Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(01-31-2022, 08:32 AM)Squid Wrote: (01-31-2022, 08:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-31-2022, 08:09 AM)Peachy Wrote: I'm sorry but I just dont have any sympathy for him. Every single manager in the history of the game inherits a team of players. Theres no problem having a strong philosophy on the way you play but you simply have to play to your players strengths and he just isnt doing it.
You have to coach to make players better. You have to play formations that suit those players and you have to man manage your players.
He is failing on all counts.
Exactly, the argument he hasn’t got a perfect squad, the perfect circumstances is just an excuse. Allardyce was slated for managing in far more difficult circumstances and criticised relentlessly by many of the same posters who are now ever so understanding of Val’s awful position… which isn’t awful let’s be honest, he’s in a very good position fail or succeed.
Allardyce should have said he was undertaking a ‘project’ it would have given far more leeway.
Not sure about this. Those who were most critical of Allardyce are the ones who didn't want Bilic to leave. I don't think anyone in this conversation falls into that camp. I very much wanted Allardyce to succeed and I liked the players and fitness he brought to the club.
I think there was a huge and rather childish anti-Sam sentiment which was quite independent of the Bilic situation. He's one of the game's bogey-men, like 'Arry, Warnock and Pulis. Being a dingle and also being associated with our darkest hour in 1991 were always going to be factors. I reckon Steve Bruce would have the same issues if he came to the Albion. We see our fellow posters at their worst, full of dogmatic opinions, vitriolic abuse, seeming to wish failure on a coach or player so they can be proved right. The abuse Sam received on here was unnecessary.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-31-2022, 08:55 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I think there was a huge and rather childish anti-Sam sentiment which was quite independent of the Bilic situation. He's one of the game's bogey-men, like 'Arry, Warnock and Pulis. Being a dingle and also being associated with our darkest hour in 1991 were always going to be factors. I reckon Steve Bruce would have the same issues if he came to the Albion. We see our fellow posters at their worst, full of dogmatic opinions, vitriolic abuse, seeming to wish failure on a coach or player so they can be proved right. The abuse Sam received on here was unnecessary.
Didn't want BFS anywhere near the club, not for any of the reasons you listed. Purely based on after his shenanigans and dodginess with England I don't think he should have been allowed to manage again. I also didn't think he would save us or be very good at the job.
I also do not think Bruce will do a very good job, simply because I don't think he's that good a manager, with Palace and actually Villa being his best runs... Other than that his win percentages are crap, and it's not like he hasn't spent at times too (he must be one of the few managers who has almost as many losses as wins, 376W vs 370L). I think he's another old fella who probably won't have the fight and heart to do the job that well.
Couldn't give a flying one where they've been before.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(01-31-2022, 08:55 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I think there was a huge and rather childish anti-Sam sentiment which was quite independent of the Bilic situation. He's one of the game's bogey-men, like 'Arry, Warnock and Pulis. Being a dingle and also being associated with our darkest hour in 1991 were always going to be factors. I reckon Steve Bruce would have the same issues if he came to the Albion. We see our fellow posters at their worst, full of dogmatic opinions, vitriolic abuse, seeming to wish failure on a coach or player so they can be proved right. The abuse Sam received on here was unnecessary.
He then went on to record just 4 wins in 25 games (the third worst record of any Albion permanent manager after Pardew and Stiles) and yet some still regard him as a messiah. Some of those probably also state that results are all that matter! Teflon-coated or what?
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-31-2022, 09:02 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (01-31-2022, 08:55 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I think there was a huge and rather childish anti-Sam sentiment which was quite independent of the Bilic situation. He's one of the game's bogey-men, like 'Arry, Warnock and Pulis. Being a dingle and also being associated with our darkest hour in 1991 were always going to be factors. I reckon Steve Bruce would have the same issues if he came to the Albion. We see our fellow posters at their worst, full of dogmatic opinions, vitriolic abuse, seeming to wish failure on a coach or player so they can be proved right. The abuse Sam received on here was unnecessary.
He then went on to record just 4 wins in 25 games (the third worst record of any Albion permanent manager after Pardew and Stiles) and yet some still regard him as a messiah. Some of those probably also state that results are all that matter! Teflon-coated or what?
They'll tell you it was all Bilic's fault and it's all Bilic's fault for Six's problems too...
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
01-31-2022, 09:09 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-31-2022, 09:20 AM by WorcsWBA.)
Assuming Val does go, I am concerned at the lack of football knowledge within the Board to be able to make an informed choice for his replacement. I can just about understand how they had to appoint Val without having a Director of Football in the summer, but they've had plenty of time to bring one in since and have failed to do so.
