Posts: 3,011
Threads: 287
Joined: Jun 2019
(02-02-2022, 08:42 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely spot on for me and exactly my thoughts
He will go on to be a decent manager somewhere, where the players buy in and the ego's are a little smaller
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...ny-longer/
Ironically he’d be perfect for us when/if we get promoted as we’d have less of the ball at PL level. He just couldn’t get us out of the Champ as we needed to be more dominating with the ball.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-03-2022, 08:01 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: (02-02-2022, 08:42 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely spot on for me and exactly my thoughts
He will go on to be a decent manager somewhere, where the players buy in and the ego's are a little smaller
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...ny-longer/
Ironically he’d be perfect for us when/if we get promoted as we’d have less of the ball at PL level. He just couldn’t get us out of the Champ as we needed to be more dominating with the ball.
Personally I think we'd have ended up worse than Derby if we'd gone up with Six. Ahhh well, none of us will ever find out though.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
There is a contradiction in Massis analysis.
On one hand he acknowledges our xg for stats were high. Suggesting we create sufficient chances to score.
On the other hand he states that clubs worked us out and stopped us creating chances.
Up until xmas I felt by and large we were doing enough in games to win them, but were failing to take advantage of the opportunities we were creating.
In the games I have seen since xmas, there has been a massive drop of in performance .
Given his brand of football is not popular with fans at the best of times, any drop in performance and results were going to be dangerous for Ismael.
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(02-03-2022, 08:14 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: There is a contradiction in Massis analysis.
On one hand he acknowledges our xg for stats were high. Suggesting we create sufficient chances to score.
On the other hand he states that clubs worked us out and stopped us creating chances.
Up until xmas I felt by and large we were doing enough in games to win them, but were failing to take advantage of the opportunities we were creating.
In the games I have seen since xmas, there has been a massive drop of in performance .
Given his brand of football is not popular with fans at the best of times, any drop in performance and results were going to be dangerous for Ismael.
Spot on Shabby
Personally I think his inflexibility will be his downfall. We became an easy team to plan to play against.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
02-03-2022, 08:37 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-03-2022, 08:57 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(02-03-2022, 08:14 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: There is a contradiction in Massis analysis.
On one hand he acknowledges our xg for stats were high. Suggesting we create sufficient chances to score.
On the other hand he states that clubs worked us out and stopped us creating chances.
Up until xmas I felt by and large we were doing enough in games to win them, but were failing to take advantage of the opportunities we were creating.
In the games I have seen since xmas, there has been a massive drop of in performance .
Given his brand of football is not popular with fans at the best of times, any drop in performance and results were going to be dangerous for Ismael.
There isn’t a contradiction, if anything it perfectly illustrates the problems we had with Val Ball. XfuggingG stats are a blunt tool that only tell a fraction of the story. We created half chances from aimless crosses, and balls lumped forward, shots from outside the box as teams sat deep. They were weren’t many gilt edged chances we were missing on the whole and the opposition were quite comfortable in many games as we toiled to create decent opportunities against them. The strikers have taken a battering this season for being shot shy, but the quality of chances created not quantity is a major reason for our lack of goals.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Pros
- We're far fitter and organised than we have been in previous seasons. Our excellent defensive record is testament to this and means you don't have to score as often to win games (but you do still have to score sometimes).
- The system and his principles I liked, whether you're a fan of the % football or not there is no questions that it created us enough (not loads) chances to have us 6-8 points better off providing he had someone capable of scoring from 6 yards, literally anyone but Hugill. Dike arriving and then getting injured straight away was the final nail in his coffin.
- The age group sides really seem to have taken to his style of football. From watching bits of the U23s some of the goals they've been scoring are peak Valball.
- Calling out are awful recruitment of the previous years. Signing ageing players with no resale value, he knew it had to change. It would have been interesting to see who he brought in. Mowatt started well and tailed off with the rest of the team, Clarke looks tidy enough and Dike comes highly thought of.
Cons
- Repeatedly shot himself in the foot by refusing to change and adapt. Every manager can stick to their principles but they have to change things up. Guardiola and Klopp do it, Mowbray has totally changed his MO with Blackburn this season and Val refused. As futile as it would have been he would have been given more slack for simply playing a different formation.
- Think his lack of experience cost him as well. Ultimately when things started going awry he wasn't able to stop, strip everything back to basis and build again. The last month or so from the Cardiff game onwards was particularly bleak as I think he completely lost his head. His antics post-Cardiff, the fall out with Johnstone, the supposed 'epiphany' after the Preston game. It all got too much for him I think.
I was pleased when we appointed him. We'd been urging the club to pick a younger manager with some potential and on the face of it he'd earned his chance. I was willing to give him a season as it was never going to be an easy job turning this squad over and into something that could master Valball. Especially when the resources provided restricted him to Adam Reach, Kean Bryan and Jordan Hugill. If I were Val I'd be wanting some time away from the game, but could also see him being a decent fit somewhere like Sunderland where he would have chance to bring them into the Championship, or even a return to Barnsley in L1. I'd also echo the thoughts of many on here in that he wont be really successful until he can adapt his methods to suit what is at his disposal better.
