If a dividend is paid then it’s a total farce and the club are effectively writing off the debt.
To understand what I mean, look at it this way
To make it simpler, ignore company names
So, the club made a loan to Peace with no repayment date
Peace seeks up and the loan is passed to Lai
So... Lai should pay back the money to the club
If a dividend is made, the club give money to Lai as a gift.
Lai then says thank you for your gift, and hands it back and says here’s the money I owed you.
So the club (partly owned by the minority shareholders also receive a gift (but they can say no thanks) but the club loses out as it’s bank balance is the same (if the minority shareholders don’t accept their dividends) but the loan (debtor) in the balance sheet has gone. So the club is worth less by the amount of the debt which has now been repaid. So the net assets of the club will be reduced.
What a shambles and I can see why s4A don’t want a dividend.
And it’s not a simple inter-company loan as the loan went to a company which doesn’t own all the shares in the club. It went to a company wholly owned by Peace and Peace used this company to acquire the shares in the club. Peace then sold this company to Lai. So Lai owns this company which holds his majority shares in the club.
Making a dividend is clearly allowable but it wouldn’t be a moral thing to do as it’s effectively writing off the loan and Lais company should pay the club the loan amount plus interest without a dividend being issued.
Or...
You go out with a mate and you have £30 in your pocket and your mate has no cash on him.
Your mate asks to borrow £10 and you give it him.
Your mate then asks if you can give him another £10, as a gift for his birthday and you hand that over.
Your mate then hands you a tenner back and says here’s the £10 I owed you.
So now you have £20 in your pocket and your mate has £10 and he no longer owes you any money.
Motto of the story is don’t have Lai as a mate if a dividend is issued