5 worst Albion managers of your generation
#41
1. Gould
2. Pardwank
3. Little
4. Burkinshaw
5. Allardyce
Reply
#42
(02-02-2022, 10:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:57 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:54 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:39 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: Stiles 
Saunders 
Little
Pardew
Allardyce

Stiles wasn’t that bad in v difficult circumstances at the time, and certainly shouldn’t be on there at the exclusion of Val or Pulis.


Yup. In a season where we won 8 games all season (including Cup games) 6 of those came under Styles stewardship.

Stiles only won 3 games as manager according to Wikipedia (which includes cup games normally). It could be argued that Val came in under difficult circumstances when we'd only won 5 games the previous season and had sold our best player plus lost a lot of loan players.

3 league wins
1 league cup win
2 full members cup wins

Name the opposition….
Watford 3-1 a certain Robbie Dennison scored a curler from the edge of the box.  A few months later he was in the 4th division with the dingles.  Cheers Saunders.  Cut the wage bill? I doubt Dennison, Bull ans Thompson were earning much. 
Blues home or away?
Southampton 1-0 , was that the Sunday game?

Cov in the league cup?
Villa knocked us out in a replay, in the snow if memory serves me.  I recall snowballing the villa fans and being chased by the local plod.  We drew 2-2 at their place.  Pretty sure we were 2-0 up, Martyn Bennet scored early 2nd half in front of us?

V good Cab 

Stiles beat Blues home and away and Watford. Think Saunders beat Soton

Cov 4-3 in LC.  We really fugged up the last 16 tie at Villa

You are doing well if you get the FMC wins
Reply
#43
Pardew, by some distance.
Little
Gould
Smith
Irvine
Reply
#44
(02-02-2022, 10:38 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: V good Cab 

Stiles beat Blues home and away and Watford. Think Saunders beat Soton

Cov 4-3 in LC.  We really fugged up the last 16 tie at Villa

You are doing well if you get the FMC wins

Brighton away, Palace at home. Lost on penalties to Chelsea in the Southern semi-final.
Reply
#45
(02-02-2022, 10:38 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 10:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:57 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:54 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:39 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: Stiles 
Saunders 
Little
Pardew
Allardyce

Stiles wasn’t that bad in v difficult circumstances at the time, and certainly shouldn’t be on there at the exclusion of Val or Pulis.


Yup. In a season where we won 8 games all season (including Cup games) 6 of those came under Styles stewardship.

Stiles only won 3 games as manager according to Wikipedia (which includes cup games normally). It could be argued that Val came in under difficult circumstances when we'd only won 5 games the previous season and had sold our best player plus lost a lot of loan players.

3 league wins
1 league cup win
2 full members cup wins

Name the opposition….
Watford 3-1 a certain Robbie Dennison scored a curler from the edge of the box.  A few months later he was in the 4th division with the dingles.  Cheers Saunders.  Cut the wage bill? I doubt Dennison, Bull ans Thompson were earning much. 
Blues home or away?
Southampton 1-0 , was that the Sunday game?

Cov in the league cup?
Villa knocked us out in a replay, in the snow if memory serves me.  I recall snowballing the villa fans and being chased by the local plod.  We drew 2-2 at their place.  Pretty sure we were 2-0 up, Martyn Bennet scored early 2nd half in front of us?

V good Cab 

Stiles beat Blues home and away and Watford. Think Saunders beat Soton

Cov 4-3 in LC.  We really fugged up the last 16 tie at Villa

You are doing well if you get the FMC wins

I know we lost to Chelsea on pens, but can’t recall who we beat to get there, was that the area final?Fudge will know.

FMC was North and South back then so I’m guessing southern teams as we got Chelsea.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#46
How do we define "worst"? Results, style of play, personality, popularity with the players? I'll go with "least favourite", the ones I was happy to be rid of for whatever reason. In no particular order:

Pulis
Howe
Gould
Pardew
Buckley

There are many other candidates, but those are the ones that stand out for uselessness, cynicism and/or obnoxiousness.
Reply
#47
(02-02-2022, 10:24 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:03 PM)Ada Wrote: 1. Brian Little
2. VI
3. Buckley
4. Pullis
5. Talbot

Saunders was before my time. As was Don Howe! Tempted to put in Atkinson for leaving the second time. Perhaps harsh on Talbot as had good players sold to balance the books. A bit in the dark about Little, as was at Uni, but sense from reputation his time was slightly more dour than VI but stand to be corrected.

As much as I hate the cunt, Pulis should be nowhere near that list. He was pretty good at what he did for the most part. 

Pardew comfortably the worst in my lifetime.

Wow. Pulis happily threw the entire club under the bus because he needed to pay off another club for lying. He should be the top of everyone’s list. That relegation is more on him than Pardew.
Reply
#48
This is an unfair list to try and pick. Little was my least favourite but even I can see that he had very little backing when you compare him to Val.

We were a totally different club back then and we shopped in poundland. Despite what people think Val inherited a decent squad when compared to the rest of the division.

You have to look at all managers in relation to the tools at their disposal at that time and Albions relative wealth in comparison to the rest of the division that those managers managed in.

Given all the above Val is right up there imvhfo.
Reply
#49
(02-02-2022, 11:28 PM)Moore Than Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 10:24 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:03 PM)Ada Wrote: 1. Brian Little
2. VI
3. Buckley
4. Pullis
5. Talbot

Saunders was before my time. As was Don Howe! Tempted to put in Atkinson for leaving the second time. Perhaps harsh on Talbot as had good players sold to balance the books. A bit in the dark about Little, as was at Uni, but sense from reputation his time was slightly more dour than VI but stand to be corrected.

As much as I hate the cunt, Pulis should be nowhere near that list. He was pretty good at what he did for the most part. 

Pardew comfortably the worst in my lifetime.

Wow. Pulis happily threw the entire club under the bus because he needed to pay off another club for lying. He should be the top of everyone’s list. That relegation is more on him than Pardew.

Can't disagree with that. Pulis was entirely focused on fixing his £3m loss with Crystal Palace. Desperate to sell Evans for a fat fee, then angling for a pay-off. The least ambitious and most self-serving manager we ever had. I'll agree with Malcolm that he was pretty good at what he did - looking after his own interests.
Reply
#50
Very subjective but based on my attendance home and away at the time:

Buckley - that run of 13 games and his stubbornness
Gould - Twerton Park
Pardew- for being a wanker
Val - sucked the life out of fans.
Little- Sheffield away
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)