Is our problem purely the front line decision making?
#11
I said elsewhere a few times. I'm not sure whether it's training issues or simply confidence, the players body language in most games is shocking for me. Yet was different against Brighton.

I genuinely think there is a massive crisis of confidence among the squad, and I really can't see Val as the type who can fix that.
Reply
#12
(01-19-2022, 12:08 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 11:18 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 11:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: You have to look at the system as a whole for me.
We have decent forwards, who have all scored goals at this level. Grant, Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Hugill. Yet no combination seems to work.
We have decent crossers, Reach, Townsend, Phillips, Furlong, yet no combination seems to work.
We have decent set piece specialists, Mowatt, Reach, TGH, Phillips, Furlong (throws anyway) even Snodgrass taking, Bartley, Kipre, Clarke, Ajayi, Hugill on the receiving end, yet even this no longer pays dividends.

There's just too much that's not working to simply blame the players. IMO
But maybe then Bob you have to look at the incredible injuries/suspensions we've had?
I'm inclined to think it's the system is fine, and you can say what you like but some of the crossing by our decent crossers at QPR were pub league standard. Reach was particularly woeful. Maybe we need players who can adapt to this?
It's not just QPR though, it goes way back and is not improving so, my question is, what are we doing in training to make decent forwards, decent crossers and decent set piece specialists, so bloody awful.
This gets lost a bit in the "players just aren't good enough" rhetoric. Val is coaching them, Val is setting up the training sessions, Val is man-managing them, yet there is no sign of improvement. If that's not a key part of his job, and therefore something he should be judged on, what is?

Players don't 'un-learn' ability though. If they could cross a ball last season, they should be able to do so now. Same as passing. If they can pass, they can pass. Not being able to do a basic skill all of a sudden can't be down to a manager. Whatever anyone thinks, Val or any manager wouldn't want or ask footballers to be worse!
Reply
#13
Decision making from the bench to the attacking players is largely a mess, there is no composure anywhere in the team. That may be down to tactics and orders from the manager, or it may be that players that have shown they can actually do it much better in previous seasons suddenly have lost the ability....

I totally disagree that we're dominating games, in my mind to do that you have to look like you might score, and we definitely do not look like we will score, hence all our hopes on Dike.

Where is the instruction coming from to just cross it without caring if anyone is able to get to it, or worse to cross it but to not have anyone gambling on getting there? That can't just be the players making the same decision over and over again.
Reply
#14
(01-19-2022, 12:11 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I said elsewhere a few times. I'm not sure whether it's training issues or simply confidence, the players bodyblanguage in most games is shocking for me. Yet was different against Brighton.

I genuinely think there is a massive crisis of confidence among the squad, and I really can't see Val as the type who can fix that.

The pressure was off and it demonstrates they can't handle the pressure, same with the promotion run-in.  Almost bottled it. 

We have Val to thank for our promotion and earning us £100m  Big Grin
Reply
#15
Our problem is simple, we have consolidated our defence at the the expense of our attack. 
Tactically we are looking to to pinch a goal and defend - defend - defend. Great for the fans not.
We have an excellent defensive record, but linked with a pathetic goals for total 
Val needs to get the balance right, even a bit of gung ho is called for at times. Maybe DD can help, but he will need quality service - not a punt upfield from a CH.
Reply
#16
It's gone in three quite distinct stages for me.

Start of the season with a new style teams didn't know how to deal with us, we won the ball high up the pitch and from there decision making is easy. Simply give it to the man in space as more often than not we had the numerical advantage.

Then as teams began to figure us out a bit more, we've had more of the ball and the onus has been on us to move teams around. We aren't good enough to do this consistently well. A lot of our play is in front of the defence, we end up trying to be too clever and we play into blind alleys. Can't believe I'm saying this but I really think a Sawyers or someone with a better range of pass in the middle would help us as we try and move defences around. We're so easy to defend against at the moment.

The last 5-6 games we look totally bereft of any confidence. Players are swinging crosses in not thinking they'll find an Albion player, there's no belief we'll win a ball from a set piece. Head down, nothing football.

