000 a year.

Sunak's on their side, not yours.”

Quite, and although SM is not a reliable barometer of public opinion, I think the fact the tweet has over 70k likes is testament to the shifting tectonics in politics. The scales are falling from peoples eyes at the lies, cronyism, vested interests and lack of understanding of the average persons life. Only when the politically ignorant are hit in the pocket will they start to see these charlatans for what they are. I know the usual suspects on here who have wedded themselves to the indefensible will stay silent or try whataboutery but this government is the worst in living memory.
Reply
#42
Tbf, and I’m no fan at all of this government, but inflation is a worldwide issue right now surely. America’s inflation is going up and up too.
Reply
#43
(02-04-2022, 10:31 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Tbf, and I’m no fan at all of this government, but inflation is a worldwide issue right now surely. America’s inflation is going up and up too.

It is but when we had the opportunity to protect ourselves against these problems by building a war chest we decided to stop spending instead of raising taxes. This has left us vulnerable to these problems that are happening globally now. Government isn't just about paying the bills now, it's about building for these future events, especially when they are so predictable. This government has continually kicked the can down the road and we are reaching the end of the cup de sac they have led us down.
Reply
#44
(02-04-2022, 10:36 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 10:31 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Tbf, and I’m no fan at all of this government, but inflation is a worldwide issue right now surely. America’s inflation is going up and up too.

It is but when we had the opportunity to protect ourselves against these problems by building a war chest we decided to stop spending instead of raising taxes. This has left us vulnerable to these problems that are happening globally now. Government isn't just about paying the bills now, it's about building for these future events, especially when they are so predictable. This government has continually kicked the can down the road and we are reaching the end of the cup de sac they have led us down.

Would that really have protected us? Massive quantitative easing (money printing) over 13 years, and incredible levels in the last 2 years (even if unavoidable) are surely the driving factor. I don’t think any country in the world is protected. Does this not run much deeper into the realms of the way the world banking system works/fiat currency/money supply etc? Be interested in Kit Kat’s thoughts, he seems to have his finger on the financial pulse!

Inflation is way up everywhere from NZ to U.K. to America to Canada to Australia and throughout the EU.
Reply
#45
(02-04-2022, 09:31 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It's time to realise that small state, small taxes is not sustainable 

Eh? The size of the state has expanded massively over the last 15 years, and the tax burden at 35.5% of GDP is the highest it's been for 70 years.

The most successful and sustained rise in living standards since the war occurred when the state was contracting and taxes falling. So what does that tell you?
Reply
#46
(02-04-2022, 11:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 09:31 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It's time to realise that small state, small taxes is not sustainable 

Eh? The size of the state has expanded massively over the last 15 years, and the tax burden at 35.5% of GDP is the highest it's been for 70 years.

The most successful and sustained rise in living standards since the war occurred when the state was contracting and taxes falling. So what does that tell you?

A bit of content is probably useful there Proth, if you could split out the infrastructure costs with the benefits costs it might show a different story. Benefits have increased the tax burden (pensions and other support due to population changes) and not the infrastructure spend. 

And surely based on the current view points of those in the know, the most successful and sustained rise in living standards was a global phenomenon and nothing to do with national policies. In fact the biggest growth has been seen in China which isn't exactly small state theory is it?
Reply
#47
(02-04-2022, 11:41 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 11:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 09:31 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It's time to realise that small state, small taxes is not sustainable 

Eh? The size of the state has expanded massively over the last 15 years, and the tax burden at 35.5% of GDP is the highest it's been for 70 years.

The most successful and sustained rise in living standards since the war occurred when the state was contracting and taxes falling. So what does that tell you?

A bit of content is probably useful there Proth, if you could split out the infrastructure costs with the benefits costs it might show a different story. Benefits have increased the tax burden (pensions and other support due to population changes) and not the infrastructure spend. 

And surely based on the current view points of those in the know, the most successful and sustained rise in living standards was a global phenomenon and nothing to do with national policies. In fact the biggest growth has been seen in China which isn't exactly small state theory is it?