We have a chronic lack of "football people" in senior positions at the club and, whilst that remains the case, it's hard to envisage a workable and cohesive plan for the future to be conceived. I just hope we don't go for a lazy dinosaur-type appointment and we certainly shouldn't go for a short term one. Whoever comes in should get a contact to the end of this season + 2 years more. The idea to bring someone like Val in with a long contract to restructure and build the club was (and is) absolutely fine, but doing so without providing him with the tools to be able to be successful will be doomed to failure every time.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-31-2022, 09:09 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Assuming Val does go, I am concerned at the lack of football knowledge within the Board to be able to make an informed choice for his replacement. I can just about understand how they had to appoint Val without having a Director of Football in the summer, but they've had plenty of time to bring one in since and have failed to do so.
We have a chronic lack "football people" in senior positions at the club and, whilst that remains the case, it's hard to envisage a workable and cohesive plan for the future to be conceived. I just hope we don't go for a lazy dinosaur-type appointment and we certainly shouldn't go for a short term one. Whoever comes in should get a contact to the end of this season + 2 years more. The idea to bring someone like Val in with a long contract to restructure and build the club was (and is) absolutely fine, but doing so without providing him with the tools to be able to be successful will be doomed to failure every time.
Spot on. Except for the end of season +2, I'd say end of season, then evaluate, then 1 or 2 if they've done OK and made us look competitive again. A manager's job simply has to be based on performances, with allowable ranges of falling below / exceeding the aims. We cannot dish out long term contracts to any manager, even if Alex Ferguson decided to do it for £250 a week.
I also think player's contracts should have similar things in them too, do well you get your bonuses, as it is now, do badly and you should lose money too. There's so many metrics they could use to gauge it as well to remove some of the subjectivity.
Then we might get a club pulling in the same direction and everyone being in it together, like what Derby have got due to their self created adversity. Nothing more powerful than that feeling in sport.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(01-31-2022, 09:02 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (01-31-2022, 08:55 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I think there was a huge and rather childish anti-Sam sentiment which was quite independent of the Bilic situation. He's one of the game's bogey-men, like 'Arry, Warnock and Pulis. Being a dingle and also being associated with our darkest hour in 1991 were always going to be factors. I reckon Steve Bruce would have the same issues if he came to the Albion. We see our fellow posters at their worst, full of dogmatic opinions, vitriolic abuse, seeming to wish failure on a coach or player so they can be proved right. The abuse Sam received on here was unnecessary.
He then went on to record just 4 wins in 25 games (the third worst record of any Albion permanent manager after Pardew and Stiles) and yet some still regard him as a messiah. Some of those probably also state that results are all that matter! Teflon-coated or what?
Results are judged against resources… I expected nothing but relegation last season under Bilic and Sam because frankly our squad was never good enough. It was a very good promotion winning squad. The team did start playing better under Allardyce after he had brought in some players but it was never going to be enough.
This season our resources are better than most, we are competing at a much lower level now and the manager is not getting the most of his resources.
So yes I’m being completely consisted with my judgment unlike many others who hear the word ‘project’ or ‘philosophy’ and afford the manager far too much leeway.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
01-31-2022, 09:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-31-2022, 09:26 AM by WorcsWBA.)
(01-31-2022, 12:41 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: I think you and your preference for balanced posts would be better suited back on .com. Not nearly controversial or confrontational enough. I bet your Mother in Law even loves you, you nicey nicey twat .
(That wasn't meant nearly as misogynistic as it probably reads, and was definitely tongue in cheek ).
My mother-in-law does call me her favourite son-in-law, but that's slightly offset by me being the only one!
Given a topic I feel strongly about, I'm more than capable of being controversial, but I aim not to be abusive as much as I can, because I think resorting to that weakens the underlying point that I'm trying to make. I do have my pet peeves and beliefs like anyone else.
(01-31-2022, 09:16 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Spot on. Except for the end of season +2, I'd say end of season, then evaluate, then 1 or 2 if they've done OK and made us look competitive again. A manager's job simply has to be based on performances, with allowable ranges of falling below / exceeding the aims. We cannot dish out long term contracts to any manager, even if Alex Ferguson decided to do it for £250 a week.
I also think player's contracts should have similar things in them too, do well you get your bonuses, as it is now, do badly and you should lose money too. There's so many metrics they could use to gauge it as well to remove some of the subjectivity.
Then we might get a club pulling in the same direction and everyone being in it together, like what Derby have got due to their self created adversity. Nothing more powerful than that feeling in sport.
I think only giving someone a contract until the end of the season would significantly reduce the number of interested managers. It would also potentially leave us scrabbling around trying to find a manager in the close season when our full focus should be on player recruitment.
I agree to a large extent about players having financial stick as well as carrots, but they probably wouldn't come in the first place unless it becomes the norm throughout football. Maybe it will, as players (and agents) have ruled the roost for too long and the ever-increasing level of expenditure on them is completely unsustainable.
|