Start winning some games, confidence will come back and that will lead to better decision making, better performances and hopefully better results. We don't need a complete reset, just do the basics properly.
Reply
#17
(01-19-2022, 01:23 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Our problem is simple, we have consolidated our defence at the the expense of our attack. 
Tactically we are looking to to pinch a goal and defend - defend - defend. Great for the fans not.
We have an excellent defensive record, but linked with a pathetic goals for total 
Val needs to get the balance right, even a bit of gung ho is called for at times. Maybe DD can help, but he will need quality service - not a punt upfield from a CH.

I think that is as far away as it is possible to be.  In no way is val a defensive manager which is what makes this so frustrating.  Our players play high up the pitrch and are encourage to attack hense why the defenders and golalkeepers make so many last ditch clearances and tackles.  As an example.  Ajay scored from open play in the last minute against peterborough from a tap in and when hugil missed in the last minute against Foreest it was from 2 defenders in the box when we were down to 10 men.  I think any manager that manages to have a really tight defence whilst still creating enough opportunities to win most games has a fairly good system and is being let down by players either being shit or deciding that the system they are being asked to play is too hard!
Reply
#18
(01-19-2022, 12:49 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 12:08 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 11:18 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 11:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: You have to look at the system as a whole for me.
We have decent forwards, who have all scored goals at this level. Grant, Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Hugill. Yet no combination seems to work.
We have decent crossers, Reach, Townsend, Phillips, Furlong, yet no combination seems to work.
We have decent set piece specialists, Mowatt, Reach, TGH, Phillips, Furlong (throws anyway) even Snodgrass taking, Bartley, Kipre, Clarke, Ajayi, Hugill on the receiving end, yet even this no longer pays dividends.

There's just too much that's not working to simply blame the players. IMO
But maybe then Bob you have to look at the incredible injuries/suspensions we've had?
I'm inclined to think it's the system is fine, and you can say what you like but some of the crossing by our decent crossers at QPR were pub league standard. Reach was particularly woeful. Maybe we need players who can adapt to this?
It's not just QPR though, it goes way back and is not improving so, my question is, what are we doing in training to make decent forwards, decent crossers and decent set piece specialists, so bloody awful.
This gets lost a bit in the "players just aren't good enough" rhetoric. Val is coaching them, Val is setting up the training sessions, Val is man-managing them, yet there is no sign of improvement. If that's not a key part of his job, and therefore something he should be judged on, what is?

Players don't 'un-learn' ability though. If they could cross a ball last season, they should be able to do so now. Same as passing. If they can pass, they can pass. Not being able to do a basic skill all of a sudden can't be down to a manager. Whatever anyone thinks, Val or any manager wouldn't want or ask footballers to be worse!
Maybe they are used to having more options when facing a cross and lack of said options is making the job that much more difficult?
Maybe the attackers are better suited to ball to feet and are not equipped to be the only man in the box when a high cross comes in?

These should be issues that Val is seeing, understanding and addressing in training or adjusting his tactics to suit. I see no evidence of either. In fact, I can't think of a single attacking area where what we have done on the training pitch is clear. Same goes for set pieces. We just do the same things over and over again and get the same results.
Reply
#19
Some good posts on here. It's an intelligent discussion about the football rather than personalities. More of this I say.

I think Remi has come up with the best point of compromising attack for the defence. It's probably why we have two guys in the box as the final ball is delivered, who are hopelessly outnumbered.

A box to box guy who makes those late runs is what's needed, or a change of mindset from current midfielders. Oh for Gallagher this season.
Reply
#20
(01-19-2022, 01:23 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Our problem is simple, we have consolidated our defence at the the expense of our attack. 
Tactically we are looking to to pinch a goal and defend - defend - defend. Great for the fans not.
We have an excellent defensive record, but linked with a pathetic goals for total 
Val needs to get the balance right, even a bit of gung ho is called for at times. Maybe DD can help, but he will need quality service - not a punt upfield from a CH.

We're not defensive at all. Setting aside discussing their quality, if we were set out defensively, we wouldn't have the second highest average number of goal attempts per game (15.8). It would take about 4 games to have that many goal attempts under Pulis!

Our only major problems are the quality of our play in the final third and the decision-making of the players, plus our attacking set pieces have gone to pot.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: