What formation would you play.
#1
Ideally I would want to play 433.

Problem is I'm not sure I could pick a midfield three from this group of players.
Reply
#2
Depends on if he’s actually injured or not but I’d be having Snodgrass straight back in a 3 personally. He can take a set piece for one
Reply
#3
I have always favoured a back 3, since I can remember as I think it stops you getting stuck with a back 6 and makes you harder to pin back.

However you need to be brave in posession and good wide players and centre backs.

I prefer a 3412 with 2 out and out 18 yard box forwards, 2 attacking wingbacks and a floating number 10.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
The system debate is a moot point. Loads on here slamming Val for playing with a back 3 and in the next sentence professing their love for Chris Wilder, who is basically famous for playing a back 3.

Agree with Lurker that a back three with two deeper midfielders with a good range of pass, high wing backs and strikers is effective. One of our big issues the last few months is that our wing backs are consistently 30 yards too deep.

I'd be reluctant to play a midfield 3 if we're not going to bring Sawyers back to the club.
Reply
#5
4-3-3

The thing is, in that midfield 3 I'd have Livermore centrally but as a sort of central half back effectively making a back 3 when out of possession. One of the biggest issues with us is the fact that we're too easily crowded out of midfield when in possession and having the central defender step up gives the two in front license to push up, also lets that man cover the wider centre halves when they roam up on the overlap.
Reply
#6
4 - 4 - 2
Two banks of 4 
With two up top.
Alex Ferguson was a master at it.
Reply
#7
(01-30-2022, 03:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have always favoured a back 3, since I can remember as I think it stops you getting stuck with a back 6 and makes you harder to pin back.

However you need to be brave in posession and good wide players and centre backs.

I prefer a 3412 with 2 out and out 18 yard box forwards, 2 attacking wingbacks and a floating number 10.

Except when played properly by really good players, a back three always seems to make good players look average. When it's a true three they are expected to do things they don't usually do, cover more ground and generally get stretched. When (as usual) it degenerates to a back five, the centre backs get in each other's way, don't pick up the right players to mark and end up looking stupid. If your defence isn't good enough to play as a conventional back four, adding another not good enough player won't make it better. If you aren't using proper attacking players as wing backs then you aren't getting any benefit form the three CBs. If your CBs are expected to join in the attacks, then you don't want Clarke or Kipre getting up there when you could have a Pereira-type there instead. It's a fashion which comes and goes but never stays.

(01-30-2022, 03:32 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: 4 - 4 - 2
Two banks of 4 
With two up top.
Alex Ferguson was a master at it.

I've always liked this. The 70s style 433 needed a truly influential midfielder (Bryan Robson) and an out and out winger who didn't do much tracking back (Willie Johnston). A well organised 442 makes better use of players with less flair. Which is what most of them are.
Reply
#8
[Image: Comdp32Q_400x400.jpg]
Reply
#9
SJ
O’Shea Ajayi Barley Townsend

TGH Livermore

Phillips Robinson. Diangana

DK

I know I’ve dropped Grant our leading scorer but he offers very little in open play and has one trick. Maybe he can come on in the 60th minute…

And Birdman will put his fist through the screen at O’Shea at RB as he is our best centre half. He can also actually play RB and I’d rather these than Fulromg playing.

Maybe Diang right side and Grant left side but there’s not much else I’d change without new players.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#10
(01-30-2022, 04:18 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 03:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have always favoured a back 3, since I can remember as I think it stops you getting stuck with a back 6 and makes you harder to pin back.

However you need to be brave in posession and good wide players and centre backs.

I prefer a 3412 with 2 out and out 18 yard box forwards, 2 attacking wingbacks and a floating number 10.

Except when played properly by really good players, a back three always seems to make good players look average. When it's a true three they are expected to do things they don't usually do, cover more ground and generally get stretched. When (as usual) it degenerates to a back five, the centre backs get in each other's way, don't pick up the right players to mark and end up looking stupid. If your defence isn't good enough to play as a conventional back four, adding another not good enough player won't make it better. If you aren't using proper attacking players as wing backs then you aren't getting any benefit form the three CBs. If your CBs are expected to join in the attacks, then you don't want Clarke or Kipre getting up there when you could have a Pereira-type there instead. It's a fashion which comes and goes but never stays.

Yeh I agree. It relies on very able wider defenders. Thats why more defensive, old fashioned or older, fullbacks are perfect. The likes of ceasar azpulaceta (spl) is perfect for the job. Then you rely on lightning quick and fit wide players. In the Liverpool model, they should know how to defend at some level, but their pace and ability to recover is most important. 

I think O'Shea and Townsend could do this job for us, its the wingback positions we are desperately short in. Contrary to public opinion, in this system, Mowatt and Livermore both do the job. As they shouldn't be expected to do anything else. Thats the wide players and number 10s job.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)