Massi's article on Val
#1
Absolutely spot on for me and exactly my thoughts

He will go on to be a decent manager somewhere, where the players buy in and the ego's are a little smaller

https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...ny-longer/
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#2
Decent article Cuzer.

Will be interesting what Val's next move is. I feel he'll be successful at a club where the expectations are a little lower, but he needs to see out a longer stint at his next club.

What was most concerning in terms of us was the inability of decent footballers to pass to their team mates. A basic requirement, and I struggle to understand why we were unable to do this. Hopefully this will change under the next Manager.
Reply
#3
I fair reflection on Val's time with us. 
I'm not sure if his single mindedness is an asset, good managers adopt, change and find a winning formula and convert that into a winning mentality. 
Val hasn't shown he is a winner in his time with us.
Good luck to him in the future.
Reply
#4
(02-02-2022, 08:42 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely spot on for me and exactly my thoughts

He will go on to be a decent manager somewhere, where the players buy in and the ego's are a little smaller

https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...ny-longer/

Tactically, his time here would lead me to believe not.
Reply
#5
Why Dumbo? Masi summed it up perfectly, his performances and XG rating is best 8n the division in terms of chances created, his system clearly needs a Dike type of player and Hugill couldn’t fill that void in any capacity

Then Dike getting injured was just rotten luck for him

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#6
Val had shocking luck while he was here. Dike and O'Shea being injured and nonsensical red cards, it just wasn't meant to be.

It's a good article (still miss Matt Wilson though), but I think he's too soft on the players. So what if he dropped Johnstone? No justification for them to down tools whatsoever.
Reply
#7
Still people have time for the idiot? He's taken Albion backward in a way that no other manager has ever done and over a longer period, the executive having just sat and watched. Not one player improved, they are all worse for the Ismael experience. Just one example - Grady, a superb player; one that should have taken the divison by storm and the idiot has him on the bench for an hour playing three half backs one of whom (Kipre) along with Reach have a fraction of his ability and creativity. The joy was sucked out of the game for Albion fans. OK, Pulis ball was awful at times, but never forget he got Albion up to sixth in the premier league and we could if he'd been a little luckier been in Europe. The idea that you are unlucky after 29 games playing the exact same way, shape, style, tactics, selections and like for like subs on sixty minutes is fatuous. A truly awful manager and he can stick xG where it's dark - good riddance.
Reply
#8
(02-03-2022, 07:28 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Still people have time for the idiot? He's taken Albion backward in a way that no other manager has ever done and over a longer period, the executive having just sat and watched. Not one player improved, they are all worse for the Ismael experience. Just one example - Grady, a superb player; one that should have taken the divison by storm and the idiot has him on the bench for an hour playing three half backs one of whom (Kipre) along with Reach have a fraction of his ability and creativity. The joy was sucked out of the game for Albion fans. OK, Pulis ball was awful at times, but never forget he got Albion up to sixth in the premier league and we could if he'd been a little luckier been in Europe. The idea that you are unlucky after 29 games playing the exact same way, shape, style, tactics, selections and like for like subs on sixty minutes is fatuous. A truly awful manager and he can stick xG where it's dark - good riddance.

All very well and then you provide Diangana as an example of a player who had gone backwards under Ismael.

This is a player, for whatever reason, was in retreat before Ismael got here.

And the truth is that the team in general have been in retreat since the start of 2020.

In the Bilic promotion season we started well, hit the half way point and started to go backwards. 

Ismaels gob was to arrest this decline, ultimately he failed to do this. But if we pretend the club was not in decline before he arrived, then there is little chance of us getting it right going forward.
Reply
#9
I think Six will have a good career in the lower leagues, where bulldozing the opposition might work better.

I think these two paragraphs sum everything that we just went through perfectly:

"When Albion were struggling to score, it was surely worth trying Hugill in a two or taking off a centre-back and throwing on another attacking player. But Ismael never did.

Instead, for months they played in a system that suited Daryl Dike – and yet he didn’t arrive from Orlando until January 1."
Reply
#10
(02-03-2022, 07:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 07:28 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Still people have time for the idiot? He's taken Albion backward in a way that no other manager has ever done and over a longer period, the executive having just sat and watched. Not one player improved, they are all worse for the Ismael experience. Just one example - Grady, a superb player; one that should have taken the divison by storm and the idiot has him on the bench for an hour playing three half backs one of whom (Kipre) along with Reach have a fraction of his ability and creativity. The joy was sucked out of the game for Albion fans. OK, Pulis ball was awful at times, but never forget he got Albion up to sixth in the premier league and we could if he'd been a little luckier been in Europe. The idea that you are unlucky after 29 games playing the exact same way, shape, style, tactics, selections and like for like subs on sixty minutes is fatuous. A truly awful manager and he can stick xG where it's dark - good riddance.

All very well and then you provide Diangana as an example of a player who had gone backwards under Ismael.

This is a player, for whatever reason, was in retreat before Ismael got here.

And the truth is that the team in general have been in retreat since the start of 2020.

In the Bilic promotion season we started well, hit the half way point and started to go backwards. 

Ismaels gob was to arrest this decline, ultimately he failed to do this. But if we pretend the club was not in decline before he arrived, then there is little chance of us getting it right going forward.

What is wrong with you, that you can't see what Ismael has done. We were relegated from the prem, we could rightly expect to be promoted if not automatically at least via the playoffs. Equally we should have been preparing to take our place in the Premier League and put up a good fight to stay there. Who on earth could see that shambles getting even getting promoted. Clearly the issues at the club are legion but hopefully the executive who ever they are, seem to have grasped that they have utterly failed to ask questions of the manager (supervison) and are putting it right. Don't make excuse for an intransigent, stubborn fool who has utterly failed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: