Imminent Sacking?
#71
(01-27-2022, 12:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:26 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 11:39 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 11:36 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 11:30 AM)Peachy Wrote: Can't believe im saying this but I actually wouldn't mind old spud nose until the end of the season. 

He'd at least have the players playing where they should and keep things fairly simple whilst bringing a measure of calm to preceedings.

His fishy past might not go down to well though with some. Fwiw I think he'd take it if offered.

I think he's underrated

Same here.   His track record is decent and he’s handled a lot of issues with great dignity.  He knows the division well.  He’s probably the most interesting obvious and available candidate.

ITK'ers at The Seals say he sorted a load of shit behind the scenes, and was rated by them.

Villa were a mess when he arrived and he did well there... HOWEVER he spent a lot of money, mostly on poor players.

If we did appoint Bruce, I think we'd finish in the top 6.  However I think we'd only be further postponing the absolute mess we are heading rapidly into at some point in the next 2-3 years.

I’m not so sure about that.  Bruce knows what it takes, has probably very few jobs left in him, and has a chance to build some stability.
Reply
#72
(01-27-2022, 12:35 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I did think Bilic was useless, in terms of developing a stable, sustainable club structure and a repeatable model. What you're talking about is short term success as a marker of a successful premiership. I do not, and haven't not for a while, wanted that. The desire for promotion go the premier league is a cancer within the game. Not viewing being a self sufficient, well run club with an identity which goes beyond promotions and trophies as success is what is pulling us down as a fan base and a club. IMO of course.

We actually are of a similar view there, just from different angles. My desire for the promotion is to guarantee the longer term possible survival of the club, I agree it is a cancer, but realistically we will more than likely end up back as mid table championship also rans without a promotion this or next season. However, with football finances being so bad of late, I would have doubts about our owners (whoever they are), sustaining us. I'd happily take a nice happy club that puts in some performances you can enjoy in pretty much any division. I've never enjoyed us in the Premiership, but I get that the club needs the finances to do anything.

I honestly cannot see how Six has created a sustainable future for the club structure either though. You don't do that by pissing off all the players as it appears he has done.

heck I used to enjoy going to matches more when we were proper dogshit, we had no illusions of grandeur back then and mostly just accepted each game... Sadly, football has changed so much since those dark days... And now money is all that matters to the clubs, I do not want to see us end up like Blues...or Derby etc.... I can see us going that way without the promotion, and that is why I do want it, even though i know the Prem season will be utterly soul destroying and shit.
Reply
#73
(01-27-2022, 12:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:35 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I did think Bilic was useless, in terms of developing a stable, sustainable club structure and a repeatable model. What you're talking about is short term success as a marker of a successful premiership. I do not, and haven't not for a while, wanted that. The desire for promotion go the premier league is a cancer within the game. Not viewing being a self sufficient, well run club with an identity which goes beyond promotions and trophies as success is what is pulling us down as a fan base and a club. IMO of course.

We actually are of a similar view there, just from different angles. My desire for the promotion is to guarantee the longer term possible survival of the club, I agree it is a cancer, but realistically we will more than likely end up back as mid table championship also rans without a promotion this or next season. However, with football finances being so bad of late, I would have doubts about our owners (whoever they are), sustaining us. I'd happily take a nice happy club that puts in some performances you can enjoy in pretty much any division. I've never enjoyed us in the Premiership, but I get that the club needs the finances to do anything.

I honestly cannot see how Six has created a sustainable future for the club structure either though. You don't do that by pissing off all the players as it appears he has done.

heck I used to enjoy going to matches more when we were proper dogshit, we had no illusions of grandeur back then and mostly just accepted each game... Sadly, football has changed so much since those dark days... And now money is all that matters to the clubs, I do not want to see us end up like Blues...or Derby etc.... I can see us going that way without the promotion, and that is why I do want it, even though i know the Prem season will be utterly soul destroying and shit.

Agree with much of that, bud. But I don't think we are in any financial danger if we don't go back up as we have lots of contacts that are up within the parachute period. I also don't think upsetting this squad is a bad thing. In the short term, yes. But not in the long run.

I want to see us remodel ourselves. Have a clear identity, philosophy and structure, ala the Dashworth days, and I think Val could head that up. But sadly I think short termism will win.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#74
I presume there will be a Presser tomorrow with Val, before the Millwall game. I think if he hasn't gone today then he ain't going at the moment.
Reply
#75
(01-27-2022, 12:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:35 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I did think Bilic was useless, in terms of developing a stable, sustainable club structure and a repeatable model. What you're talking about is short term success as a marker of a successful premiership. I do not, and haven't not for a while, wanted that. The desire for promotion go the premier league is a cancer within the game. Not viewing being a self sufficient, well run club with an identity which goes beyond promotions and trophies as success is what is pulling us down as a fan base and a club. IMO of course.

We actually are of a similar view there, just from different angles. My desire for the promotion is to guarantee the longer term possible survival of the club, I agree it is a cancer, but realistically we will more than likely end up back as mid table championship also rans without a promotion this or next season. However, with football finances being so bad of late, I would have doubts about our owners (whoever they are), sustaining us. I'd happily take a nice happy club that puts in some performances you can enjoy in pretty much any division. I've never enjoyed us in the Premiership, but I get that the club needs the finances to do anything.

I honestly cannot see how Six has created a sustainable future for the club structure either though. You don't do that by pissing off all the players as it appears he has done.

heck I used to enjoy going to matches more when we were proper dogshit, we had no illusions of grandeur back then and mostly just accepted each game... Sadly, football has changed so much since those dark days... And now money is all that matters to the clubs, I do not want to see us end up like Blues...or Derby etc.... I can see us going that way without the promotion, and that is why I do want it, even though i know the Prem season will be utterly soul destroying and shit.

Agree with much of that, bud. But I don't think we are in any financial danger if we don't go back up as we have lots of contacts that are up within the parachute period. I also don't think upsetting this squad is a bad thing. In the short term, yes. But not in the long run.

I want to see us remodel ourselves. Have a clear identity, philosophy and structure, ala the Dashworth days, and I think Val could head that up. But sadly I think short termism will win.

Agree, except that Six has shown me that he is not the man to do it. The quality of players he bought in has not been good.

Dashworth era spoiled us Big Grin, but was probably the closest we got to having some form of long term plan. Even then we went through a good amount of managers.
Reply
#76
(01-27-2022, 12:35 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:29 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: When considering the idiocy of many of fans, the only way to please them is short term success, and to constantly shuffle the pack to achieve that. Its something I cannot stand so will just sit back and not get as emotional about stuff, and laugh my tits off as we bundle ourselves from one short term journeyman/firefighter to the next whist hoping to remain relevant.

I keep reading people saying they want to see a young manager who can unite the fans. Like Darren Moore, who got binned off as soon as things went sour and we were not going up? Like Bilic who was useless? Its all bollocks frankly. We wither need to stick with Val or another like him with a fixed philosophy and just ignore the demented lot. Or accept we need to bounce around short term fixes.

What a palaver, eh?

Loving the critique of some fans, and then adding in that Bilic was useless. What price a scraped over the line lucky to have got there and all the other rhetorical bollox used to describe his promotion, now eh? Promotion is the only way to ensure the club has a longer term survival strategy, so whatever you thought of Bilic he got us to the point where we have the needed parachutes. FFS I hated Pulis, but I could accept he was keeping us up.

I did think Bilic was useless, in terms of developing a stable, sustainable club structure and a repeatable model. What you're talking about is short term success as a marker of a successful premiership. I do not, and have not for a while, believe that. The desire for promotion to the premier league is a cancer within a dying game. Not viewing being a self sufficient, well run club with an identity which goes beyond promotions and trophies as success is what is pulling us down as a fan base and a club. IMO of course.

You’re not taking into account all of our relative success is thanks to successive managers getting us promotion. The money allowed us to compete, it allowed us to sign players of the calibre we needed abs it enabled us to build an academy that took around a decade to find its feet and now the rug has been taken from under us even on this as we lose players to Villa due to money. What you want to happen is admirable but it’s not realistic, we have two rich clubs with ambitious owners on our doorstep and they are going to hoover up all the local talent unless we can compete via TV money which in turn is linked directly to short term success through promotion. The same with scouting networks and a sustainable business model. They need constant investment and the owners will not pay for it, the club will have to. Where’s the money coming from, if it’s not short term success and Sky / TV money? 

Whether you like it or not the long term plan is completely beholden to short term success and Val is failing to achieve that currently, with a far better squad than we will be able to put together as we die a death of a thousand cuts as we cut our cloth according to our inevitable dwindling income as TV money reduces hugely and fans stop attending as Val ball sucks the life out of fans even further.

TV income is the constant in our relative success, not Ashworth, not RDM, Mowbray, Hodgson, not players, not even JP… it’s why we were successful, without it we are fucked! Heck Sir Gary even benefitted from the Egioigh (spelling) money, which was thanks to Sky’s investment that kick stated our renaissance. Our owners have shown no sign of investing so the long term business model has no basis in reality without promotion.
Reply
#77
(01-27-2022, 01:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You’re not taking into account all of our relative success is thanks to successive managers getting us promotion. The money allowed us to compete, it allowed us to sign players of the calibre we needed abs it enabled us to build an academy that took around a decade to find its feet and now the rug has been taken from under us even on this as we lose players to Villa due to money. What you want to happen is admirable but it’s not realistic, we have two rich clubs with ambitious owners on our doorstep and they are going to hoover up all the local talent unless we can compete via TV money which in turn is linked directly to short term success through promotion. The same with scouting networks and a sustainable business model. They need constant investment and the owners will not pay for it, the club will have to. Where’s the money coming from, if it’s not short term success and Sky / TV money? 