As for us we're now back to square one, appointing one of the old guard, how utterly depressing.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-03-2022, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Pros
- We're far fitter and organised than we have been in previous seasons. Our excellent defensive record is testament to this and means you don't have to score as often to win games (but you do still have to score sometimes).
- The system and his principles I liked, whether you're a fan of the % football or not there is no questions that it created us enough (not loads) chances to have us 6-8 points better off providing he had someone capable of scoring from 6 yards, literally anyone but Hugill. Dike arriving and then getting injured straight away was the final nail in his coffin.
- The age group sides really seem to have taken to his style of football. From watching bits of the U23s some of the goals they've been scoring are peak Valball.
- Calling out are awful recruitment of the previous years. Signing ageing players with no resale value, he knew it had to change. It would have been interesting to see who he brought in. Mowatt started well and tailed off with the rest of the team, Clarke looks tidy enough and Dike comes highly thought of.
Cons
- Repeatedly shot himself in the foot by refusing to change and adapt. Every manager can stick to their principles but they have to change things up. Guardiola and Klopp do it, Mowbray has totally changed his MO with Blackburn this season and Val refused. As futile as it would have been he would have been given more slack for simply playing a different formation.
- Think his lack of experience cost him as well. Ultimately when things started going awry he wasn't able to stop, strip everything back to basis and build again. The last month or so from the Cardiff game onwards was particularly bleak as I think he completely lost his head. His antics post-Cardiff, the fall out with Johnstone, the supposed 'epiphany' after the Preston game. It all got too much for him I think.
I was pleased when we appointed him. We'd been urging the club to pick a younger manager with some potential and on the face of it he'd earned his chance. I was willing to give him a season as it was never going to be an easy job turning this squad over and into something that could master Valball. Especially when the resources provided restricted him to Adam Reach, Kean Bryan and Jordan Hugill. If I were Val I'd be wanting some time away from the game, but could also see him being a decent fit somewhere like Sunderland where he would have chance to bring them into the Championship, or even a return to Barnsley in L1. I'd also echo the thoughts of many on here in that he wont be really successful until he can adapt his methods to suit what is at his disposal better.
As for us we're now back to square one, appointing one of the old guard, how utterly depressing.
Mostly agree, but Reach is 29 and so falls into the no real resale value category. So he didn't stop it, and you could argue Carroll too, but obviously that was 'special' circumstances (those caused by no fecker at the club thinking we needed a real striker from day 1).
The age group sides I am not surprised by, as I've pointed out a few times, his style works really well in the lower leagues.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
The big thing to take away from the podcast Masi did was journalist's did ask Val why he never deviated away from the system, even at the end of games and his answer was he still firmly believed you will create more chances playing this system than any other, that was ultimately his downfall
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 3,594
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
02-03-2022, 09:27 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-03-2022, 09:27 AM by Brentbaggie.)
I have no doubt that Val could achieve a measure of success with young fit players who have no long term experience of different playing styles and are willing to accept a footballing philosophy that is aimed at forcing errors and turnovers high up the pitch in order to create 'chances'.
But at the higher levels of the game where is there a club with that player profile or fanbase willing to accept the sometimes unwatchable 'product' such a style requires? In the lower leagues it could very well work but invariably an incoming manager has to accept an age and experience range of players, many of whom have played under better (and worse) managers who have demanded at least a modicum of thoughtful, entertaining, passing football. Our players may not have been the most skilful and were I'm sure more than prepared to accept his methods, but his intransigence and inability to acknowledge the need to change horses for courses cannot have been easy to take.
I have spent 54 years watching the Albion and even in our darkest hours, when the football was truly dreadful, I have never felt so exasperated or miserable as I have this season. My daughter has only watched us for four years but the sight of her putting her hand over her eyes at a home game and trying not to watch through her fingers told me everything I need to know about the game we were at. Val is clearly likeable, intelligent and committed, but he is not a man manager or even a football manager, and until he learns those two basic requirements he is highly unlikely - in my opinion - ever to achieve success at anything approaching the higher levels of the game.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
02-03-2022, 09:30 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-03-2022, 10:53 PM by WorcsWBA.)
(02-02-2022, 08:42 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely spot on for me and exactly my thoughts
He will go on to be a decent manager somewhere, where the players buy in and the ego's are a little smaller
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...ny-longer/
I agree with most of the article too. he was as success at LASK and at Barnsley and I'm sure he will be elsewhere. I wish him all the best and hope he's back in work soon.
Those who have been (and still are) mercilessly scorning him might stop to consider that he's been miles away from his family whilst at Barnsley and with us, which is no small measure of commitment. Hopefully he'll spend a decent amount of time back with them and recharging his batteries.
|