Man Utd/The Albion
#31
(01-17-2022, 04:02 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 03:58 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 03:43 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 03:21 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Hate to point out the bleeding obvious, but their level of failure is still realms above ours. So they may not make Champs League, if we don't get promotion we may end up like Blues.. Hardly the same thing at all. We don't have the luxury of time that they have.

I did point that out in the OP. But I disagree with the fact that we may end up like Blues. We may see a steady, managed decline, and fall to our natural level as Roland repeated alluded too.

However it is more likely that we consistently challenge for promotion. Especially if we get to a point where the academy is sustaining the majority of our squad and all investment is in saleable assets at what ever level we are operating. 

When you build a house you get the foundations right, even if you have to live in a caravan for a while.

But, in this case, it really is the level of difference that matters.

Well I hope you are right, personally I've not seen enough from the academy to suggest it would sustain us in the coming seasons, let alone keep us challenging for promotion. I don't think we'll ever have the right foundations whilst Lai (whoever) owns us, hence why I see us doing a Blues if we don't go up this year, again I really hope I am wrong.

For it to work you need one player breaking into the 18 every year, 1 big signing every year, and a big-ish sale every 2.  That is more than doable in the long run. 

The next window will be the major overhaul, and will be funded by the parachute payment advantage.

Oh that's all that's needed. Pretty sure Blues et al all thought the same, then the big signings dried up, and they were reliant on an honourable Academy player pretty much saving them.

There is no parachute payment advantage, as we'll have Norwich and Burnley and maybe even those poor Geordies coming down. Even Watford coming down would be a challenge to us. So that realistically puts us fighting for 4th...at best. Heck we can't even fight for that when we have had the advantage.
Reply
#32
(01-17-2022, 04:08 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Oh that's all that's needed. Pretty sure Blues et al all thought the same, then the big signings dried up, and they were reliant on an honourable Academy player pretty much saving them.

There is no parachute payment advantage, as we'll have Norwich and Burnley and maybe even those poor Geordies coming down. Even Watford coming down would be a challenge to us. So that realistically puts us fighting for 4th...at best. Heck we can't even fight for that when we have had the advantage.

No mate, Blues came down with crippling debt and were a shit show. Like their neighbours in Whitton.

When you break things down in terms of what we need, its not beyond the realms of possibility. The last few years have seen promising players leave with ageing squad fillers brought in. That can stop. 1 decent sized sale of an asset every 2 years. We have been notorious for not selling at teh right time as we have always operated on a low turnover model which led to an aged squad (GMac, Jonas, Brunt, Morrison etc) and have failed to capitalise on saleable assets such as Saido, Evans etc.

If the model is changed, the requirements are not excessive, and we are lucky enough to have one of the best infrastructures outside the top 10 clubs. One which is highly thought of across the country, and is why our young players have been regularly pinched. We now need to change the culture so we reap the rewards of the work Roland put in to build the infrastructure before abandoning the use of it in favour of short term desperation.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
baggy1 Wrote:That's a new one on me about Duncan Edwards from us of all clubs. Definitely not been sung since I have been going up so nearly 45 years - any of the old boys remember us singing an anti Duncan Edwards song. As a Dudley lad we were brought up to be very proud of Edwards with his caps and medals on show in the old leisure centre - I spend what seemed ages staring at them after swimming lessons as a kid.

True. I've been going since the late 60's and have never heard this.  I really can't imagine anyone singing that on the Brummie. Duncan Edwards is revered in most of the Black Country, and in return many Man Utd supporters (the proper ones, not the glory hunters), make a pilgrimage to see the stained glass window in St. Francis church and the hologram on his headstone. They are welcomed. I'd be both amazed and disappointed if this was ever true.
Reply
#34
(01-17-2022, 07:37 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:That's a new one on me about Duncan Edwards from us of all clubs. Definitely not been sung since I have been going up so nearly 45 years - any of the old boys remember us singing an anti Duncan Edwards song. As a Dudley lad we were brought up to be very proud of Edwards with his caps and medals on show in the old leisure centre - I spend what seemed ages staring at them after swimming lessons as a kid.

True. I've been going since the late 60's and have never heard this.  I really can't imagine anyone singing that on the Brummie. Duncan Edwards is revered in most of the Black Country, and in return many Man Utd supporters (the proper ones, not the glory hunters), make a pilgrimage to see the stained glass window in St. Francis church and the hologram on his headstone. They are welcomed. I'd be both amazed and disappointed if this was ever true.

Well, as my lunchtime research dug up the first reference to this happening was in an American publication in 2009 and even United fans think it's bollocks.

So I think it's complete horseshit and the person who said it should apologise.
Reply
#35
(01-17-2022, 03:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: That's a new one on me about Duncan Edwards from us of all clubs. Definitely not been sung since I have been going up so nearly 45 years - any of the old boys remember us singing an anti Duncan Edwards song. As a Dudley lad we were brought up to be very proud of Edwards with his caps and medals on show in the old leisure centre - I spend what seemed ages staring at them after swimming lessons as a kid.

I'd be surprised if that was genuine but you never know with football fans. 

No doubt next time we visit OT some of our idiots will be singing the dambusters theme.  Braindead.   One of the reasons I don't enjoy going as much anymore.

(01-17-2022, 03:58 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 03:43 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 03:21 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Hate to point out the bleeding obvious, but their level of failure is still realms above ours. So they may not make Champs League, if we don't get promotion we may end up like Blues.. Hardly the same thing at all. We don't have the luxury of time that they have.

I did point that out in the OP. But I disagree with the fact that we may end up like Blues. We may see a steady, managed decline, and fall to our natural level as Roland repeated alluded too.

However it is more likely that we consistently challenge for promotion. Especially if we get to a point where the academy is sustaining the majority of our squad and all investment is in saleable assets at what ever level we are operating. 

When you build a house you get the foundations right, even if you have to live in a caravan for a while.

But, in this case, it really is the level of difference that matters.

Well I hope you are right, personally I've not seen enough from the academy to suggest it would sustain us in the coming seasons, let alone keep us challenging for promotion. I don't think we'll ever have the right foundations whilst Lai (whoever) owns us, hence why I see us doing a Blues if we don't go up this year, again I really hope I am wrong.

We are in a far better position than the Blues.  For one thing, our ground isn't falling down.
Reply
#36
(01-17-2022, 07:43 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 07:37 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:That's a new one on me about Duncan Edwards from us of all clubs. Definitely not been sung since I have been going up so nearly 45 years - any of the old boys remember us singing an anti Duncan Edwards song. As a Dudley lad we were brought up to be very proud of Edwards with his caps and medals on show in the old leisure centre - I spend what seemed ages staring at them after swimming lessons as a kid.

True. I've been going since the late 60's and have never heard this.  I really can't imagine anyone singing that on the Brummie. Duncan Edwards is revered in most of the Black Country, and in return many Man Utd supporters (the proper ones, not the glory hunters), make a pilgrimage to see the stained glass window in St. Francis church and the hologram on his headstone. They are welcomed. I'd be both amazed and disappointed if this was ever true.

Well, as my lunchtime research dug up the first reference to this happening was in an American publication in 2009 and even United fans think it's bollocks.

So I think it's complete horseshit and the person who said it should apologise.

Just asked my MUFC STH father-in-law about it and he has confirmed it is total bollox. He'd seen the rumour before, but it is entirely untrue. Laughed at the M-U-N-I-C-H spelling thing -  Borin' baggie and Old Stroller and whoever else said it is horseshit - you are right.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: