Jake
#21
On one hand we need to rebuild because these players have let down numerous managers and aren't good enough and on the other hand the captain of all of those sides isn't seen as one of the problems. Some people attack Val at every opportunity but some defend him with everything also
Reply
#22
(01-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.
Reply
#23
He seems better suited in defence because he's a defensively orientated anchor man type of player. He was played by Southgate to simply be in a position to accept the ball back from any player getting closed down while trying to work the ball forward or to help break down any attack if we lost it. Not every player needs to be cavalier.
Reply
#24
I have mixed feelings about Livermire.

Not as good as the player he was brought into replace... Claudio Yacob. Not really good enough at Premiership level.

Overall does a good job in the championship, very good in the Bilic season and has been one of our better players this season.

Operates better in a 433 system,. Does he have the legs to play 90 minutes every game  not sure he does.
Reply
#25
Duffers Wrote:
Jacobthebaggie Wrote:Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

He's played quite well in the last few matches he's played in. Cardiff in particular.He does that scrappy job in the middle, breaking up play etc that never gets any credit. While I get much of the criticism for not creating anything, I think he mostly suffers from there not being an extra body just ahead of him. I also think he would be better suited to playing in the back 3 in this system as we don't appear to need 3 out and out centre backs.
Reply
#26
(01-19-2022, 10:43 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have mixed feelings about Livermire.

Not as good as the player he was brought into replace... Claudio Yacob. Not really good enough at Premiership level.

Overall does a good job in the championship, very good in the Bilic season and has been one of our better players this season.

Operates better in a 433 system,. Does he have the legs to play 90 minutes every game  not sure he does.

Think you're being generous there Shab... he was average at best in the Slav season. He had a decent run of form in the build up to Xmas, but was otherwise a passenger and a key reason as to why our midfield was so often overrun.

Jake hasn't been able to play in a 2 for the last 5 years, and for all his faults Fat Sam was the only manager to realise and implement this. 

He may be a decent bloke off the pitch and be a strong personality in the dressing room, but he is categorically not good enough to play the role he does and doesn't offer enough in determination, leadership or will power to overcome his physical limitations. I hope to hell we don't extend his deal as he is one of the group we should have moved on some time ago.
Reply
#27
Year extension for Livermore or not, if he’s still our starting midfielder at the start of next season there’s something seriously wrong with our club. Happy to keep him around but he cannot be starting every week anymore. Just not good enough.
Reply
#28
(01-19-2022, 10:17 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:14 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:11 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 09:58 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Another so called shit player that got called up for England. Thanks for staying Jake. Some can see he does a decent job in the role he's asked to play.

Last England cap was a friendly in 2017 so not sure how relevant that is to how he’s been performing recently.

So he wasn't being spacegoated back then, everyone said he was great and deserved his call up. I think not hence the relevance of the same old bollox. Think SJ for similar

He was doing ok back then. It’s the last couple of years he’s really deteriorated.

Or maybe things have deteriorated around him?

(01-19-2022, 09:32 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Activated a contract extension.


Going nowhere

The contract was agreed and it's appearances that have triggered the one-yr extension.  He hasn't selected himself so nowt to do with him.

It does however seem less likely that we'll sign a replacement such as Yokuslu now.
Reply
#29
Ahh well Six loves him so I think he'd have wanted him for the rebuild anyway.
Reply
#30
Dont rate him, would say he is a scapegoat just don't see what he contributes. He must give us something somewhere as he keeps getting picked?

To be fair I think he would be better in a 5 man midfield
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: