Val Ball and stats
#11
(02-03-2022, 08:47 AM)SophLad Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 08:42 AM)strawman Wrote: xG the woulda, coulda, shoulda stat - We woulda  had more goals if we coulda had better finishers which shoulda give us more points.

Fact - Footballers miss chances, better footballers miss less chances, poorer footballers miss more chances - bring on Cilla - surprise surprise

Surprise Surprise, a Jordan Hugill effort, between the eyes

He'd never get it that much on target! But op 'arfs when I read it Big Grin

I always feel that stats (other than the score ones) should only be used as an assistive set of data, and shouldn't rule what is actually happening.

Six has made me agree with Derek so many times! Ack!
Reply
#12
(02-03-2022, 08:42 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 08:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 08:35 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: I’m not interested in facts. I find they tend to cloud my judgement.

I bet you used to point to possession stats as well to say we were the better team!

I prefer to rely on instinct and blind prejudice.

So you did. What prejudice is that then?

(02-03-2022, 08:53 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 08:47 AM)SophLad Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 08:42 AM)strawman Wrote: xG the woulda, coulda, shoulda stat - We woulda  had more goals if we coulda had better finishers which shoulda give us more points.

Fact - Footballers miss chances, better footballers miss less chances, poorer footballers miss more chances - bring on Cilla - surprise surprise

Surprise Surprise, a Jordan Hugill effort, between the eyes

He'd never get it that much on target! But op 'arfs when I read it Big Grin

I always feel that stats (other than the score ones) should only be used as an assistive set of data, and shouldn't rule what is actually happening.

Six has made me agree with Derek so many times! Ack!

Statistically I’m right a lot more than I’m wrong on here Wink
Reply
#13
Guardiola, Klopp, Mourinho, Bielsa, Tuchel, Nagelsmann all wrong. Stats are pointless. Val's inflexibility and his use of statistics are completely separate, although he does have a small point. I can think of three Hugill sitters off the top of my head that would have us 6 points better off.

Every manager with statistics available to them uses them to recruit players, pick teams, develop their tactical ideas and plans for the opponent. Especially for a club like ours where we can't just throw money at the biggest name players there are knowing their obvious quality, we have to rely heavily on statistics to see who is performing the best week in, week out. It would be absolutely negligent of us not to be doing this.

Take the example of a manager trying to sign a player. You can watch a player for hours and form an opinion, but it's only once you look into the stats do you know if said player will be an appropriate fit for your team and your tactical principles.
Reply
#14
(02-03-2022, 08:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: “A manager who relies heavily on statistics, the Frenchman – like many in the modern game – is a fan of expected goals data, or xG as it is known.” Masi Express and Star

That explains the one dimensional, robotic, predictable tactics we employed. Relying on statistics like XFuggingG is not managing and it ignores what you can see with your own eyes. The stats said we were creating more chances than the opposition but that only tells a fraction of the story, most of those chances weren’t gilt edged they were half chances from poor crosses, corners, set pieces, balls lumped into the box and long throws. It’s no surprise it only took a handful of games for managers to work out how to beat us employing these ‘ball free’ tactics. 

Even on here some of us said as early as the Sheff Utd match if you just sit deep, play it long and don’t dawdle on the ball in your own half you have very workable tactics to negate any XG inspired tactics we employed. 

Sadly this is what I will remember from Val’s time with us. It’s a shame as I think he’s a decent person who got lost in the theory and it harmed his practice.

XG does account for the quality of chance you know. A half chance will hardly get any added to the Xg, chances like Dike's header v Peterboro would get quite a bit added. It tells you (roughly) how good your finishing is. 

Early in the season we were probably (I havent checked) matching or exceeding our Xg in games like Cardiff away, then came a period when we were missing a lot of good chances, then the chances started to dry up and in the last couple of games unsurprisingly we've been comfortably outscored in Xg
Reply
#15
(02-03-2022, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Statistically I’m right a lot more than I’m wrong on here Wink

Feck, so am I! Big Grin
(02-03-2022, 08:57 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Guardiola, Klopp, Mourinho, Bielsa, Tuchel, Nagelsmann all wrong. Stats are pointless. Val's inflexibility and his use of statistics are completely separate, although he does have a small point. I can think of three Hugill sitters off the top of my head that would have us 6 points better off.

Every manager with statistics available to them uses them to recruit players, pick teams, develop their tactical ideas and plans for the opponent. Especially for a club like ours where we can't just throw money at the biggest name players there are knowing their obvious quality, we have to rely heavily on statistics to see who is performing the best week in, week out. It would be absolutely negligent of us not to be doing this.

Take the example of a manager trying to sign a player. You can watch a player for hours and form an opinion, but it's only once you look into the stats do you know if said player will be an appropriate fit for your team and your tactical principles.

I agree with a lot of that, but surely Six would have really used the in depth player stats BEFORE signing Hugill? And he's never ever been an amazing goal scoring striker (over 4.5 games per goal, any stat based manager would think, hmmm maybe not, surely?)

Stats have a place without a doubt, but they should never be the be all and end all. There were several games when people on here were bigging up our xG, but the reality to me and others was that we still never looked like scoring. I think the people who run xG need to re-evaluate their algorithms to account for us this season, we've definitely been the epitome of a statistical anomaly.

(02-03-2022, 09:01 AM)TartanRug Wrote: XG does account for the quality of chance you know. A half chance will hardly get any added to the Xg, chances like Dike's header v Peterboro would get quite a bit added. It tells you (roughly) how good your finishing is. 

Early in the season we were probably (I havent checked) matching or exceeding our Xg in games like Cardiff away, then came a period when we were missing a lot of good chances, then the chances started to dry up and in the last couple of games unsurprisingly we've been comfortably outscored in Xg

Did we really need stats to tell us our finishing was shyte though?
Reply
#16
Stats can be measured so many ways, but simply whilst they are useful and a key indicator there's common sense too, which you can't bottle. It was clear to observers we were getting more and more lost and creating less and less, but he wouldn't do anything.

I've lost count of the games I saw where we dominated and the game was being played on the edge of the opponents penalty area only to finish with a blocked shot from distance until we created the next blocked shot or effort that sailed way over the bar.

For instance there were heaps of games where we had 20 odd efforts, but to my eyes we only created a handful.
Personally I think the likes of the goalless draws at Barnsley and Blackpool epitomise the turgid predictability of what his philosophy was.
Reply
#17
(02-03-2022, 09:01 AM)TartanRug Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 08:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: “A manager who relies heavily on statistics, the Frenchman – like many in the modern game – is a fan of expected goals data, or xG as it is known.” Masi Express and Star

That explains the one dimensional, robotic, predictable tactics we employed. Relying on statistics like XFuggingG is not managing and it ignores what you can see with your own eyes. The stats said we were creating more chances than the opposition but that only tells a fraction of the story, most of those chances weren’t gilt edged they were half chances from poor crosses, corners, set pieces, balls lumped into the box and long throws. It’s no surprise it only took a handful of games for managers to work out how to beat us employing these ‘ball free’ tactics. 

Even on here some of us said as early as the Sheff Utd match if you just sit deep, play it long and don’t dawdle on the ball in your own half you have very workable tactics to negate any XG inspired tactics we employed. 

Sadly this is what I will remember from Val’s time with us. It’s a shame as I think he’s a decent person who got lost in the theory and it harmed his practice.

XG does account for the quality of chance you know. A half chance will hardly get any added to the Xg, chances like Dike's header v Peterboro would get quite a bit added. It tells you (roughly) how good your finishing is. 

Early in the season we were probably (I havent checked) matching or exceeding our Xg in games like Cardiff away, then came a period when we were missing a lot of good chances, then the chances started to dry up and in the last couple of games unsurprisingly we've been comfortably outscored in Xg

But not the quality of the footballer who has the chance - based on the 'average' and apparently all ours are below average  Cool
Reply
#18
Is there a stat for the amount of unremitting boredom in a game?
Reply
#19
(02-03-2022, 09:02 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I agree with a lot of that, but surely Six would have really used the in depth player stats BEFORE signing Hugill? And he's never ever been an amazing goal scoring striker (over 4.5 games per goal, any stat based manager would think, hmmm maybe not, surely?)

Stats have a place without a doubt, but they should never be the be all and end all. There were several games when people on here were bigging up our xG, but the reality to me and others was that we still never looked like scoring. I think the people who run xG need to re-evaluate their algorithms to account for us this season, we've definitely been the epitome of a statistical anomaly.

There is not a chance in hell Hugill was his first pick of strikers available in the summer. If he was he should have been dismissed on the spot.

The issue with xG is that it's easily derided once you have seen the result. But as a longer term indicator or performance and likelihood to win matches it's a useful tool. A one off game where you miss hatfuls of chances and the opposition nick one you can live with, happens to everyone and it shouldn't make you rip up your notebook. Do you think Pep panics when he loses his annual home game against Palace/Wolves or whoever? No, because he knows that if they perform like that across 38 games they will win more than they lose.

What worries me is that Val couldn't see the pattern developing. We were out performing teams on xG through volume not quality. Not doing anything to rectify that cost him his job, rightly so.

(02-03-2022, 09:08 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Stats can be measured so many ways, but simply whilst they are useful and a key indicator there's common sense too, which you can't bottle. It was clear to observers we were getting more and more lost and creating less and less, but he wouldn't do anything.

I've lost count of the games I saw where we dominated and the game was being played on the edge of the opponents penalty area only to finish with a blocked shot from distance until we created the next blocked shot or effort that sailed way over the bar.

For instance there were heaps of games where we had 20 odd efforts, but to my eyes we only created a handful.
Personally I think the likes of the goalless draws at Barnsley and Blackpool epitomise the turgid predictability of what his philosophy was.

Blackpool yes, although Hugill missed a great chance with a header second half. I can't agree on that Barnsley game where Hugill hit the defender with an open goal gaping from 6 yards, Kipre hit the post with a free header, Grant hit the post when he'd gone round the keeper and their striker had to overhead kick one off the line. That was one of the games where we actually could claim to have been unlucky. Val's last two games and the Cardiff home game were the worst for me.
Reply
#20
(02-03-2022, 08:57 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Guardiola, Klopp, Mourinho, Bielsa, Tuchel, Nagelsmann all wrong. Stats are pointless. Val's inflexibility and his use of statistics are completely separate, although he does have a small point. I can think of three Hugill sitters off the top of my head that would have us 6 points better off.

Every manager with statistics available to them uses them to recruit players, pick teams, develop their tactical ideas and plans for the opponent. Especially for a club like ours where we can't just throw money at the biggest name players there are knowing their obvious quality, we have to rely heavily on statistics to see who is performing the best week in, week out. It would be absolutely negligent of us not to be doing this.

Take the example of a manager trying to sign a player. You can watch a player for hours and form an opinion, but it's only once you look into the stats do you know if said player will be an appropriate fit for your team and your tactical principles.

I didn’t dismiss stats, I criticised the over reliance on them by many, particularly XG stats.

The rest of your post makes exactly my point, rather than believe what your watching, using your own judgment you want to use stats to drive the decision making on signing players and who plays. The overriding stat that should govern any football manager are results. If a team is consistently getting positive results over a sustained period of time but the stats don’t back that up, do you change the winning team? Do you employ a player with a really bad attitude on the strength of his stats being good or do you take a more rounded and nuanced view of the situation and use your own judgment. 

Stats are one tool, they don’t tell the whole story and aren’t the absolute truth (fact), they will help a manager, but to rely on them as Val seems to have done is folly.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: