Big fat deadline day thread
#31
(01-30-2022, 11:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pulis football at its best was of a far better quality than anything Val dishes up. It may not be frenetically as exciting but from a tactical and skill perspective it’s far more sophisticated, better coached and has yielded better results.

Playing 4 centre-backs and having the midfield so far detached from the lone striker that he often needed binoculars to see them - Pulisball was always about not losing, even in games that we needed to win. He is the anti-christ to entertainment; I believed that before he came here (I can remember us losing 1-0 to Stoke where Stoke didn't have a single shot on target and we contrived to score an own goal in the last minute) and hated every single second of his time here. At least Val's system is based on attacking and, prior to him coming to England, his sides were averaging scoring nearly 2 goals per game. The Pulis ethos is anti-football and anti-entertainment.

To go back on topic, I can't honestly see us signing anyway today, but we could do with a more attack-minded central midfielder and a better left or right wing-back than the ones we have. If they're going to be busy with removing Val, then I can't see them also having time to bring any players in.
Reply
#32
Normally I'm optimistic that we might do some business on deadline day, to strengthen the squad and give the club a bit of a lift. This January, I just want a new Manager in place, because for this 'project' to work, we've reached the point where we either replace half the squad, or the Manager. I really don't see things improving under Val even if we replaced half the squad, so that needs to be the focus today.

This will mean that others around us will strengthen their playing staff, and we won't, but hopefully with the right managerial appointment that will give the squad a huge lift, and it will be like having new signings. We can but hope.
Reply
#33
(01-31-2022, 09:22 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Val Ball is far more ‘anti-football’ than Pulis. I said this at the start of the season and stand by that. Our current style of play negates any creativity and even makes the basics like passing worse. Townsend is a great example of a player going backwards in performance under Val Ball.

I hated Pulis, but at least his teams had a purpose and obvious direction to what they were doing on the pitch. Six has sucked all forms of everything from the game, and on that basis I say it's worse than Pulisball... I really hope we get a nice shiny, football in the pleasant style manager so I can get back to disagreeing with Derek soon Big Grin
Two key differences to Tony Pulis:

1) Pulis achieved his objectives so his style - like it or loathe it - worked and when it stopped working he was sacked. Our points haul and goals tally suggests this manager's style doesn't work;

2) To get a team to play as disciplined and organised as Pulis, Roy, Benitez and co does takes a hell of a lot of hard work, buy-in from players and coaching. This team - e.g. set pieces and lack of movement off the ball - looks anything but well drilled.
Reply
#34
I genuinely hadn’t realised it was today.
Reply
#35
I'm really struggling to contain my excitement.    Rolleyes
Reply
#36
Any signings today should not go outside the bigger picture plan. If they are young, athletic, powerful and have been genuinely been monitored as a long term signing, and we have found a few quid, then great.

If not, we should only sign players ala Carroll or give the youth team lot a go in positions we are short. Then go again in the summer with a solid, considered approach. please dont get wasting money on 18 month deals for players who just are not what we need (Snoddy etc)
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#37
(01-31-2022, 09:37 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 11:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pulis football at its best was of a far better quality than anything Val dishes up. It may not be frenetically as exciting but from a tactical and skill perspective it’s far more sophisticated, better coached and has yielded better results.

Playing 4 centre-backs and having the midfield so far detached from the lone striker that he often needed binoculars to see them - Pulisball was always about not losing, even in games that we needed to win. He is the anti-christ to entertainment; I believed that before he came here (I can remember us losing 1-0 to Stoke where Stoke didn't have a single shot on target and we contrived to score an own goal in the last minute) and hated every single second of his time here. At least Val's system is based on attacking and, prior to him coming to England, his sides were averaging scoring nearly 2 goals per game. The Pulis ethos is anti-football and anti-entertainment.

To go back on topic, I can't honestly see us signing anyway today, but we could do with a more attack-minded central midfielder and a better left or right wing-back than the ones we have. If they're going to be busy with removing Val, then I can't see them also having time to bring any players in.

You're including Six's time with the second string clubs, where he did indeed have sides that scored loads.

Check his time at 'proper' league clubs and the goals dried up to around 1 per game everywhere he has been, us and Barnsley actually improved things very slightly for him.

The only one that differs is LASK, an Austrian proper league club...

In short, his football in all proper leagues yields roughly 1 goal per game. His football in other leagues yields 2+ per game... He's damn consistent with never having sides that score goals, so we really should not be amazed that we are not scoring. His sides also tend to conceded around 1 goal per game on average across all his leagues.

This suggests he'd be brilliant with say Walsall, but not so much as he moves up the chain.

(01-31-2022, 10:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Any signings today should not go outside the bigger picture plan. If they are young, athletic, powerful and have been genuinely been monitored as a long term signing, and we have found a few quid, then great.

If not, we should only sign players ala Carroll or give the youth team lot a go in positions we are short. Then go again in the summer with a solid, considered approach. please dont get wasting money on 18 month deals for players who just are not what we need (Snoddy etc)

Totally agree with that.
Reply
#38
I wonder if he calls his forward line the Triple Alliance?
Reply
#39
(01-31-2022, 11:02 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 09:37 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 11:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pulis football at its best was of a far better quality than anything Val dishes up. It may not be frenetically as exciting but from a tactical and skill perspective it’s far more sophisticated, better coached and has yielded better results.

Playing 4 centre-backs and having the midfield so far detached from the lone striker that he often needed binoculars to see them - Pulisball was always about not losing, even in games that we needed to win. He is the anti-christ to entertainment; I believed that before he came here (I can remember us losing 1-0 to Stoke where Stoke didn't have a single shot on target and we contrived to score an own goal in the last minute) and hated every single second of his time here. At least Val's system is based on attacking and, prior to him coming to England, his sides were averaging scoring nearly 2 goals per game. The Pulis ethos is anti-football and anti-entertainment.

To go back on topic, I can't honestly see us signing anyway today, but we could do with a more attack-minded central midfielder and a better left or right wing-back than the ones we have. If they're going to be busy with removing Val, then I can't see them also having time to bring any players in.

You're including Six's time with the second string clubs, where he did indeed have sides that scored loads.

Check his time at 'proper' league clubs and the goals dried up to around 1 per game everywhere he has been, us and Barnsley actually improved things very slightly for him.

The only one that differs is LASK, an Austrian proper league club...

In short, his football in all proper leagues yields roughly 1 goal per game. His football in other leagues yields 2+ per game... He's damn consistent with never having sides that score goals, so we really should not be amazed that we are not scoring. His sides also tend to conceded around 1 goal per game on average across all his leagues.

This suggests he'd be brilliant with say Walsall, but not so much as he moves up the chain.

So, in essence, you're saying that his time with LASK, and what they did in Europe, doesn't count? Even if you look at Barnsley, if his win percentage was the same here as it was there, people wouldn't be clamouring for him to go.
Reply
#40
No incoming expected today.

Close thread.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 5 Guest(s)