Posts: 2,881
Threads: 106
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
Pulis
Little
Pardew
Irvine
Nobsor
In that order.
Clarnet v2.0
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
02-04-2022, 12:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-04-2022, 12:45 PM by AnelkasBeard.)
Mel
AFI
Pardew
Little
Pulis
Robson
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Seems that for a lot of people this is a list of managers whose football you disliked.
If that had been the question then Pulis would have been on the list. Well my list anyway.
But he did the job he was asked to do in the short term which was to keep us in the premiership.
Posts: 665
Threads: 28
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
My lord, I judge the defendants as follows:
Little
Complete no hoper during his time with us as the wheels firstly loosened and then soon fell off and he was incapable of taking steps to address it. I know money was tight, but he allowed the sale of Miller and threw in the inexperienced Adamson to enjoy a 0-6 at Sheffield Utd, followed not long after by a 0-3 at home to Blues. I attended both. His ineptitude was compounded by the fact he had fairly recently won trophies with the fuckers down the road and then delivered this pile of shite for us. We should have known better though after his Stoke City implosion the previous year. To this day the bloke still annoys me - There was a BBC WM Adrian Goldberg “The Other Side Of” episode a couple of years ago for Brian Little where the only references to WBA were that he managed us for a period, blah blah blah but he spoke at length about all other aspects of his career. I’d have had more respect for him if he’d lifted the lid on what the problems he undoubtedly faced were, or perhaps a bit of self-deprecation at how it all went for him here, but not a bar of it. Thank you for the memories Brian, my personal favourite was when the rest of the hawthorns joined in with the celebrating Bluenoses in the Smethwick for a full-time whistle chorus of “Brian Little! You’re a w***er, you’re a w***er!”
Sentencing Mitigation – He signed Larus Sigurdsson
Pardew
Over confident clown with an ego bigger than Sean Gregan’s arse. Failed to steady the ship, lost game after game after game and failed at 99% of the things he was brought in to do. Left us with an unrecoverable situation completely and senior players doing what the feck they wanted. Halted the career of Sam Field with his stupid opinions.
Sentencing Mitigation – A fine FA cup victory at Anfield
Smith
Converted the great work of Ray Harford and the chance of being in the promotion mix into a mid-table finish and backed it up with a couple more thereafter. I don’t remember any consistency at all with him in charge. A so-called leader and well-regarded former Centre half who subsequently signed Matt Carbon and couldn’t in any way coach us to stop the stupid goals going in against us every game to chuck away more points. How a team that once had Hughes averaging a goal a game couldn’t even make the play offs is shameful. Also fell out with Bob and felt he wasn’t needed, but sent him on loan to the division above and watched him knock in a few for Bolton before trying to change his tune but it was too late. Should have achieved more with that firepower available and he also chose to buy a goalie he didn’t even need (Whitehead) when we had Miller.
Sentencing Mitigation – Signed Enzo Maresca, and turned Hughes from a super sub to a regular starting striker.
Buckley
The man that brought us the Blundell Park foreign exchange program where the participants always got homesick when they arrived at the Hawthorns and never properly integrated into the new culture. Completely ineffective signings, one of them being Paul Crichton performing each week like a Subbuteo goalie being operated by a 3-year-old as another saveable shot sails past him. There were far too many losses in a row to contrast against the arrogance that that man possessed in his football management philosophies. Flattered to deceive, and couldn’t deliver a league finish with Albion above what he had achieved in the division with the fishy ones (not those ones!).
Sentencing Mitigation – Signed Richard Sneekes to rescue the disastrous run of form.
Val
Ultimately didn’t have enough good will from the fans or players to ride out the drop off in form and has paid the price for his own stubbornness and blunt tactical approach. Even the eejits mentioned above could change things up a bit and make subs and tactical changes to suit a particular opponent or how a match was going. Val – you played it like a football manager game where you click to play the matches as quickly as possible and do everything precisely the same for each one. And then you got sacked for it! Standard. Underachieved after a great start. “You’re not the God of football!”
Sentencing Mitigation – Modern day player power can put some managers on a collision course. Performed a memorable touchline sprint of Barry Fry vintage in Barry Fry’s own back yard.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Personally, I would award all 5 worst manager trophies to Saunders. Never has one man wreaked such misery on a club at the same time as re-vitalising their worst enemies. Winning a league title for one and donating the players to get the other back from extinction. It was pure hell back then and anyone that began their supporting life in that period deserves a gong. He oversaw record low gates, regular humiliation and all the time kept the straight faced cruelty of the worst of Bond villains. I went to the Yeltz one weekend and saw a whole crowd of ex Albion fans, driven away by this charlatan. Compared to this character, all the others mentioned are merely inept.