Whether you like it or not the long term plan is completely beholden to short term success and Val is failing to achieve that currently, with a far better squad than we will be able to put together as we die a death of a thousand cuts as we cut our cloth according to our inevitable dwindling income as TV money reduces hugely and fans stop attending as Val ball sucks the life out of fans even further.

TV income is the constant in our relative success, not Ashworth, not RDM, Mowbray, Hodgson, not players, not even JP… it’s why we were successful, without it we are fucked! Heck Sir Gary even benefitted from the Egioigh (spelling) money, which was thanks to Sky’s investment that kick stated our renaissance. Our owners have shown no sign of investing so the long term business model has no basis in reality without promotion.

I think you're half right Derek, initial success under Dan Ashworth allowed us to build a fantastic infrastructure, under the ownership of a motivated Jeremy Peace. We invested sensibly and continued to develop younger players who were assets to us for 10 years (Brunt, Morrison, Jonas, etc.). The point it changed was when Peace wanted to sell up. His asset was only valuable to him as a Premier League club. So he changed course. We started signing older, stop gap players to protect the clubs EPL status. That fear of relegation led to 4 years of malaise, and as you quite rightly point out we have suffered "death by a million cuts" ever since. Once we finally succumbed to relegation when our squads legs fell off under Pulis, we then have jumped from one short term solution to the next, desperately clinging on to the coat tails of the EPL financial bandwagon. 

We have the infrastructure, we are solid financially. Its time to cut ties, and let go of the EPL gravy train. Restore some pride in our approach and become a club others aspired to be once more.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#78
(01-27-2022, 01:26 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 01:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You’re not taking into account all of our relative success is thanks to successive managers getting us promotion. The money allowed us to compete, it allowed us to sign players of the calibre we needed abs it enabled us to build an academy that took around a decade to find its feet and now the rug has been taken from under us even on this as we lose players to Villa due to money. What you want to happen is admirable but it’s not realistic, we have two rich clubs with ambitious owners on our doorstep and they are going to hoover up all the local talent unless we can compete via TV money which in turn is linked directly to short term success through promotion. The same with scouting networks and a sustainable business model. They need constant investment and the owners will not pay for it, the club will have to. Where’s the money coming from, if it’s not short term success and Sky / TV money? 

Whether you like it or not the long term plan is completely beholden to short term success and Val is failing to achieve that currently, with a far better squad than we will be able to put together as we die a death of a thousand cuts as we cut our cloth according to our inevitable dwindling income as TV money reduces hugely and fans stop attending as Val ball sucks the life out of fans even further.

TV income is the constant in our relative success, not Ashworth, not RDM, Mowbray, Hodgson, not players, not even JP… it’s why we were successful, without it we are fucked! Heck Sir Gary even benefitted from the Egioigh (spelling) money, which was thanks to Sky’s investment that kick stated our renaissance. Our owners have shown no sign of investing so the long term business model has no basis in reality without promotion.

I think you're half right Derek, initial success under Dan Ashworth allowed us to build a fantastic infrastructure, under the ownership of a motivated Jeremy Peace. We invested sensibly and continued to develop younger players who were assets to us for 10 years (Brunt, Morrison, Jonas, etc.). The point it changed was when Peace wanted to sell up. His asset was only valuable to him as a Premier League club. So he changed course. We started signing older, stop gap players to protect the clubs EPL status. That d=fear of relegation led to 4 years of malaise, and as you quite right point out we have suffered "death by a million cuts" ever since. Once we finally succumbed to relegation when our squads legs fell off under Pulis we then have jumped from one short term solution to the next, desperately clinging on to the coat tails of the EPL financial bandwagon. 

We have the infrastructure, we are solid financially. Its time to cut ties, and let go of the EPL gravy train. Restore some pride in our approach and become a club others aspired to be once more.

Cut ties with the EPL and our trousers fall down and we make a complete arse of ourselves.
Reply
#79
(01-27-2022, 10:41 AM)SophLad Wrote: What's Athers saying about it?

Ven ze seagules follow ze trawler.....
Reply
#80
(01-27-2022, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Cut ties with the EPL and our trousers fall down and we make a complete arse of ourselves.

We need to make sure we get that arse toned and get we sack and crack waxed then, cause it needs to happen!
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)