Imminent Sacking?
(01-30-2022, 11:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Yep, totally agree Squid, the anger at times has often been at the lack of direction at the club and it's now become hostile and toxic towards Val, he's come in with a plan, a strategy which at times has worked, others has not but one thing I do know is how hard he works, the hours, the study, the research, he lives away from his family and he's had zero patience from the fan base IMO, we were booiing when we battered Derby and drew 0-0, 1-1 at home to Milwall, 5th game of the season was it, sure they were booed then, it's the fall out from a shit Premiership season and stumbling over the line under Slav and Val has took a lot of the wrap

Where he has failed is his complete one dimensional approach tactically, you would almost love a pint with him just to ask "Why?" From Sunday league to Klop managers have more than one approach, why can't he?

Cuzer
This. Currently Val is taking all the flak and I am equally puzzled at what you mention in the last paragraph. He isn't taking any other route. He could choose to change, I wish he would,  he isn't going to. So think on. We have been left under invested at continual transfer windows, preferring instead to take our better players on loan while our salaried players have been replaced with lesser capable options. I'm amazed the manager has continued with his aim but at the PNE game, for the 1st time, I saw the players not bothering. Their careers to date suggests they should listen to all the advice they get. They are championship players, at best.
The toxicity off the field now bothers me, but a big part of me is saying we should not be swayed. We really might need a good clear out.  And, I must add, for fuck sake  lay off Livermore.  He's been our best player, or thereabouts for probably the last 5 games. Unpopular view? Yes, but fact all the same.
Reply
(01-30-2022, 11:47 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 11:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Yep, totally agree Squid, the anger at times has often been at the lack of direction at the club and it's now become hostile and toxic towards Val, he's come in with a plan, a strategy which at times has worked, others has not but one thing I do know is how hard he works, the hours, the study, the research, he lives away from his family and he's had zero patience from the fan base IMO, we were booiing when we battered Derby and drew 0-0, 1-1 at home to Milwall, 5th game of the season was it, sure they were booed then, it's the fall out from a shit Premiership season and stumbling over the line under Slav and Val has took a lot of the wrap

Where he has failed is his complete one dimensional approach tactically, you would almost love a pint with him just to ask "Why?" From Sunday league to Klop managers have more than one approach, why can't he?

Cuzer

I agree with that, particularly what I've highlighted in bold. He deserves more respect in what is increasingly becoming a cynical and offensive world.

His system has served him so successfully in the past and, if things had just gone a little differently, would have here too, so I can understand him feeling that it would come good if only a few things went his way.

(01-30-2022, 11:41 PM)Squid Wrote: If he'd just made us decent at set pieces it would have helped. If your strikers aren't working, you should at least be trying to get something from corners. It's been something we've lacked since Dawson left.

We looked so dangerous at set pieces early in the season and, for a short while, had scored more goals (10 I think it was) from set pieces than any other club in the division. I don't know why they've gone so badly wrong, but I think it's a shame that he hasn't said anything about it to indicate that he knows they've gone to pot and has been trying to address it.

I think you and your preference for balanced posts would be better suited back on .com. Not nearly controversial or confrontational enough. I bet your Mother in Law even loves you, you nicey nicey twat  Big Grin  Wink .

(That wasn't meant nearly as misogynistic as it probably reads, and was definitely tongue in cheek  Big Grin ).
Reply
I've not bothered to read all 17 pages of this.
However, who wouldn't want to be sacked with still three and a half years left on a contract, I'd be all over it.
Reply
I'm sorry but I just dont have any sympathy for him. Every single manager in the history of the game inherits a team of players. Theres no problem having a strong philosophy on the way you play but you simply have to play to your players strengths and he just isnt doing it.

You have to coach to make players better. You have to play formations that suit those players and you have to man manage your players.

He is failing on all counts.
Reply
(01-31-2022, 08:09 AM)Peachy Wrote: I'm sorry but I just dont have any sympathy for him. Every single manager in the history of the game inherits a team of players. Theres no problem having a strong philosophy on the way you play but you simply have to play to your players strengths and he just isnt doing it.

You have to coach to make players better. You have to play formations that suit those players and you have to man manage your players.

He is failing on all counts.

Exactly, the argument he hasn’t got a perfect squad, the perfect circumstances is just an excuse. Allardyce was slated for managing in far more difficult circumstances and criticised relentlessly by many of the same posters who are now ever so understanding of Val’s awful position… which isn’t awful let’s be honest, he’s in a very good position fail or succeed. 

Allardyce should have said he was undertaking a ‘project’ it would have given far more leeway.
Reply
(01-31-2022, 08:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 08:09 AM)Peachy Wrote: I'm sorry but I just dont have any sympathy for him. Every single manager in the history of the game inherits a team of players. Theres no problem having a strong philosophy on the way you play but you simply have to play to your players strengths and he just isnt doing it.

You have to coach to make players better. You have to play formations that suit those players and you have to man manage your players.

He is failing on all counts.

Exactly, the argument he hasn’t got a perfect squad, the perfect circumstances is just an excuse. Allardyce was slated for managing in far more difficult circumstances and criticised relentlessly by many of the same posters who are now ever so understanding of Val’s awful position… which isn’t awful let’s be honest, he’s in a very good position fail or succeed. 

Allardyce should have said he was undertaking a ‘project’ it would have given far more leeway.

Not sure about this. Those who were most critical of Allardyce are the ones who didn't want Bilic to leave. I don't think anyone in this conversation falls into that camp. I very much wanted Allardyce to succeed and I liked the players and fitness he brought to the club.
Reply
I'm not seeing any huge case for Val's defence. All say his intransigence will be the end of him. I'd suggest there is a possibility that the club have given him a remit (and possibly the time) to change the entire system and to move away from these players. I don't know this, of course. It's just a thought, but Big Sam wasn't overly impressed with this lot either.
Reply
(01-31-2022, 08:33 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not seeing any huge case for Val's defence. All say his intransigence will be the end of him. I'd suggest there is a possibility that the club have given him a remit (and possibly the time) to change the entire system and to move away from these players. I don't know this, of course. It's just a thought, but Big Sam wasn't overly impressed with this lot either.

Allardyce brought in other players to compete in the Prem it was obvious before the season kicked off the squad wasn’t strong enough for that level. The squad was clearly never good enough to stay up without them. Some argued they were, which was a big pile of oss poo. That isn’t the same as managing a good group of players for the Championship. We cannot as a self sufficient club build a Prem squad in the Championship.
Reply
(01-31-2022, 08:09 AM)Peachy Wrote: I'm sorry but I just dont have any sympathy for him. Every single manager in the history of the game inherits a team of players. Theres no problem having a strong philosophy on the way you play but you simply have to play to your players strengths and he just isnt doing it.

You have to coach to make players better. You have to play formations that suit those players and you have to man manage your players.

He is failing on all counts.
This , 99% of our issues are self inflicted from Val himself . I don't need to list them as we all know the routine , he's got himself the sack and nothing else ( hopefully ) .
Reply
Can't say I've had sympathy for any of our recently sacked managers. Arguably all of them should have been disposed of before they were, Val is no different.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)