If you're arguing that we should spend proportionately less on benefits and proportionately more on infrastructure I can't say I disagree, but you won't get that past an electorate who've been sucking on the client-state teat of Gordon Brown since 1997. Any way you look at it the state is bigger than ever - and we are taxed at the highest level in living memory.

In the UK the most successful and sustained rise in living standards occurred after the end of the 79-81 recession and continued through Major and Blair. The impact of the growth of China on the UK has been to mask the stagnation in living standards since 2008 - during which the state has progressively increased in size. I'm afraid comparing growth in the UK to a coercive state like China which until very recently was an agrarian subsistence economy is facile.
Reply
#48
(02-04-2022, 01:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 11:41 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 11:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 09:31 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It's time to realise that small state, small taxes is not sustainable 

Eh? The size of the state has expanded massively over the last 15 years, and the tax burden at 35.5% of GDP is the highest it's been for 70 years.

The most successful and sustained rise in living standards since the war occurred when the state was contracting and taxes falling. So what does that tell you?

A bit of content is probably useful there Proth, if you could split out the infrastructure costs with the benefits costs it might show a different story. Benefits have increased the tax burden (pensions and other support due to population changes) and not the infrastructure spend. 

And surely based on the current view points of those in the know, the most successful and sustained rise in living standards was a global phenomenon and nothing to do with national policies. In fact the biggest growth has been seen in China which isn't exactly small state theory is it?

If you're arguing that we should spend proportionately less on benefits and proportionately more on infrastructure I can't say I disagree, but you won't get that past an electorate who've been sucking on the client-state teat of Gordon Brown since 1997. Any way you look at it the state is bigger than ever - and we are taxed at the highest level in living memory.

In the UK the most successful and sustained rise in living standards occurred after the end of the 79-81 recession and continued through Major and Blair. The impact of the growth of China on the UK has been to mask the stagnation in living standards since 2008 - during which the state has progressively increased in size. I'm afraid comparing growth in the UK to a coercive state like China which until very recently was an agrarian subsistence economy is facile.

I'm not actually comparing the UK with China, I'm just pointing out that the growth in living standards is a global phenomenon brought on by cheaper available 'luxury' goods aligned with the technological advances made in the period since the late 70s / early 80s.

The obvious point here is that successive governments have simply kicked the can down the road and we are now at the end of the cul-de-sac with nowhere to go - planning for this should have been priority and the choices made over the last decade, austerity, clearly hasn't worked. It's disingenuous to say the government shouldn't / couldn't have known about the pandemic, when that is exactly what they should have planned for (not specifically obviously). I am a small cog in a large global organisation but I have to plan for things that may never happen and put safety nets in place, this government have simply not done that and proactively stripped away the ability for the country to do that basic function of government - protect the population from the global issues. 

We really are at a point in time when we have to rethink how we go forward - this Conservative government with its gameshow leader are continuing to damage the economy to better their own status / wealth / kudos without a thought for what they should be doing it for - the country.

It's no good talking of 'levelling up' when these are the very people that caused the inequalities, and keep on repeating that they are the party that 'got brexit done' means the grand sum of fuck all when there can be no benefit to doing that. The best and most blatant example of that is leaving the EU gave us the power to set our own VAT rates, when the 1st real need to do that (energy prices) they don't use that power.
Reply
#49
You won't "level up" buy cutting VAT on fuel. You'll disproportionately put more money in my pocket.

I'd much rather the government adopted measures to sort out the supply side of labour (training & education), energy and land.

I don't agree the Tories are damaging the economy to better their own status (how?) / wealth (how?) / kudos (how?) Why on Earth would they? To what feasible end?

Like governments around the globe they're hostages to the policy errors of decades past, like Tax Credits in an era of Full Employment, like illiberal planning policy in an era of or cheap credit and runaway house prices, like taxing the young and poor to fund the social care of the older and wealthy, like going for net zero without cheap baseload energy. You can't unwind any of these issues without paying a hefty political price.

I have had it with active politics for good - because no party seems capable of addressing the fundamental issues of life, let alone "levelling up". Instead I'll encourage everyone to do whatever they can for themselves and their families despite whichever government is in power.
Reply
#50
do whatever they can for themselves and their families.

The I'm alright Jack approach is not far off Anarchy
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: